I ordered a plain slice and barbeque slice. The plates they serve the pizza on are so flimsy and small that when the pizza was brought to the table the server, had to put his bare hands on the pizza (holding the crust with his thumb) to prevent the pizza from falling off the plate. Really didn't like the idea of his hands on my food. The plate wasn't big enough for the pizza and so the pizza touched the table. When I asked for extra plates so it would actually fit the pizza and prevent it from touching the table, he gave me a single plate. The pizza crusts are so thin that the pizza falls apart before you can eat it. Hope they implement some changes
Oliver Rogers
Whippany pizza is good. The pizza is pretty good, have not tried any other dishes. The workers are friendly and do a good job.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Karen Bolger
I haven’t been able to find a pizza place in the area that I really like and then I found Whippany Pizza. I’ve had their pizza, dinners, salads, and calzones (deep fried) and have not been disappointed yet. The food is always ready when they say and the people who work their are friendly. You have to try them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gissell Coste
Decided to eat here before catching the polar express train, great service and they worked with my sons food allergies and I noticed the worker/owner giving some kids who were probably known customers free slices because they didn't have money. Awesome service in the little time I had
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe Schmoken
Pizza was ready on time and it tasted good.
Julia S.
Service is GREAT. Pizza is ok. My daughter loves the garlic knots and mozzarella sticks. Easy parking
MaryAnn Simmons
Food was terrible, owner seemed clueless. Wouldn’t recommend. Can definitely tell the food is pre made and comes frozen
Pat York
Great pizza, crusty. Not too many seats inside and quite small but the food is good which is the most important.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michelle Chiappetta
Brand new pizzeria! Located on Rt 10 W in the new high rise complex next to CVS. MUST GO HERE! The food is top notch, plentiful, fresh and excellently priced. Check out the menus I posted- their full menu and Lunch Menu. The people who work there are so friendly and accommodating. The atmosphere is clean and pleasant. They have so many options to choose from. The pizza case is always full with fresh pizza, garlic knots, empanada, etc. Come by, enjoy and support this new business. You will be satisfied! To boot they also have a family special you literally cannot beat. It’s a large pie, garlic bread, mozzarella sticks, Caesar salad and a 2 liter soda for……?$26.95!!! Get it! You won’t regret it!! Especially if you’ve got a small crowd, kids or kids and their friends!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken Pizza
Lindsay F.
Nothing annoys me more than a wrong order. Ordered pizza, peppers and onions. Delivered pizza with pepperoni and onions.Probably won't order again due to mistake. Tried to call but no answer.
For a pizza place, the pizza is really not that good. Tried it in slices and pies multiple times, only to be disappointed over and over.However, the pastas were pretty good. Until today, all bland. The chicken fingers looked old and obviously just frozen. Same goes for the fried calamari.Lastly, I typically order for 5-10 people and they wanted an extra .50 cents for some crushed peppers. Cmon now.Edit: I think your response pretty much sums it up. Seems like there’s other reviews that state your pizza isn’t that good. So what? And you’re right, I can have my own opinions. And I decided to express it here after order multiple orders.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Melanie Benton
I have had nothing but a great experience. My other go to place kept messing up our orders and was very overpriced. Whippany Pizza has great prices, good food and the order is always correct and on time delivery. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
eric b
Best pizza I have had in a long time. Excellent presentation and super clean, but the taste was the best part.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken Pizza
Joe H.
I work nearby. I ordered two sandwiches for pickup. I walk in with a smile and ask the girl have you got my sandwiches, which I could see were sitting on top of the pizza oven. The place was empty. The manager (owner?) immediately copped a nasty attitude. 'What sandwiches?" "For who?" He was practically yelling. I gave him my name, still smiling, and the clown throws his hands up in the air like I had done something wrong. The friendly teenaged girl got my sandwiches and as the guy was walking away I told him "they should have been easy to find, it looks like that 's the only business he's had."That made him go ballistic. I walked out, still smiling, and I could hear him still bitching about HOW I asked for my "two sandwiches". Recently I ordered a delivery to my workplace nearby. I paid through slice (credit card) and when the order arrived my co-worker paid the delivery driver, not realizing I had already paid. I called the place and they told me to take it up with slice! I called slice and they said they couldn't help me! I'm going to try and get the cred card back to void the payment. UNbelievable! In Whippany, try Johnny's pizza or Paulie G's deli.
