Ocean Fresh Seafood Market and Dining

3400 NJ-37, Toms River
(732) 270-3300

Recent Reviews

Joseph Bologna

Good stop would like to see daily lunch special sign and I would stop in and I think it would get customers in to check it out .

Marilynn Manganella

Fabulous!! Everything is so fresh and delicious!!!

Jed Hyle

I was hoping the quality and value of Pisces was still alive here but sadly it is not. Just like Gregory’s was waylaid, another great local shop has fallen to greedy owner cutting quality and jacking prices. The Bennys and north jersey/ ny infestations will keep these places in business.

Joan Palmieri

Salmon was very goodIt’s was big piece, so I didn’t mind paying more money

Samantha Stewart (Mrs. S Stewart)

It's been a long time since I've had such good seafood! Everything was cooked perfectly and was amazing hopefully I can eat there again before we leave.

Bonnie Browne

Food is wonderful! But website not updated hours☹️Made special trip to get yummy food, checked and posted as open and they are not.

NJ

Extremely overpriced, below average execution and basically a tourist trap. I was searching the ShopRite app to compare prices while there and they were around 3 times as expensive for the same exact product. It was almost like they were daring you to buy it. I got the lobster roll and a clam chowder. Neither were memorable and the portions were small. The chowder was $9 for a half pint. The smallest portion I’ve ever seen sold. It was more like a tasting, not a soup. Too much competition to be charging that much for what you are producing. Lastly, the menu online does not match the store on price or products. Avoid it and let this place die off, maybe the next tenant will know how to do food costs when writing a menu.

Cody Davis (CoCo)

There is a scam going on online offering King Crab for $6/lb. They are using this restaurant's information, please be aware.

Lisa M.

I have to say that Pieces was a great place and am very pleased to see that the new owners have the same quality of food. Dave the waiter was very attentive and funny guy. Mac salad a little dull. Add onions, more mayo and some celery and Salt and pepper. The flounder sandwich was outstanding!!! Two pieces of flounder. Where do you get that. Yes it's a little pricey but prices have gone up everywhere. I highly recommend you visit. I know I'll return and hope they remain busy. No good seafood by the barrier island and this place is right over the bridge. Loved it

Lena L.

Small pale with a great fish market and sit down dinner. The restaurant is unassuming, but food is fantastic!!! Seared shrimp tacos were awesome, topped with spicy aioli and tasty salsa. Good size portion for the price. Seared scallops were excellent, not too big but incredibly delicious! Manhattan clam chowder super yummy, we bought a container to take home for later. Thank you for surprising us with this delicious meal!!!

Aliyah DiMaria

Food & service was great! Thank you to Margie who was our sweet server!

Margarita "Margie" Raymond - REALTOR ASSOCIATE

Delicious food & great people. I’m glad my daughter brought me here.

Mike DiMaria

Food was good! Service was great! Margie was our server and she was very nice and enhanced our dining experience!!

R BK

I had the crab cake sliders which were delicious. My friend had the flounder sandwich that was also delicious. French fries were perfectly cooked and seasoned. Mac salad liked flavor which is the only reason I didn't give them five stars. I definitely will go back again.

Michael Rutherford

Excellent sea food. I got one of their platters and they give you a good amount for the price

Load More

Ocean Fresh Seafood Market and Dining

3400 NJ-37, Toms River, NJ 08753
(732) 270-3300