Joey D's Pizza

1311 NJ-37 West, Toms River
(732) 503-4409

Recent Reviews

joseph harvey

Went there for dinner tonight before the movie. Only us and two other people in the place and service was extremely slow. Food was ok but not as good as I've had in the past. Because of the slow service I didn't have time to finish my dinner and make it to the movie in time so I asked for a doggie bag. They charged me an extra $2 for the bag. Totally ridiculous. I will never go back. And the guy with the greasy combed back hair always was and still is extremely rude.

Ted R.

Really great food! I go here once a week and it’s great!! People are very nice and accommodating. I always try new things here and they don’t disappoint!

Katrina Iorio

Delivery took over 2 hours for a single pizza, and when food came it was the wrong order and cold. Restaurant was very rude when I called. Drove over to get the right food (also cold), and the crust was so tough you couldn't bite through it. No appology, replacement, or refund. Shame 'cause this place used to be good ...! Go to C & R's (on East Veterans, across from Liberty high school, best ? ever!) instead!

Julia Cho

Haven’t been here in years and decided to dine in with my boyfriend. Our mussels were so good and so was our chicken penne vodka pasta. Our server Karen was amazing! Fast service with a friendly face. She was really sweet. We will be back for sure!

Cathy S

Very convenient, next to movie theater, that's about it. Very expensive. Gluten free pizza tasted like corn meal. Cold sub had a very odd tasting vinegar. Wasted alot of food. Girl at register also played with her hair to put up...right near the food...yuck. plenty of other places in plaza and area. Got "personal size" gf pizza (could have fed 2), Ceasars salad(could have served 3), cold sub(no half sub offered) and margaritas slice plus 2 soda, 1 water=$52.

Albert La Francesca

DISGUSTING. Food is god awful no matter what you order. Service is somehow even worse than the food. Owner is even worse than the service lol. Seriously eat anywhere else but here. Youre better off eating out of the dumpster behind the movie theatre. Im not even kidding its that bad.Owner is a total clown. Very rude and not very bright. No business sense. No class. No respect. Only reason this place hasnt gone out of business yet is bc of the location. Even then im still surprised they havent gone under. Everything about this place is just terrible. Top to bottom.Joey D or whoever the owner is dont bother responding bc i do not care what you have to say. You are a clown and a disgrace to the entire industry.

George Johnson

Don’t even bother leaving a bad review. They don’t care lol. This place is so bad it’s almost like a government run operation on how bad service can be and get away with it.Don’t bother responding JoeyD. No one cares what you have to say. And even on occasions when they got my order correct I never left a positive review because it really was never that good.Joey D… the D should stand for “don’t go”.

No-Panic- Zone

Everytime I go to their Tom's River location the Food is terrible. This time I got a COLD pie that was sitting for 30min when I got their and TOTALLY IGNORED, then the WORKER TRIED TO CONVINCE ME IT JUST CAME OUT THE OVEN... so we had COLD pizza in the end. My fault for Going back I guess.

JW 83NascarRacingFan23

I had tried this pizza last year and, it was good but I warm it up when I got home and, it came out great.Now, I grab 2 slices and eat In before I see a movie at the Marquee Cinemas next to it.

Kim Matta

Waitress tried but wait time terrible half got their food other half sat and waited. Shrimp scampi mushy and cold. Lasagna came very last and cold. Very uncomfortable. Shaky table and no booster or high chair for 2 year old. Only giving a 2 because waitress tried.

Bowers Roxzan

Absolutely the best Eggplant Rollatini I have ever had.Fast Service. Incredible Pizza also. Very Impressed and will absolutely eat here again.

Shotsie Dell

I ordered Shrimp scampi muscle the bill was over 70 dollars and it was not good had to flavor or taste it is slimy not going to order anymore they used to he amazing and I raved about how good there food is hoping they just had a bad day I waited a hour for food that isn't good

Louis L. (Louie)

Well first the Waitress (Karen) I was extremely disappointed. She decides to take my order, puts the order in and then she goes outside to smoke a cigarette. She comes back in smelling of cigarette smoke. Her breathe when she talked was disgusting, she didn't wash her hands. Her clothes smelled horrible. I told her exactly how Im writing this to her at my table. The food wastasty but the eggplant rollatini hardly has any ricotta cheese in it. The bread rolls weren't fresh. Meatballs were tasty. Too expensive $8 for two meatballs and $18. For two eggplant rollatini. I wrote this while still at my table.

Kathleen R

I have gone to this pizzeria over past 9 years living in the area after going to the Marquee Cinema close by, the food and customer service has always been very good. However, I was there recently after a movie just to get 2 slices of pizza to go which I clearly stated and was repeated back to me. There were only 2 other customers present and the staff member I gave order to seemed out of sorts and confused. I have no issues with a person having a bad day, we all do, but when he brought slices out to me to eat there and I very nicely said "oh these were to go" he became irritated and shoved them in a bag with an attitude. I clearly stated to him "to go" which he repeated back to me. I was disappointed when I left. I am choosing to assume this employee/owner must have had a particularly difficult experience prior to myself and 2 other customers entering the pizzeria. The food is always excellent.

Brendan 21

One of the worst pizza joints in NJ. Delivery or pick-up its terrible either way. Gave this place multiple chances bc its close to home but theres always something wrong and the staff are all rude and unhelpful. One night recently we stopped there during business hours just to find the door locked an hour before closing time and staff just waved us away lol. So many great pizza spots around town but this aint one of em. Skip this place.

Load More