Jimmy Pecci's Taste Of Italy

1201 Sycamore Ave, Tinton Falls
(732) 542-2700

Recent Reviews

Glen Genovese

Ahh quality lost years ago

Kellie McCann

We used them for a catered event. The food was wonderful, and they were friendly, professional, and easy to work with.

Katie McLeod

Wonderful store!

Maria K.

There service is the worst. The people behind the counter are not friendly but rather nasty. Their sandwiches have barely anything in them. I had a prosciutto mozz sandwich and barely any meats and Tver mozz was tinkly sliced. Nothing compares to Uncle G, taliercio or even jersey mikes. People up tour anti and hire nice people. Not going again. This is my my 4 th time. Forgot to mention pasrioso which makes an awesome sandwich. Mine tasted like hiring.

Sarah Nutter

I looked up the menu online and decided what I wanted, when I got there to order it I saw it was also on the menu in store but when I ordered they said they stopped making it. So why is it on your menu in store and online?? What’s the whole point of the menu? Beware, they may not have what you want even if it’s on the menu.

Rosemary M.

Bought Pasta Fagioli and it was terrible. Pasta, a few beans, little broth and it was full of carrots. Way too many carrots....I threw it away. Gave it two stars because I bought bread and that was good. The people that work there have an attitude and are very unfriendly. Better step it up with Uncle Giuseppes in town.

Ralph Mucerino

Always a favorite. Great food and people.

Lise Patterson

Decent deli but sandwiches leave a lot to be desired. The bread is great but they load on the cheaper meats and skimp on the good Italian meats when making Italian style sandwiches. You get one or two slices of the good stuff and inches thick of the cheaper ham, etc. Also they make A LOT of mistakes with the sandwiches. They forget lettuce and tomato, etc. Better sandwiches close by at less cost.

K H

Worst service ever!!!!!!!!!!! The lady at the check out area was very rude towards me when I came to pick up a door dash order then she proceeded to rudely ask me to call the customer and tell her they don't have what she ordered and she acted like she didn't care about the customer order. She acted very racist towards me when I entered the place she was looking at me in a mean way like she didn't want me their she treated everyone else who was white kindly and spoke politely to them very bad service!!!!!!!!

Tamra Wroblesky

Not only did I pick up a fantastic fresh load of bread, chicken meatballs, and cannolis but I had accidentally left my wallet in the store. The owner reached out to me after I made an after hours request on their website and let me know that it had been found and would be there for me to pick up in the morning. Very grateful to such a wonderful company. Will be returning!

John Paragano

Very bad customer service. I wanted to order a tray of food and the person who takes the catering orders made me wait 20 minutes before I walked out and have never returned.

Steve Skesavage

Just ordered lunch today, we had Wraps. Awesome and HUGE.. The counter help was very nice. Alot of good snacks there, cookies...

Big G

Great Italian deli sandwiches catering daily specials friendly service!

Rick G.

Food is ok, but nowhere near worth the cost. Subs are on the small side and 12-15 bucks. Two sandwiches and some macaroni salad was $40. On top of that I was charged 40% more than menu price and when I questioned it I was told "prices are subject to change" even though it's the menu On THE CASE TO ORDER FROM. I've been going for years but enough is enough now. Wish we had a competitor in the Colts Neck area, I won't be going back. Clearly I'm not the only one, as the store was empty during lunch time.

Andrea Carella

I recently worked with Mike coordinating a company event. He was courteous, thorough, thoughtful and took care of everything. He anticipated all of my needs and hired well trained servers who were amazing. On top of the great service, the food was delicious. All of our guests were happy and left full. We had more than enough food that was delivered, set up and served hot. Everything was super fresh and I wouldn't hesitate to hire Mike and Jimmy Pecci's again and again!

Load More