Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

470 Schooleys Mountain Rd, Hackettstown
(908) 979-3560

Recent Reviews

Ed Fi

Excellent,

Dom Bastello

Hummm, ice or custard.? Ice or custard? Ok... I'll get both!You can't go wrong and won't be disappointed.Try it you'll like it.?

Christina L.

Super yummy and tasty! There's only one sugar-free option when I came (tangerine), but it was still super good and didn't taste sugar-free. All the italian ice are made from real fruit daily too. The cashier was patient and nice, getting my order quickly. Perfect spot for a hot summer day.

christine g

The kids size is perfect. Never too much or too little. Loved my mango Italian ice. My fiance's chocolate Italian ice was delicious as well. With a little vanilla custard... you can't go wrong!

Nancy Mezzina

Great staff and really really yummy ice and frozen custard

April Kiesling

I was disappointed there were no sugar free flavors ?

Susan Melkowits

Great ice cream and the staff is wonderful.

Vito S.

Thank goodness for Ritas! This magical oasis is a must stop in the summer while we are out and about. Plenty of parking is available. The staff is always friendly and the store front is always clean. They have picnic benches available so one can enjoy their delicious treat outside. Plenty of flavors and topping to choice from. Watermelon and mango are my favorite flavors. Swedish Fish with Gummy Bears are my kids favorite. Make sure you stop by if your in the area. You will not be disappointed.

Gerry Harman

Had the Mango Ice with the Vanilla Custard. Rang everyone of my bells. So good I wondered how it could be I have never had this combo.......try it, you will not be disappointed.

Olivia Planer

Change your hours. ?

Jonathan Sloane

Great ice and gelato as always.Trash was way overfull and (2) tables less than the cleanest. Granted it was evening.Fairly busy for early in the season (May).Walkable greens if you're an adult, and a field-ish area behind that kids can sit in the grass if it's not wet.

Erik Velasco

There's always things unavailable, either ingredients or, flavors. Once you made up your mind get ready for a broken record of I'm out of it...

Brenden Matthews

It's just not like the other one.

Warren Tarkington (Gearhead2017)

I gave 4 stars because the employees are kinda slow but the italian ices are the bomb,I used to get 2 flavors chocolate and fudge brownies and they mixed them,don't live in flemington anymore since I moved to Oxford in warren County but yeah good food

James Connors

Fast and easy - it was fine to get in and out. Unfortunately, their prices are a bit on the pricey side.

Load More