Mike Voiland
Great place to catch a bite to eat. With a good sized menu and many types of pizza by the slice this place is the go to. Easy access on and off of route 10
I ordered a plain slice and barbeque slice. The plates they serve the pizza on are so flimsy and small that when the pizza was brought to the table the server, had to put his bare hands on the pizza (holding the crust with his thumb) to prevent the pizza from falling off the plate. Really didn't like the idea of his hands on my food. The plate wasn't big enough for the pizza and so the pizza touched the table. When I asked for extra plates so it would actually fit the pizza and prevent it from touching the table, he gave me a single plate. The pizza crusts are so thin that the pizza falls apart before you can eat it. Hope they implement some changes
Whippany pizza is good. The pizza is pretty good, have not tried any other dishes. The workers are friendly and do a good job.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
I haven’t been able to find a pizza place in the area that I really like and then I found Whippany Pizza. I’ve had their pizza, dinners, salads, and calzones (deep fried) and have not been disappointed yet. The food is always ready when they say and the people who work their are friendly. You have to try them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Decided to eat here before catching the polar express train, great service and they worked with my sons food allergies and I noticed the worker/owner giving some kids who were probably known customers free slices because they didn't have money. Awesome service in the little time I had
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was ready on time and it tasted good.
Service is GREAT. Pizza is ok. My daughter loves the garlic knots and mozzarella sticks. Easy parking
Food was terrible, owner seemed clueless. Wouldn’t recommend. Can definitely tell the food is pre made and comes frozen
Great pizza, crusty. Not too many seats inside and quite small but the food is good which is the most important.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brand new pizzeria! Located on Rt 10 W in the new high rise complex next to CVS. MUST GO HERE! The food is top notch, plentiful, fresh and excellently priced. Check out the menus I posted- their full menu and Lunch Menu. The people who work there are so friendly and accommodating. The atmosphere is clean and pleasant. They have so many options to choose from. The pizza case is always full with fresh pizza, garlic knots, empanada, etc. Come by, enjoy and support this new business. You will be satisfied! To boot they also have a family special you literally cannot beat. It’s a large pie, garlic bread, mozzarella sticks, Caesar salad and a 2 liter soda for……?$26.95!!! Get it! You won’t regret it!! Especially if you’ve got a small crowd, kids or kids and their friends!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken Pizza
Nothing annoys me more than a wrong order. Ordered pizza, peppers and onions. Delivered pizza with pepperoni and onions.Probably won't order again due to mistake. Tried to call but no answer.
Restaurantji Recommends
For a pizza place, the pizza is really not that good. Tried it in slices and pies multiple times, only to be disappointed over and over.However, the pastas were pretty good. Until today, all bland. The chicken fingers looked old and obviously just frozen. Same goes for the fried calamari.Lastly, I typically order for 5-10 people and they wanted an extra .50 cents for some crushed peppers. Cmon now.Edit: I think your response pretty much sums it up. Seems like there’s other reviews that state your pizza isn’t that good. So what? And you’re right, I can have my own opinions. And I decided to express it here after order multiple orders.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
I have had nothing but a great experience. My other go to place kept messing up our orders and was very overpriced. Whippany Pizza has great prices, good food and the order is always correct and on time delivery. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza I have had in a long time. Excellent presentation and super clean, but the taste was the best part.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken Pizza
I work nearby. I ordered two sandwiches for pickup. I walk in with a smile and ask the girl have you got my sandwiches, which I could see were sitting on top of the pizza oven. The place was empty. The manager (owner?) immediately copped a nasty attitude. 'What sandwiches?" "For who?" He was practically yelling. I gave him my name, still smiling, and the clown throws his hands up in the air like I had done something wrong. The friendly teenaged girl got my sandwiches and as the guy was walking away I told him "they should have been easy to find, it looks like that 's the only business he's had."That made him go ballistic. I walked out, still smiling, and I could hear him still bitching about HOW I asked for my "two sandwiches". Recently I ordered a delivery to my workplace nearby. I paid through slice (credit card) and when the order arrived my co-worker paid the delivery driver, not realizing I had already paid. I called the place and they told me to take it up with slice! I called slice and they said they couldn't help me! I'm going to try and get the cred card back to void the payment. UNbelievable! In Whippany, try Johnny's pizza or Paulie G's deli.
Great place to catch a bite to eat. With a good sized menu and many types of pizza by the slice this place is the go to. Easy access on and off of route 10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza