Buttercrust Pizza

2015 U.S. Rt. 66 suite 1, Moriarty
(505) 832-6900

Recent Reviews

Charlesanthony

Charged 160 dollars for a large pizza and sent to my bank for fraud.somethings gotta change!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Unique TheeSlayer

The new owners have done the most amazing job with turning this pizzeria around and making sure it is a small town hospitable place! I was having an extremely hard night and I just wanted to fast feed my family! This family made my night tonight! Thank you guys so much!

shari white

This place is HORRIBLE. We have attempted to order three separate times to give this a change. We have ordered spaghetti (a TOTAL joke, sauce from a can with noodles that were overcooked) pizza (much like a little Ceasars) and two sandwiches that were my ULTIMATE thing to tell folks why NOT to eat here, sooooo GROSS!! It had carrots or something on it. A HOT SANDWICH that was nasty enough we LITERALLY chucked it and ate a bowl of cereal. I've noticed the owner comes on here and instead of just accepting what folks say and either ignoring it or GOD FORBID!!! Realizing her food is trash, she comes on here and argues with people who do not care for her food. It's obnoxious and rude and comes off as someone who actually KNOWS their food is trash but is stuck with it for some reason so she DIES ON THE HILL of her food when it would be so easy to relax and take some criticism to heart. Quit thinking your food is bomb (it SOOO VERY MUCH, isn't) and start tweaking some of this! This stuff is fixable!! You can't be this bad in a town this small and be this obnoxiously arrogant and survive. This restaurant will ABSOLUTELY NOT be here in a few years, and this woman will blame EVERYTHING and EVERYONE except her terrible food. But here she comes to blame ME or her supplier or her staff....ANYONE but her terrible food decisions.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Bion Shelden

I got pizza and buffalo wings. The wings were some of the worst looking wings I've ever seen. They appeared to have been boiled in water and then lightly sauced. The manager said that's how they come out from being "baked", but there was no hint of color from browning on the wings that one sees on baked wings. Their texture was quite slimey and unappetizing. The pizza (hand-tossed) was adequate and unremarkable; akin to very well made little cesars.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Dutch Shaver

First time and now hooked! Priced right! Loved the atmosphere. ZOOM, BOOM, AND YUMMY! Highly recommended!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hawaiian, Cheese Pizza

Guy Madsen

Hit and miss. The pan pizza is good, the Chicago deep dish is bad. Not sure how this is the best pizza in New Mexico when it's no inconsistent.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: The Works Pizza

Greg Hinze

It was

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Sausage

zack coe

The crusty crab pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ryan Whitehead

Great calmness and they just added churros to the menu

Larissa Barreras

owner harasses customers and has employees harrass as well when they get a bad review, very rude and unprofessional

Shannon Sullivan

I don't go here anymore due to the owner blasting their customers when they don't leave good reviews. then has her employees and friends harass you. very unprofessional

Jeremy Goble

Pizza is not good. Think frozen pizza from Wal-Mart, but you also have to pay more and deal with the owner glaring at you from the back because you asked for an extra side of blue cheese dressing. At least the girl at the register was friendly.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

Roger Bender

Had the Chicago Beef Calzone. EXCELLENTParking: Plenty of itKid-friendliness: Nice atmosphere for kidsWheelchair accessibility: Lots of room

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Deep Dish Cheese Pizza

Nic

Phone was answered by very professional and kind lady ( sorry I didn’t memorize her name). She knew the menu extremely well, was not rude when I needed to be corrected on the size of a specialty pizza because I did not read on the size it comes in.Husband picked up three pizzas, a full garden salad with added ham, and the cinnamon nuggets.Atmosphere was very laid back inside and the same courtesy and professionalism was still shown in person as it was on the phone.‘The Dexter’ , ‘ The Pinto’ , and cheese pizza all were delicious. Very simple pizzas with delicious flavor and of course the ‘butter crust’ just adds to the flavor.Salad was very fresh and I like how the condiments come separate in the bag.The dessert of course , just can’t go wrong with just the right amount of cinnamon and frosting ( see photo).Highly recommend this local business due to their professionalism , kind, honest friendly staff, and great options of food to choose from with very fair pricing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salad, Green Chili

Angelica Ortiz

This place was amazing fast service clean spot to stop! I lost my id while here and worker found it outside in the parking lot it was returned to me! The pizza here is amazing ? frist time here and I will be returning for more delicious food!!!Parking: Lots of safe parking right at front doorKid-friendliness: Kid safe place clean quiet alcohol free (for now)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Deep Dish Cheese Pizza

Load More