It was my first time picking up bagels from here. The bagels were not cooked thoroughly. I could pull balls of dough off. Never again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Cindy Cav
Love their bagels.. soft and fresh
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
bob murison
Great bagel and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sebastian Spahn
Great bagels, great service!
Michelle Pressler
Best service ever! I went before to get bagels and they were delicious. The people are so understanding and are very kind. I definitely recommend!
Michael Tobin
Eh. Bagels are fine but don't get a sandwich.
Charles Lieberman
I like the bagels made here. I usually get there early and everything is fresh. I find the people behind the counter to be friendly. Have never been given a burnt bagel.I did not notice if they wore gloves and my preference is no gloves. They are not surgeons, they sell bagels. I find gloves just make for needless waste. At my home no one wears sterile gloves when preparing food or eating.
jason pyo
I love bagels, so I always go to bagel shop. This is the most delicious bagel shop in New Jersey that I have ever been to.Trust me and eat it?
Matthew Kim
Everything bagel with Taylor ham, cheese, egg, ketchup, and salt and pepper. Very good sandwich.
Masklyn A.
The bagels here are absolutely delicious, however, for the past 2 weeks in a row, we have been shorted in our order and also given incorrect items. Just this week, we ordered 15 bagels: 4 sesame; 2 rye; 3 cinnamon raisin; 3 egg; 1 pumpernickel; 1 whole wheat everything; 1 health (grains and nuts, I think that's what it's called, my wife picked them up and that was hers).We did NOT get the pumpernickel and we got a whole wheat WITHOUT the everything, so it was a whole wheat nothing bagel.The previous week was similar.The other issue is consistency. One of the sesame bagels was of a normal size, one was about 60% of that size and two of them were the size of softballs (one of which was extremely overcooked).This is an indication of poor training of the employees. Whoever is in the prep area and the people in the front of house either don't really pay attention to what they are doing or they just don't care. Both attitudes are fatal to a business, in the long run.I called and spoke to "Angela" who promised us recompense for the errors next week, when we come in, but we will see if that happens.Stay tuned.
Consistent for the most part but nothing like the previous owners where everything was perfect. Very slow and always try to put on cheese when you say no cheese
Matthew T
used to be a go to for me. unfortunately, they drove priced way too high and put way less product on it. Will not be returning.
Michael Barreiro
I can’t believe that a business in North Jersey would have the courage to sell a Taylor Ham Egg and Cheese like this. I was in town for work, paid $16 for two of these with a large coffee and a small fairlife shake. When I got back to my desk I couldn’t believe what I was looking at. I didn’t have the ability to go back and complain, but this is disrespectful. How they could have 4 1/2 stars serving like this is beyond me.
Rafaello Reviews
If you're looking for the best bagels in town, look no further than Wyckoff Bagels. This place is a hidden gem that you don't want to miss. The staff is always friendly and welcoming, and they know your order as soon as you walk in. The bagels are simply amazing, with a perfect crunch on the outside and a soft, chewy texture on the inside. And don't even get me started on their croissants - they're out of this world! If you're in the area, do yourself a favor and stop by Wyckoff Bagels. You won't regret it!
It was my first time picking up bagels from here. The bagels were not cooked thoroughly. I could pull balls of dough off. Never again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Love their bagels.. soft and fresh
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great bagel and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great bagels, great service!
Best service ever! I went before to get bagels and they were delicious. The people are so understanding and are very kind. I definitely recommend!
Eh. Bagels are fine but don't get a sandwich.
I like the bagels made here. I usually get there early and everything is fresh. I find the people behind the counter to be friendly. Have never been given a burnt bagel.I did not notice if they wore gloves and my preference is no gloves. They are not surgeons, they sell bagels. I find gloves just make for needless waste. At my home no one wears sterile gloves when preparing food or eating.
I love bagels, so I always go to bagel shop. This is the most delicious bagel shop in New Jersey that I have ever been to.Trust me and eat it?
Everything bagel with Taylor ham, cheese, egg, ketchup, and salt and pepper. Very good sandwich.
The bagels here are absolutely delicious, however, for the past 2 weeks in a row, we have been shorted in our order and also given incorrect items. Just this week, we ordered 15 bagels: 4 sesame; 2 rye; 3 cinnamon raisin; 3 egg; 1 pumpernickel; 1 whole wheat everything; 1 health (grains and nuts, I think that's what it's called, my wife picked them up and that was hers).We did NOT get the pumpernickel and we got a whole wheat WITHOUT the everything, so it was a whole wheat nothing bagel.The previous week was similar.The other issue is consistency. One of the sesame bagels was of a normal size, one was about 60% of that size and two of them were the size of softballs (one of which was extremely overcooked).This is an indication of poor training of the employees. Whoever is in the prep area and the people in the front of house either don't really pay attention to what they are doing or they just don't care. Both attitudes are fatal to a business, in the long run.I called and spoke to "Angela" who promised us recompense for the errors next week, when we come in, but we will see if that happens.Stay tuned.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great breakfast sandwich.
Consistent for the most part but nothing like the previous owners where everything was perfect. Very slow and always try to put on cheese when you say no cheese
used to be a go to for me. unfortunately, they drove priced way too high and put way less product on it. Will not be returning.
I can’t believe that a business in North Jersey would have the courage to sell a Taylor Ham Egg and Cheese like this. I was in town for work, paid $16 for two of these with a large coffee and a small fairlife shake. When I got back to my desk I couldn’t believe what I was looking at. I didn’t have the ability to go back and complain, but this is disrespectful. How they could have 4 1/2 stars serving like this is beyond me.
If you're looking for the best bagels in town, look no further than Wyckoff Bagels. This place is a hidden gem that you don't want to miss. The staff is always friendly and welcoming, and they know your order as soon as you walk in. The bagels are simply amazing, with a perfect crunch on the outside and a soft, chewy texture on the inside. And don't even get me started on their croissants - they're out of this world! If you're in the area, do yourself a favor and stop by Wyckoff Bagels. You won't regret it!