Mamma Maria

40 Washington St, West Orange
(973) 731-3774

Recent Reviews

Michael Johnson

Very good food and friendly staff

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Clyburn

I drive past this place a few times a week. Haven't stepped foot in here in probably about 7-8 years because the pizza wasn't good the last time I was here. Needed a quick bite and figured I would give them another shot. Took home two slices and ended up only eating half of a slice.I just don't think the pizza is very good here. Maybe some of the other dishes are better.

Dineel Sealy

I love it hereGreat foodFriendly service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Caesar, Pizzas

Jack DeWitt

The service was nice. The place is clean. A bit pricey for pizza. I think I paid $10 for two slices. Granted they had a lot of toppings. I was not a fan of the combinations and tried two different pizzas.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

Lisa Chavis

Good food. Nice people ?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Hakim Rutledge

This place is very nice and I'm definitely going back. I went on my birthday and had a very nice price meal and very nice time!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kyle McCray

Mama Maria's is my go to spot! It's very clean, the staff is always friendly, and the chicken Caesar pizza is the very best I've had

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: King Kong Sandwich

Bruno N.

Stopping by for a slice with the kids after a swim meet, we were all pleasantly surprised by the quality of their plain slice (or, as they call it in other parts of the United States, "cheese slice"). When kids are hungry, everything naturally tastes better, so in order to confirm their ratings, I helped myself to samples of their slices, which had been ordered separately. A lifelong pizza aficionado, I gave it a very high 8/10 rating. The cheese was abundant, the sauce had the slightest tinge of sweetness and the crust was in the perfect spot between thin and Sicilian. We dined in on a Wednesday evening, so of course your mileage may vary. The ambiance is interesting, with a rotating menu displayed on large LCD screens above the cashier that featured an animated fiery background, perhaps simulating a pizza-eye's view of the inside of an oven? The employees were pleasant and patient with taking two kids' orders, and the prices ($3 for a slice, $1 for a can of soda) were great. We'll definitely stop by next time we're in the area.

WEGOTUS KIDZ

Definitely my favorite place to eat now. The Grilled chicken Caesar pizza is so filling and very affordable. I personally recommend it! The Buffalo Chicken Ranch Pizza is just as awesome if you like spicy food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Favorite Chicken Caeser Salad Pie

TONIA CHAMPAGNE

I was by myself but felt like I was a part of the family while I was there. Great atmosphere. Loved the Spanish videos playing on the screen while I was dining in. The staff was very helpful and friendly. I definitely recommend them. I used to get their grilled chicken Caesar salad when I was working in the office in East Orange. Our entire office use to order from there. They have really kept up their great repoire. I look forward to going back and I've shared my experience with my social media friends and family also.Vegetarian options: They definitely have great options for vegetarians.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza Sub

Ginnene Simpkins

Horrible customer service! Delivered my pizza with half of it stuck on the box. Called them. They said cool will send a new pizza. NEVER CAME! Called back and now they spoke to someone who said the pizza was good. But hey lesson learned. Be blessed!

Mercedes Orejuela

When the order came it was cold and an Item was missing I had to wait another 25/30 mins for the driver to bring the missing item after the initial delivery. When calling the store to get answers they would continuously place me on hold. Once the item came it was hard as in overcooked. Very very poor customer service I’m very disappointed how they handled the situation.

Ebonnie Arrington

The pizza was amazing!!! The beat ive had in yrs. All the ingredients were so fresh especially the bread and crust. My entire family enjoyed it. This will be my main pizza place from now on

Julie DaSilva (Jules)

Good take out - delivery people are really friendly.

JEFF REYNOSO

Great local Business !A nice menu and great customer service !

Load More