First time here and it was an amazing experience! The pizza was so good, i ate every single thing from the top to the crust!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Our Favorite Pizza
Melissa Barbarisi
My family visited on Sunday. We ordered at the counter and ate in the dining room. The guys who worked there were very courteous. There was a problem in the kitchen, so our food was taking a while to be served. They gave our table and another table slices of pizza to eat while we waited. Excellent customer service and excellent food!!
Excellent pizza! Staff is young and a little lost. But the boss there keeps things in line. Worth wading through a the confusion for a good slice.
Kelly P.
Pretty good pizza spot in NJ. We ordered 2 Sicilians slices , buffalo chicken and chicken bacon slices. All were really delicious. The Sicilians were extra fluffy which I loved. It's also really decently priced.
Madeleine A.
Stopped in here a few days ago for a couple of slices and man, they did not disappoint. I usually order two slices when I'm trying out a new place: cheese and margharita. Both were excellent! I preferred the cheese over the margharita, the dough was a little more foldable and I liked the flavor of the cheese. If I lived closer to this place I would probably stop in every week honestly.
Paul NJ
Food is good. Overpriced. 2 apps and a veal dish $54 takeout. They charge a credit card fee so I paid cash. They have the tip jar on counter which irks me big time. I never tip takeout. Ballsy. I tip service industry people who make a service industry minimum wage and work for tips. Not takeout food. Servers, bartenders, bellhop, housekeeping, valet, etc.
aliza rosen
Great food, nice people. We go often. Highly recommend!!!Kid-friendliness: Yes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Sticks, Grilled Cheese Panini, Pan Pizza, Chicago Pan Pizza, Margherita Pizza Slice, Garlic Knots, Our Favorite Pizza
Yolanda Houston-Oduneye
I work near hear. The pasta with vodka sauce is great also the Buffalo wings. Ooh and the pizza. One of the best. If you can order ahead.
Ann
Why is chicken cutlet sandwich made with chicken fingers ? I just picked up chicken cutlet sandwich it is a cutlet when I called an asked that question a few weeks ago young lady who answered phone said it was made with chicken fingers !! Glad I took a Chance tried it delicious like everything else at Wyckoff
Food: 5
Service: 5
Abs Gordon
Great weekday pizza place. Wings, salads, pizza. Everything very good. Not much room for groups and not much of a sense of atmosphere. If I lived nearby it’s probably a place I’d stop at on my way to bring home a quick meal.
3.00$ fee for delivery that goes to the owner not the delivery guy is just criminal. Last delivery for
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 3
Mary Carroll
We ordered an 18" Traditional Pizza that was delivered during halftime of the Jets-Giants game! We thought we'd try something different, so for toppings we ordered eggplant, spinach, and broccoli. All I can say is WOW! The eggplant was grilled to perfection, not mushy, not bitter...just perfect! I probably would have liked more spinach and broccoli but I'm not complaining! Two slices and I'm stuffed!
Food: 5
Kathy Greenwood
We order quite often and are never disappointed. Food and service are great.We had food catered once again and everything was delicious and all of our company were very happy! I had no left overs for me to enjoy later on!!! Kudos to all at Wyckoff Pizza!!!
Hannah C.
Great pizza on par with NJ standards for sure. Mozzarella sticks are better than I've had at most places - more fresh and a better cheese pull! Highly recommend if you're in the area. Service is friendly and pizza was made in a timely manner. Though it's not my jam, my friends rave about the salads here! Not really a sit in place, better for takeout based on the interior.
Trucking Designer
Amazing pizza, delicious, Clean, variety of food .Workers are so nice and
First time here and it was an amazing experience! The pizza was so good, i ate every single thing from the top to the crust!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Our Favorite Pizza
My family visited on Sunday. We ordered at the counter and ate in the dining room. The guys who worked there were very courteous. There was a problem in the kitchen, so our food was taking a while to be served. They gave our table and another table slices of pizza to eat while we waited. Excellent customer service and excellent food!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Potato Skins, Grilled Chicken Panini, Plain Cheese Pizza
Excellent pizza! Staff is young and a little lost. But the boss there keeps things in line. Worth wading through a the confusion for a good slice.
Pretty good pizza spot in NJ. We ordered 2 Sicilians slices , buffalo chicken and chicken bacon slices. All were really delicious. The Sicilians were extra fluffy which I loved. It's also really decently priced.
Stopped in here a few days ago for a couple of slices and man, they did not disappoint. I usually order two slices when I'm trying out a new place: cheese and margharita. Both were excellent! I preferred the cheese over the margharita, the dough was a little more foldable and I liked the flavor of the cheese. If I lived closer to this place I would probably stop in every week honestly.
Food is good. Overpriced. 2 apps and a veal dish $54 takeout. They charge a credit card fee so I paid cash. They have the tip jar on counter which irks me big time. I never tip takeout. Ballsy. I tip service industry people who make a service industry minimum wage and work for tips. Not takeout food. Servers, bartenders, bellhop, housekeeping, valet, etc.
Great food, nice people. We go often. Highly recommend!!!Kid-friendliness: Yes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Sticks, Grilled Cheese Panini, Pan Pizza, Chicago Pan Pizza, Margherita Pizza Slice, Garlic Knots, Our Favorite Pizza
I work near hear. The pasta with vodka sauce is great also the Buffalo wings. Ooh and the pizza. One of the best. If you can order ahead.
Why is chicken cutlet sandwich made with chicken fingers ? I just picked up chicken cutlet sandwich it is a cutlet when I called an asked that question a few weeks ago young lady who answered phone said it was made with chicken fingers !! Glad I took a Chance tried it delicious like everything else at Wyckoff
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great weekday pizza place. Wings, salads, pizza. Everything very good. Not much room for groups and not much of a sense of atmosphere. If I lived nearby it’s probably a place I’d stop at on my way to bring home a quick meal.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chicken Waldorf Salad, Our Favorite Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
3.00$ fee for delivery that goes to the owner not the delivery guy is just criminal. Last delivery for
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 3
We ordered an 18" Traditional Pizza that was delivered during halftime of the Jets-Giants game! We thought we'd try something different, so for toppings we ordered eggplant, spinach, and broccoli. All I can say is WOW! The eggplant was grilled to perfection, not mushy, not bitter...just perfect! I probably would have liked more spinach and broccoli but I'm not complaining! Two slices and I'm stuffed!
Food: 5
We order quite often and are never disappointed. Food and service are great.We had food catered once again and everything was delicious and all of our company were very happy! I had no left overs for me to enjoy later on!!! Kudos to all at Wyckoff Pizza!!!
Great pizza on par with NJ standards for sure. Mozzarella sticks are better than I've had at most places - more fresh and a better cheese pull! Highly recommend if you're in the area. Service is friendly and pizza was made in a timely manner. Though it's not my jam, my friends rave about the salads here! Not really a sit in place, better for takeout based on the interior.
Amazing pizza, delicious, Clean, variety of food .Workers are so nice and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5