Middletown location 12-14 people in line, 2 girls working one is serving customers the other is Stacking cups on full stacks already on counter, terrible customer service, great ice
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Big Blue
Friendly and helpful staff.Delicous ice cream.Great flavors (standard and special).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Coffee Crunch
Darius Shayegi
Great place for kid birthday party. Did Laser
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Dana Loffredo
Went here for the first time this weekend and it was well worth the trip ! I got the nachos ice cream box with Whoopie pie strawberries and cream and cookies n cream all flavors were amazing the hot fudge was so good ! Definitely will be coming back
Jeremy Yowell
We visited this Nicholas Creamery location specifically to try the Italian rainbow flavor and it did not disappoint! The whoopie pie flavor we also got was delicious as well. Prices were high but not ridiculous, and service was fast. Great ice cream.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Stephanie Giardina
Best ice cream in NJ!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elliot Antebi
Get the Tahitian Vanilla... Some of the finest ice cream on the Jersey ShoreKid-friendliness: I brought my 3 daughters. They loved the bench shaped like a cow
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tahitian Vanilla
Sara Sheehan-Petti
I love how much the employees love ice cream. And how sweet they are to my kids. The flight is 6 scoops. And honestly one is better than the next so fun to share a little of everything
Neil M.
I discovered Nicholas Creamery many years ago in Atlantic Highlands and was blown away by their exceptional quality and unique flavors (lemon blueberry remains my favorite). Once they opened up at Tinton Falls, I knew I'm going to be coming here a lot. This location can get very crowded (and not just on summers) but the line moves quickly. It's cash only but they have an ATM on site. Amazing gourmet ice cream, consistently high quality and very varied flavors with seasonal specials.
Larry
BEST ICE CREAM EVER!!! High quality ingredients, amazing flavors, 10/10
Delicious ice cream and service! Their pumpkin and bourbon coffee are so good!
Rich Conroy
You cannot fathom how good the ice cream is here. It's small batch it's eclectic flavors or a different kind of twist on something you've already heard. The brown sugar cookie dough is hands down the greatest cookie dough ice cream I've ever eaten in my life.Very friendly staff and well worth this sometimes long line from rabid fans.
Jamie O'Reilly
Very cute ice cream shop. The ice cream is good. I ended up going with the pineapple mango sorbet which was good. Not my absolute favorite but I did enjoy it and my family did as well. Was very crowded and I feel understaffed for the amount of people waiting on line. The staff was very friendly and handled the situation very well and pleasant.
Jonathan R.
Solid Ice Cream shop with homemade ice cream flavors.Service is greatPrices are high but on par for small batch ice cream.Bourbon is my favorite flavor.
Christina S.
Do yourself a favor and please go to a Nicholas near you! Best ice cream in the area, we love their flights. My kids like to try different flavors and then mix them at the end but bc of the quality it somehow is tolerable . Who knew cotton candy and booskerdoo crunch would go well together lol. Amazing ice cream and owners
Middletown location 12-14 people in line, 2 girls working one is serving customers the other is Stacking cups on full stacks already on counter, terrible customer service, great ice
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Friendly and helpful staff.Delicous ice cream.Great flavors (standard and special).
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Coffee Crunch
Great place for kid birthday party. Did Laser
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Went here for the first time this weekend and it was well worth the trip ! I got the nachos ice cream box with Whoopie pie strawberries and cream and cookies n cream all flavors were amazing the hot fudge was so good ! Definitely will be coming back
We visited this Nicholas Creamery location specifically to try the Italian rainbow flavor and it did not disappoint! The whoopie pie flavor we also got was delicious as well. Prices were high but not ridiculous, and service was fast. Great ice cream.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Best ice cream in NJ!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Get the Tahitian Vanilla... Some of the finest ice cream on the Jersey ShoreKid-friendliness: I brought my 3 daughters. They loved the bench shaped like a cow
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tahitian Vanilla
I love how much the employees love ice cream. And how sweet they are to my kids. The flight is 6 scoops. And honestly one is better than the next so fun to share a little of everything
I discovered Nicholas Creamery many years ago in Atlantic Highlands and was blown away by their exceptional quality and unique flavors (lemon blueberry remains my favorite). Once they opened up at Tinton Falls, I knew I'm going to be coming here a lot. This location can get very crowded (and not just on summers) but the line moves quickly. It's cash only but they have an ATM on site. Amazing gourmet ice cream, consistently high quality and very varied flavors with seasonal specials.
BEST ICE CREAM EVER!!! High quality ingredients, amazing flavors, 10/10
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious ice cream and service! Their pumpkin and bourbon coffee are so good!
You cannot fathom how good the ice cream is here. It's small batch it's eclectic flavors or a different kind of twist on something you've already heard. The brown sugar cookie dough is hands down the greatest cookie dough ice cream I've ever eaten in my life.Very friendly staff and well worth this sometimes long line from rabid fans.
Very cute ice cream shop. The ice cream is good. I ended up going with the pineapple mango sorbet which was good. Not my absolute favorite but I did enjoy it and my family did as well. Was very crowded and I feel understaffed for the amount of people waiting on line. The staff was very friendly and handled the situation very well and pleasant.
Solid Ice Cream shop with homemade ice cream flavors.Service is greatPrices are high but on par for small batch ice cream.Bourbon is my favorite flavor.
Do yourself a favor and please go to a Nicholas near you! Best ice cream in the area, we love their flights. My kids like to try different flavors and then mix them at the end but bc of the quality it somehow is tolerable . Who knew cotton candy and booskerdoo crunch would go well together lol. Amazing ice cream and owners