Addams Tavern

115 Elm St, Westfield
(908) 232-3201

Recent Reviews

Frederick Schroeder

Stopped in here for an early dinner. The waitress at the bar (maybe she is a bartender) took my order and before I could even tell her what I wanted to drink she quickly left me to go chat with her friends or whoever at the bar. Never once came back to even ask if I needed anything. And these people expect a tip. FXXK that!If you’re so busy chatting that you can’t do your job then find another line of work!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

Dan Stephens

Went there for a lunch with my wife, they have a live fire place, I think some thing is broken with it cause the whole place reeked of wood smoke. It was too much for me, I had to leave. They comped my sandwich but

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 4

Gaston Sardi

Varied menu and delicious food. The attention must improve a little to be

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Gianna Martini

Beautiful place, amazing food, and our server, Danny was great!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amanda P

The food was great. I recommend getting the lobster fettuccine, short rib, and spicy calamari. We walked-in on a Friday night at 6pm and luckily we were able to get a table but I'm sure if we came later we might have had to wait so I would recommend getting a reservation since this seems like a popular place. My kids seemed to really enjoy the food too especially the desserts! You have to try the cinnamon roll bread pudding a la mode! ? If nothing else, get the bread pudding.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dan Bradley

My wife and I stopped here yesterday for a "quick" drink around 5pm and found 2 seats at the bar. Bartender, who was right in front of us, did not acknowledge us and went to the end of the bar to service other customers and chat with them. A second bartender came over, told the first one to go home, ignored us, and disappeared. We sat there for 25 minutes without service. Another couple came in and sat beside us. We decided to wait 10 more minutes out of curiosity to see how long it would take to be served. All of the bartenders stood at the kitchen end of the bar chatting with each or other patrons. Finally, the chattiest one came our way and asked the couple next to us for their order. After a few more minutes she told us she would be with us in a minute. We then watched her clean up the bar area behind her and begin typing on her laptop right in front of us. Since our 10 minute time limit had now expired, we left after 40 minutes without being acknowledged for 39 of them without receiving any service. Terrible way to run a dining establishment.

Kavita Torres

I love this place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Julie Lotzmann

We’ve been here once and our experience was less than great especially knowing harvest restaurant group standards. First the waitress served me about a half glass of wine for my taste, so I was extremely confused when she paused before pouring my husband a glass for me to taste. We didn’t go for anything crazy but given the prices of wine on their menu I’d hesitate to splurge on wine here. My husband heard her boss saying to her a few times to pour us wine. I don’t mind pouring my own wine but if you come by and we have empty or almost empty glasses it’s standard to pour it. Not sure why the waitress took away the napkin on the wine about 2/3 of the way through the bottle either.Food was super good. Was a little confused why the table next to us got their food first but wasn’t drastic enough time to notice. The main reason I’m even writing this review is first they brought us the wrong dessert, then they tried to change us for the WRONG desert and the right dessert. When we brought it to someone attention (not the waitress she was no where to be found) they took off the wrong dessert and that was it…it’s extremely standard when you screw up to comp the dessert. We weren’t going to keep waiting around. I already had to flag the waitress down the first time at which point she just mouthed that she was working on it or something and kept walking. It was like 9pm so it really wasn’t that busy.When I left feedback on resy I got a call from the restaurant and they said they wanted to drop something off at our house so I gave them my address. Not surprised we received nothing, this was for Valentine’s Day. Much better placed in Westfield to spend $200+ on dinner or could drive over to summit.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2

Jessica Lindner

Amanda was our server and she was amazing! The food and drinks were excellent. We had our 11 month old daughter with us and we didn’t know they didn’t have high chairs and she went to her car to get her portable high chair for us! So thank you to Amanda for being so kind to us and going above and beyond to make our girl comfortable.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dan S.

Went to the tavern for lunch today. They had a real wood fire going in their fireplace, not sure what was up but the smell of woodsmoke is so strong I got lightheaded and sick to my stomach, couldn't even smell the food under my nose. I had to leave my meal basically uneaten. The tavern comped my sandwich so good news there, but I'm still feeling queezy and have a headache from that fire.

Matthew Krupit

Have been here for lunch several times but went for the first time to dinner and our expectations were highly exceeded. It was a special occasion and they seated us upstairs in the back dining room which felt special, also giving us a card signed by the entire staff. The service was exceptional, the food was outstanding, the atmosphere is incredible, and our experience was superior. Will be back here again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sinem Akinci

The food and atmosfer was good however the service was not good. We have waited for 1,5 hours to have our meals

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Joy Yagid

Ambiance was amazing. Server was fantastic. Food was pretty good. I had the kale chicken salad. It was delish, but could have been even more if they had a bit more dressing, herbs, and crunch. Dining companion had the baby back ribs which were like buttah. There was a miscommunication by us on the sides but it was quickly rectified by our attentive and wonderful server. Will be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salad

M S.

They need to fix the chimney bc the stink of smoke that gets imbedded in your hair and clothing while dining is awful. We had to go home to shower afterwards. The food also needs improvement. We were going every other week to sit at the bar and will be taking a break. The fries that we ordered were stale and obviously reheated. It's not difficult to make fresh fries. We didn't even eat half of them. They changed the tuna tartar appetizer which previously was the best thing on the menu and it's now drenched in a sweet sauce that is not good. If you go on their website, they have pictures of the previous tuna tartar and we wish they would bring that back. The service is five stars.

Brian Mandell

Whitney is amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More