Perused the menu, decided on what I wanted, and asked for it over the phone. When I arrived to pick up the pizza and appetizer, I was told that I hadn’t ordered the pizza. When I said I remembered ordering it, I was again told I hadn’t, but that I could buy a slice if I wanted one. It was a poor first experience at this location. I don’t recommend it.
Robert Mcbride
Any time I call I ask for John he is great he gets to learn his Customers he is the only one that I tip really good one day I went into the Pizzeria and he was there we just walked so if order from here ask for john I promise you you will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emilie Giordano
Best Pizza in Warren County by far!
Food: 5
Courtney Singleton
I got a small 14" supreme pizza and it was so soggy it was like eating a weird disgusting soup. Disgusting. The garlic cheese bread, is actually pesto bread with a little bit of cold hard cheese. It was weird. Lastly, the salad had almost all brown lettuce. Not yum. I had it delivered and it was delivered quickly (I live two blocks away). I will never order from this place again. My mother and I both felt ill after eating the food. I can't believe we actually tried to drink that pizza down. We had way more than half left over and threw it all away. I wouldn't even give it to the dog. Nasty...it was a comical dinner in a sad way though.
Food: 1
Service: 2
GARY JAMES MAGUIRE
Excellent pizza and meals, never disappoints my family or me. My daughter never liked pizza now She does, hands down Sal's is a better pizzeria then other local pizzeria's.
The sicilians pizza is my favorite!Their salads are amazing.The pasta dishes are amazing!Friendly atmosphere Amazing chef/owner.Vegetarian options: Gluten free items and vegetarian pizzas and salads available.Kid-friendliness: Lots of yummy food for kiddDietary restrictions: Gluten free items available
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Soda
Leon Neon
I like this place! I'm a local and we get food here every now and than. A friend from Cali even said she loves this places pizza more than anywhere else! I think the foods good for what it is, definitely gonna taste decent everytime. I recommend trying Sals, especially sense their kind people who make some damn good brooklyn style pizza!
James 87
Ordered food at around 9:30pm on a Saturday by Sal's website food never comes no call, no show. They close at 10pm can't even call to tell us they can't make it. I call slice at around 10:30pm they tell me through multiple reps only Sal's can refund the money back sorry call them at 12pm when they open. Ok. I call Sal's you think they would be like so sorry blah blah blah will give you the money back or when you order again will give you a credit but no I get from them Call Slice. Just like that "call Slice". I said no they told me to call you to get my money back again in a rude tone "Call Slice." I said I can call the police to get my money back guy tells me "ok". Wow really normal and customer service so great here. Take your money,never Send your food,never anything for the inconvenience, not even a sorry. Pretty much who cares approach.His voice mail is full so you can't even leave a message you have to wait until someone picks up. A other person on here give the same review so they never learn from there mistakes they don't care about any customer service so when they reply they do it's a lie. Will never order again here. In a town with pizza places on every corner you think they would care but no. So if they ever go out of Business don't feel sorry for them. I support local business just not this one.
Julia P
We placed an order at 9:20pm Sal’s pizza took our order and money, est delivery time was at 10:27pm and no one show with our pizza. Now it’s 11:10pm and still no pizza. DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS SCAM PLACE!!!
Yada yodo
I have tried this place over 5 times and I have not enjoyed their pizzas. My experience was worse during the times the owner, (Fabio?) took my order. So every time I consider trying again I must re-consider. The cheese of the slices on display often looked questionable.When I was a teenager and the owner once saw my friend looking into a dumpster, he offered the group of us 3, free pizzas. We accepted and ate, but then he sat at my table, flirted with me and stroked my arm my arm, complimenting my "tattoo", which was faded marker scribbles. He then offered me a job.My friend (who was also a teenager at the time) told me about his time working there and mentioned a huge dilution of tomato sauce and reheating of very old slices that he did not feel right being told to serve to customers. Sorry but the truth needs to be said, or else how can things change?I do not blame the other employees who especially seem to work hard and have respect for personal space.
Ordered pizza for my granddaughter and me. I was told 25 minutes for delivery. Pizza came over an hour later.
