12 Best Italian Restaurants in Wildwood

“Our family celebrated my husband's 60th birthday at Venezia last night. There were 16 of us. Milo went out of his way both ahead of time and that night to be sure that my husband's event was special. Milo offered us a semi-private dining area. It was very intimate and quaint and we felt like we were the only party at the venue. The food, which goes without saying, was absolutely delicious. Milo had nine appetizers ready for us, along with our wine, beer, ice, and favors set-up. Our meals were wonderful. My very favorite was the Gnocchi Sorento. The gnocchi are truly little pillows of deliciousness. I highly recommend Venezia for a romantic dinner or a larger party with your favorite people. Thank you to Milo and Venezia for a wonderful night! We will surely be back!“

“The ambiance is amazing at Santorini. The place is so well lit up and the music is fantastic. The Scallops were cooked to perfection and left me wanting more. Delicious! The short rib with risotto was again cooked to perfection and was delicious. The wine list was a bit pricy with Cabernet at 11/glass and 24/glass for Farmsted but they too were excellent. The service was perfect and desert tiramisu was also delicious. Stop by this restaurant and you won't be disappointed!!! Steviesil!“

“Santorini is a real delight!! The ambience transports you to the Greek Isles while the food and drink delight your taste buds. The staff is friendly and the menu appropriately priced. It's becoming rarer and rarer to find a restaurant on the Cape the offers what it promises- most now over charge and under deliver, Santorini, however does not. Delicious!“

“Stephen’s was a Great Find for my wife and I. Everything was awesome from the friendly service to the gourmet food. My Ribeye was cooked to perfection as was my wife’s broiled seafood combo.Thankyou Steven’s for a Great Evening! We will certainly be back as regulars but next time, with family and friends. …..The Bakers“

“Taken to high heights with simple humble delicious dishes and musiiiicccc! They gave us cake and coffee at the end of the meal to celebrate our friend, they took a song request- we danced we laughed we loved. ? These beans recommend others order the escarole, beans and sausage.“

“This place has the best ? slices!!!! ? Definitely try the buffalo chicken, or BBQ chicken, white pizza with ricotta cheese, even their plain slices and pepperoni was delicious. Also the staff was very nice and didn't even charge me when I asked them for a few cups of ice( being that they are on the boardwalk I figured they would have charged me but they did not) so if you haven't tried this place out yet, GO check it out, you won't be disappointed ??? “

“Long time customer. Love the service, food, atmosphere, BYOB, large portions, delicious bread!Favorites include Prime Rib, Fried Seafood Combo, Shrimp Fra Diavolo, Shrimp/ Chicken Parmigiana, Chicken Marsala, Fried Flounder, Fried Calamari.Parking is a challenge in season.“

“As a pizza maker Dave Portnoy really under scored this place he gave me an 8.3 I would rate Poppi’s pizza a 7.8 I ordered all of their recommendation and was not disappointed in anyway they serve an amazing Neapolitan style pie with a great dough, and amazing sauce and delicious mozzarella“

“Very welcoming staff and good food at a good price. They keep to the express too and I have been known to drop in for a gab. Open kitchen so really good value.I run from cape may to here (they have some locations) and its a nice jaunt. Not gonna call it the best spot in town if you are a fueler but it might be the best option and hands down not even close. If you are lucky enough you might even get gone with a six pack - of cannoli! The staff mix it on the spot and the environment including their friendliness built me toward a 60 VO max, hoping for a bit higher but the canolies are tempteous to say the least as much as the folks and staff. Worst comes to worst just breeze or head on by the boardwalk location for a hopeful sighting or wiff of the sauce if you are a strict typer. of runner or athlete.“

“Did a family style dinner on 2.29.2024. It was a great time, food was delicious and the portions were very generous! The staff was friendly and accommodating too. They don't have a full bar of their own but, otherwise I'd have given them a 5 star review. However BYOB is just fine and they are able to order beer and mixed drinks from the bar next door without any issues. Recommend!“

“Look my friend Moe Green told me about this place and he was right it's the best pizza on the island. Stevie Paglione is the best pizziola on the island. Only God makes a better pie. The sauce crust and cheese were cooked to perfection and it tastes like the award winning pie that it has always been. Romeo's is da BEST“

“I love this place …. The seafood is always fresh, and anything you can add the (Jackie) sauce to I would highly recommend .Favorite appetizer there is the spicy calamariFavorite dinner is the blackened Seabass over linguine with the (Jackie) sauceAnd if you like garlic, the family style house salad is to die for“