We went because family that lives nearby recommended it. We did not order beer or cocktails, we cam only speak about the food. It was very disappointing. The flatbread appetizer was undercooked, the cheese was not melted at all, the sauce tasted like it came out of a can. Just a couple mire minutes in a hot oven might have saved it from disaster but it was nit given a chance. The german pretzel and turkey were ok, nothing special. The Lamb Harissa Burger was the biggest let down. It had the density of a hockey puck and the moisture of desert sand. No one likes a dry dense burger of any type. If there was any harissa mixed in, it was well hidden by the extreme lack of flavor. It tasted like Ground lamb with nothing added. Even salt would have made a big difference. Overall a great location ruined by less than mediocre food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Mr Les
Went last night. Was able to secure a nice table overlooking the bar. Our server was outstanding, highly attentive and personable. Their homemade beer rated about a 7 outta 10 so I chose guest offerings. Wife’s mixed cocktail was excellent. Calamari was also about a 7. Both entrees were about a 7.5. Overall a nice experience in a beautiful space but not outstanding.
Bob B
Had a couple of apps. Wings were delicious. The ambience of the building is incredible. Beer was ok was hoping they had the lazy Jake porter. Would love for them to have Guinness on tap. Bartender was great. Juan the chef came over to see how things are going. The guy is awesome and goes out of his way to accommodate your needs. Must give it try for happy hour. They have nice specials.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Douglas Templeman Sr
We had a party 5 and the bill was $250. They charge a credit card fee. Most people don't carry a spare several hundred dollars in their wallet, so the obvious choice would be to use a credit card. Just seems excessive and greedy. For this reason, I will not go back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Kris Menard
The food was excellent and the service was stellar! Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
SteveK2K2
Food overall was good. Portion size of the reuben was quite small - especially considering price. Molten lava chocolate cake had nothing "molten" about it. Seemed stale/frozen and it was sent back. Excellent service & atmosphere with Christmas decorations was excellent as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
gentlemankilla
Long Valley Brew Pub gets an 11 out of 10 from me! The stone exterior and timber framied interior is really like sitting inside of a time capsule. The historic building is stunning. The food has been consistently wonderful going hand and hand with their extraordinary staff. These hard working men and women are professional, kindhearted, warm & inviting. That's says a lot seeing how in their industry it is getting harder and harder to meet the demands of picky customers. Through all that they seem to always rise to the occasion and continue to impress in what has really become a chaotic business. Hats off to the staff of Long Valley Brew Pub! Your home away from home!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Reuben, Fish and Chips, Chicken Schnitzel Sandwich, Bratwurst, Red Cabbage
William Fallon
I have been here several times and totally enjoyed it. Today 10/28 it was horrible. I had to ask to see a server after waiting 15 min at our table and it went down hill from there. I am not rushing back to a spot an always looked forward to going to….
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Kunal Chandel
everything seems good except the drinks seems watered down. I had 3 drinks and each was a different amount of alcohol. I had gin and club soda. the first one had no gin. the second one had a perfect amount of gin and the third one was somewhere in the middle. I don't know what they're trying to do. make sure that we don't drink and drive well. that wasn't a problem cuz I had a designated driver. I don't understand why the drinks are so uneven
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike KLEJMONT
The food was very good good portions. The waiter was extremely slow and took forever to get our food.
Horrible customer service! Bartender is completely rude and should not work in a customer service job. He actually told me to come help him work behind the bar cause I was questioning where my drink was after 25 minutes of waiting when the rest of my table had received there’s already. The owner really needs to get more help. We have been coming here for over 10 yrs. Unfortunately this was our last. Service is way too slow.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 1
Daemon
As the world eliminates plastic, these guys use them for water servings. They should use glass and make a world a cleaner place. It is ashame. They deserve low rating.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Scott Brown
Website says "hand-crafted ale's". That's nonsense..You brew nothing on-site. I wonder when the owners will take this place seriously insead of buying up all of the other restaurants in town. Focus on something great and make it great, or... just don't. The Brew Pub was a special icon. Now it's nothing.An absolute disaster. Went there today in hopes of decent food and beer. Ordered nachos. Sent them back. They can't even get that straight. Nachos are simple. But they were cold and chips were stale and old. This is the third time we tried the nachos and sent them back. If they can't even get that right, no way in hell would I order any entree. The place is filthy and is in need of new owners who would care about a historic building. I have zero plans to return until they get their act together. But it's been years and nothing has changed. The owners clearly could care less and the people that work there have even said that. Shame on them.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
Lily Mitchell
Absolutely delicious!!! Honestly the best food I've ever had. And the hookerman beer was perfect, nice and lite with a bit a citrus. I got the steak and gorgonzola pasta with sundried tomato and spinach, such a burst of favor in ever bite. For dessert we got the chocolate lava cake, cake was nice and moist and sweet as well as the ice cream and the presentation was beautiful. Our waiter was knowledgeable, quick and very friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elegantease
Hadn’t been here in ten years. Always liked it before. Today for lunch disappointed. Went at 2 and was not crowded on Labor Day. Walked in employees everywhere and nobody seating us. We almost walked out and should have. Finally seated. Sat at table for almost 8 mins with nobody coming to take drink order. Almost left again. Finally a waitress comes. Light beer was not too cold. Just of. They supposedly specialize in German fare. Pierogi appetizer tasted like fried frozen raviolis with some cheddar cheese and bacon bits sprinkled. 5 pierogies dry and tasteless for $15. One of us ordered the chicken schnitzel sandwich, dry and tasteless. The other ordered the French Dip. Bread good but small amount of dry sliced roast beef. Fries were only good thing we had. $70 for lunch for two who left dissatisfied. Won’t be back. Too many other better pub restaurants.
We went because family that lives nearby recommended it. We did not order beer or cocktails, we cam only speak about the food. It was very disappointing. The flatbread appetizer was undercooked, the cheese was not melted at all, the sauce tasted like it came out of a can. Just a couple mire minutes in a hot oven might have saved it from disaster but it was nit given a chance. The german pretzel and turkey were ok, nothing special. The Lamb Harissa Burger was the biggest let down. It had the density of a hockey puck and the moisture of desert sand. No one likes a dry dense burger of any type. If there was any harissa mixed in, it was well hidden by the extreme lack of flavor. It tasted like Ground lamb with nothing added. Even salt would have made a big difference. Overall a great location ruined by less than mediocre food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Went last night. Was able to secure a nice table overlooking the bar. Our server was outstanding, highly attentive and personable. Their homemade beer rated about a 7 outta 10 so I chose guest offerings. Wife’s mixed cocktail was excellent. Calamari was also about a 7. Both entrees were about a 7.5. Overall a nice experience in a beautiful space but not outstanding.
Had a couple of apps. Wings were delicious. The ambience of the building is incredible. Beer was ok was hoping they had the lazy Jake porter. Would love for them to have Guinness on tap. Bartender was great. Juan the chef came over to see how things are going. The guy is awesome and goes out of his way to accommodate your needs. Must give it try for happy hour. They have nice specials.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had a party 5 and the bill was $250. They charge a credit card fee. Most people don't carry a spare several hundred dollars in their wallet, so the obvious choice would be to use a credit card. Just seems excessive and greedy. For this reason, I will not go back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
The food was excellent and the service was stellar! Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food overall was good. Portion size of the reuben was quite small - especially considering price. Molten lava chocolate cake had nothing "molten" about it. Seemed stale/frozen and it was sent back. Excellent service & atmosphere with Christmas decorations was excellent as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Long Valley Brew Pub gets an 11 out of 10 from me! The stone exterior and timber framied interior is really like sitting inside of a time capsule. The historic building is stunning. The food has been consistently wonderful going hand and hand with their extraordinary staff. These hard working men and women are professional, kindhearted, warm & inviting. That's says a lot seeing how in their industry it is getting harder and harder to meet the demands of picky customers. Through all that they seem to always rise to the occasion and continue to impress in what has really become a chaotic business. Hats off to the staff of Long Valley Brew Pub! Your home away from home!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Reuben, Fish and Chips, Chicken Schnitzel Sandwich, Bratwurst, Red Cabbage
I have been here several times and totally enjoyed it. Today 10/28 it was horrible. I had to ask to see a server after waiting 15 min at our table and it went down hill from there. I am not rushing back to a spot an always looked forward to going to….
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
everything seems good except the drinks seems watered down. I had 3 drinks and each was a different amount of alcohol. I had gin and club soda. the first one had no gin. the second one had a perfect amount of gin and the third one was somewhere in the middle. I don't know what they're trying to do. make sure that we don't drink and drive well. that wasn't a problem cuz I had a designated driver. I don't understand why the drinks are so uneven
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was very good good portions. The waiter was extremely slow and took forever to get our food.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Fish
Restaurantji Recommends
Horrible customer service! Bartender is completely rude and should not work in a customer service job. He actually told me to come help him work behind the bar cause I was questioning where my drink was after 25 minutes of waiting when the rest of my table had received there’s already. The owner really needs to get more help. We have been coming here for over 10 yrs. Unfortunately this was our last. Service is way too slow.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 1
As the world eliminates plastic, these guys use them for water servings. They should use glass and make a world a cleaner place. It is ashame. They deserve low rating.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Website says "hand-crafted ale's". That's nonsense..You brew nothing on-site. I wonder when the owners will take this place seriously insead of buying up all of the other restaurants in town. Focus on something great and make it great, or... just don't. The Brew Pub was a special icon. Now it's nothing.An absolute disaster. Went there today in hopes of decent food and beer. Ordered nachos. Sent them back. They can't even get that straight. Nachos are simple. But they were cold and chips were stale and old. This is the third time we tried the nachos and sent them back. If they can't even get that right, no way in hell would I order any entree. The place is filthy and is in need of new owners who would care about a historic building. I have zero plans to return until they get their act together. But it's been years and nothing has changed. The owners clearly could care less and the people that work there have even said that. Shame on them.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
Absolutely delicious!!! Honestly the best food I've ever had. And the hookerman beer was perfect, nice and lite with a bit a citrus. I got the steak and gorgonzola pasta with sundried tomato and spinach, such a burst of favor in ever bite. For dessert we got the chocolate lava cake, cake was nice and moist and sweet as well as the ice cream and the presentation was beautiful. Our waiter was knowledgeable, quick and very friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hadn’t been here in ten years. Always liked it before. Today for lunch disappointed. Went at 2 and was not crowded on Labor Day. Walked in employees everywhere and nobody seating us. We almost walked out and should have. Finally seated. Sat at table for almost 8 mins with nobody coming to take drink order. Almost left again. Finally a waitress comes. Light beer was not too cold. Just of. They supposedly specialize in German fare. Pierogi appetizer tasted like fried frozen raviolis with some cheddar cheese and bacon bits sprinkled. 5 pierogies dry and tasteless for $15. One of us ordered the chicken schnitzel sandwich, dry and tasteless. The other ordered the French Dip. Bread good but small amount of dry sliced roast beef. Fries were only good thing we had. $70 for lunch for two who left dissatisfied. Won’t be back. Too many other better pub restaurants.