Service: 1
I'm new in town and this by far is the best pizza I've found in the area...fast delivery and friendly driver..thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian
Invalid Phone #?
Don't know what happened maybe they changed cooks but I just ordered and got two raw
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Penne Vodka with Chicken, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Italian, Slice Sausage
Best Margarita pizza ever!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Perused the menu, decided on what I wanted, and asked for it over the phone. When I arrived to pick up the pizza and appetizer, I was told that I hadn’t ordered the pizza. When I said I remembered ordering it, I was again told I hadn’t, but that I could buy a slice if I wanted one. It was a poor first experience at this location. I don’t recommend it.
Any time I call I ask for John he is great he gets to learn his Customers he is the only one that I tip really good one day I went into the Pizzeria and he was there we just walked so if order from here ask for john I promise you you will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Pizza in Warren County by far!
Food: 5
I got a small 14" supreme pizza and it was so soggy it was like eating a weird disgusting soup. Disgusting. The garlic cheese bread, is actually pesto bread with a little bit of cold hard cheese. It was weird. Lastly, the salad had almost all brown lettuce. Not yum. I had it delivered and it was delivered quickly (I live two blocks away). I will never order from this place again. My mother and I both felt ill after eating the food. I can't believe we actually tried to drink that pizza down. We had way more than half left over and threw it all away. I wouldn't even give it to the dog. Nasty...it was a comical dinner in a sad way though.
Food: 1
Service: 2
Excellent pizza and meals, never disappoints my family or me. My daughter never liked pizza now She does, hands down Sal's is a better pizzeria then other local pizzeria's.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The sicilians pizza is my favorite!Their salads are amazing.The pasta dishes are amazing!Friendly atmosphere Amazing chef/owner.Vegetarian options: Gluten free items and vegetarian pizzas and salads available.Kid-friendliness: Lots of yummy food for kiddDietary restrictions: Gluten free items available
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Soda
I like this place! I'm a local and we get food here every now and than. A friend from Cali even said she loves this places pizza more than anywhere else! I think the foods good for what it is, definitely gonna taste decent everytime. I recommend trying Sals, especially sense their kind people who make some damn good brooklyn style pizza!
Ordered food at around 9:30pm on a Saturday by Sal's website food never comes no call, no show. They close at 10pm can't even call to tell us they can't make it. I call slice at around 10:30pm they tell me through multiple reps only Sal's can refund the money back sorry call them at 12pm when they open. Ok. I call Sal's you think they would be like so sorry blah blah blah will give you the money back or when you order again will give you a credit but no I get from them Call Slice. Just like that "call Slice". I said no they told me to call you to get my money back again in a rude tone "Call Slice." I said I can call the police to get my money back guy tells me "ok". Wow really normal and customer service so great here. Take your money,never Send your food,never anything for the inconvenience, not even a sorry. Pretty much who cares approach.His voice mail is full so you can't even leave a message you have to wait until someone picks up. A other person on here give the same review so they never learn from there mistakes they don't care about any customer service so when they reply they do it's a lie. Will never order again here. In a town with pizza places on every corner you think they would care but no. So if they ever go out of Business don't feel sorry for them. I support local business just not this one.
We placed an order at 9:20pm Sal’s pizza took our order and money, est delivery time was at 10:27pm and no one show with our pizza. Now it’s 11:10pm and still no pizza. DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS SCAM PLACE!!!
I have tried this place over 5 times and I have not enjoyed their pizzas. My experience was worse during the times the owner, (Fabio?) took my order. So every time I consider trying again I must re-consider. The cheese of the slices on display often looked questionable.When I was a teenager and the owner once saw my friend looking into a dumpster, he offered the group of us 3, free pizzas. We accepted and ate, but then he sat at my table, flirted with me and stroked my arm my arm, complimenting my "tattoo", which was faded marker scribbles. He then offered me a job.My friend (who was also a teenager at the time) told me about his time working there and mentioned a huge dilution of tomato sauce and reheating of very old slices that he did not feel right being told to serve to customers. Sorry but the truth needs to be said, or else how can things change?I do not blame the other employees who especially seem to work hard and have respect for personal space.