The Bagel Box

642 Eagle Rock Ave, West Orange
(973) 731-4985

Recent Reviews

Jaison L.

I asked the girl servicing me for soft bagels (I only ordered 3) since my wife does not like crispy bagels. I got home and they were hard as in 'day old bagels'. Do not recommend going here. Yes I owned a deli so I know 'old' bagels. Just went here out of convenience but now remember the reason I stopped going to Bagel Box several years ago. At 9am, the bagels should be fresh...

alfredo posada

Great bagels, friendly service

JP G

I liked their bagels. They are thick and chewy and the lockse and cream cheese were also really good. I also tried the bagel sandwich with cheese, egg and Taylor ham. The staff try their best to keep everything moving during really high peak time in the morning. I think that maybe they might want to consider expanding into the space next door, which is currently vacant, because the space right now is very very cramped. It would benefit their customers to have some place to sit down and actually enjoy your bagel on the spot.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sam Lurie

Great bagels but cashier gave the wrong change and refused to correct it. Pay cash at your own risk.

Yakuza

Messed up the two bagels I

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Sean Morgan

Nothing special about the bagels but nothing bad either. Good price and good

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Tomas Perez

It is a good place for bagels, the bagels are fresh, the service is friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mitul Rana

Bagels are made fresh everyday and the place is packed every morning, they have a variety of cream cheeses and breakfast sandwiches.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Bagel with Taylor Ham and Egg, Egg and Cheese, Dozen Bagels

Dieusibon Dabady

This place is horrible first of all, I ordered a coffee I specifically said I want it sweat ! They give me unsweetened coffee and my food was so cold and disgusting smh please people do better next time keep it cute

arnold saslow

No shortage of bagels in New Jersey but this place is specialHuge selectionSchemers galoreThe lox and cream cheese my favoriteTons of fresh pastriesSmall placeOrder on the rightStand on the leftNo tablesYou can easily wait in line but it moves fastMexican owner and Mexican staff so speak clearly and don’t use slang expressionsJust a great placeEasy parking as it is in a mini mallWheelchair accessibleDr Arnold saslow

Joshua Ruiz

Definitely my fav to go to in the morning everything there is fresh daily

Laetitia Lampo

Absolutely delicious sandwiches every time!!! Love this place!!!

Matt N.

$10.50 for Taylor Ham egg and cheese on a bagel with a Bai drink. With all the great bagel places around. Not worth it.

Scott S.

It's a small bagel joint in a tight parking lot but don't let that discourage you from going there. I ordered a salt bagel with scallion cream cheese. Toasted enough toMake it warm but still keeping the chewiness I desired. Really good salt bagel. Scallion cream cheese was good with real scallions cut perfectly. People working here are nice and the prices were good. I'd come here again.

Greg Pisello

The employees are very friendly and the food is great!! Went there for the first time today. The employee made a mistake with my order (no big issue). I went back inside, told the owner and he immediately made me the same order, correctly and it was VERY good. I will absolutely return when I am in the area.

Load More