Proud Papa's Pizzeria

470 Chestnut St, Union
(908) 687-0347

Recent Reviews

John Rayside

Twice I ordered a vodka parm and twice there's no sauce. I ask for extra sauce the second time and again no sauce.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 1

The Renaissarian

Average Pizza... Fairly Priced...

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Victor Zevallos

Pizza is ok. But pizza guy throw the pizzawith his hands after he’s been touching everything else who knows if he washes his hands after the bathroom?pretty bad hygiene to be food handling youKind of disgusting but says he’s been doing it for 30 years first time 31 years from March 1, 1993. I suggest he should just stop the pizza is pretty good, but you can’t go wrong making pizza where else you just don’t know nothing.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Mark

Let’s just start off with me mentioning that I’ve been a customer here for several years. I placed an order today for delivery as I always do. My order and my delivery location have always remained the same. After providing my card information to the guy over the phone, he asked if I wanted to leave a tip. When I told him how much I wanted to tip I was told that it was not enough tip for the *nine minute* drive to my delivery location followed by him laughing and making unprofessional comments. Keep in mind, I’m already paying a delivery fee. The guy told me that he would be bumping my tip amount and then hung up before I was able to provide verbal confirmation. As much as I enjoy the food here, this was the last time they will be getting an order from me.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Ron “Medicare Ron” Rivers

Tried the pepperoni pizza. Didn't like the taste. Yet, they did have many to go pies ready for pickup. Try for

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Sean McCormack

I honestly really used to like this place and would order weekly. Today I called in to order a Sicilian pie with half extra cheese and sausage and half just cheese (I’ll admit it’s a weird order). When it arrived all the cheese slid to one side so I called to let them know and see if it were possible to get an extra slice or two for the people that weren’t eating sausage. They agreed and it arrived about an hour after the call completely soaked in oil. I wouldn’t even care but it was to the point where it was pooled into the crevices of the bag. Clearly the owners maturity level needs some work. Whether you agree or disagree about the pizza sometimes you just have to do what’s best for your customer. Unfortunately I will no longer be ordering from you. Good pizza, they just need to work on customer service

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Eva Karainaki

This pizza place is just ok. Just middle of the pack. Good dough but skimpy sauce. They have a Flat Sicilian pie fyi. If you pay for top quality you should get it. Service was not special not friendly as

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Anthony Grant

I ordered a Sicilian on Sunday. The pie was falling apart, lacking in flavor, and the delivery driver was rude as ever. Not happy, never again.

Laura Gamboa

I recently ordered for delivery, and unfortunately, it was a letdown. The order arrived without plates or cups, and when I called to request them, I was assured they would be brought back. However, they never showed up. Moreover, the food quality was below average, and considering the prices, it felt overpriced. Disappointing service and lackluster food. Not recommended.

Diane Renna

Sauce is key with all Italian food. Theirs is very good. Great cannolis. They are generous with the food they stuff in their subs. Delivery is very timely. No long waiting games

Jay C.

Ordered 2 salads via Uber Eats. Easy enough I figured. Completely wrong salads were delivered. And they were $21 each!!!! Called and they really seemed like they didn't give a s**t.I drive over there only to find about a half dozen angry patrons.Way better pizza and food in the area. They're just close in proximity... but never again. Live and learn.I hear Manny's Pizza just down the blockis really good!

Vince Rob

Very good Pizzeria. It’s really good, and I have enjoyed but it’s the entrees I come here for. Very good Marsala, Scarpiello, Francese,Savoy & even Gavadeal. Service is usually a quick 20 min on a pick up. Always a friendly, hard working staff present. Great for family…w pizza for kids while adults can actually share an entree. Great place!

Kosta M.

Food was ok definitely not the best slice around. Service is terrible no customer service everyone is on their cellphones and they don't even talk to customers coming in. I ordered 4 slices and the young man with a hoodie on was just rude. He took the order and then walked away and was on the phone which was on speakerphone I don't understand why everyone needed to hear his conversation. The ambiance was 0 there was literally no ambiance to this place. I don't understand how 6 people standing around couldn't say thank you or goodnight. Very disappointed.

Walter Keil

Pizza slice is just OK. Chicken parm sandwich you could a better one at the the hospital cafeteria. It’s a weird setup inside . Bizarre experience.

Vinny Vincenz

came to service my car and had a place to eat so I came here. I had one slice coming from the Bronx New York. the slice was very good

Load More