Pizza Restaurants near New Waterford

“Amazing food and staff!! Pizza was the best so light and fluffy, sauce was just perfect and the chicken is just amazing also so crispy and juicy:) I think everyone should give this a try!! The homemade donair sauce is a must try loved it so much❤️ and the most best part is they call when your order is ready so it doesn’t sit and get soggy like other shops“

“Best pizzeria style Pizza you will ever have. Lots of toppings and exclusively use Only HORYL'S Pepperoni and also have amazing Subs and Burgers, especially Steak Sub. Own homemade donair meat which makes a great pizza and both super donair (with cheese) and Regular donair all reasonably priced. Best part is 100% locally owned and operated for over 25years.“

“It was getting late, I didn't feel like cooking and Big Daddy's wasn't answering the phone, so I figured I'd give Fat Boys a try. We ordered a medium combination and 1lb of wings. I would rate the pizza a solid 7/10. The dough was soft and not too thick, a decent amount of sauce, a generous layering of pepperoni, a nice thick layer of cheese and a reasonable smattering of mushrooms and green peppers. Everyone I dealt with from the phone call to pick up was polite and it took less than 20 minutes. I know it's often impossible to get through to Big Daddy's because it's the town favourite, so give Fat Boys a chance, it might surprise you.“

“Our waitress was the best her name was Akansha. She went above to make sure our dining experience was everything we wantedKid-friendliness: Great fun atmosphere and food selection for children. The robot is fun too. Friendly staff!We come with our grandchildren on a regular basis.“

“The food was absolutely excellent—so fresh and delicious?! The staff were incredibly polite and professional, which just made the whole experience even better. I'd give their service and food a perfect 10/10 rating without hesitation. The environment was so friendly and welcoming, and let me tell you, their pizza toppings are the best, truly fresh! You've got to trust me on this one—pay them a visit and taste it for yourself. Once you do, you'll never forget it❤️“

“Pizza67 offers decent pizza. The service is generally good. The restaurant itself has a casual atmosphere, perfect for a quick bite with friends or family. The pizza toppings are fresh, and the crust is satisfactory, although nothing extraordinary. Bit overpriced compared to the quantity and size of pizza offered. Overall, it's a solid option for a no-fuss pizza meal, but don't expect anything exceptional.“

“Always loved Kay's. When I was a child, our grading day gift was treat money to go to Kay's for lunch. It was a big deal - had fries, sat on a stool & felt like a big shot. Kay & the staff always talked to us like we were important customers. One of my special memories.“

“I ordered 8 pizzas a day in advance for my daughter's birthday party. My husband went to pick them up and they told him the order wasn't placed. They eventually found the order about 15 minutes later and told him it would be 40 minutes to make the pizza (the party would be over). I understand mistakes happen but zero attempts were made to rectify the situation and we were met with attitude. If you are having a party I suggest ordering from Greco they had them ready in 20 minutes. I will never be back and I will be sure to spread the word to everyone I know having parties near by. **update** spoke to manager who was extremely understanding of the situation. probably won't be back but hopefully this doesn't happen to someone else**“

“Got a Pizza sub. Really good, roll was very fresh, tasty. Good prices, Cash Only. Was busy, but didn't take long, lots of phone orders and people picking up, so showed me that it's a good place to eat from. Kinda Mom and Pop like place. ?“

“They are my go-to for great pizza ! Lots of cheese and HEAVY to lift - really a lot of WEIGHT for the money. Very friendly and courteous. I have a huge appetite and a small combo fills me !it's a special treat to go there.- Bob McG.“

“Pizza is only bested by their amazing staff.Great taste. Fair price.Lots of menu items available and daily specials. Our favorite is the pizza (half combo, half pep and cheese), pop, and garlic fingers with real bacon. We order our food well done as seen in photos below. Yum!“

“This is by far the best pizza on the island hands down. The sauce is amazing. If you haven't had one of the open loaded pizza burgers you not truly living. The pizza turn over will change your life. Massive amount of pepperoni. Just smiply perfect! Amazing staff great family business.“

“Foods always greats but they needa make sure the people answering the phone can understand English. Order a pizza told them I'd have delivery pick it up and I'd like it made 30min later. More then 5 times I explained that not only was I told while drinking I'd be better to come pick it up cause delivery would take 45min(why I asked not to prepare it for 30min) but I also asked for a bottle of coke and was told to just pick it up when I got there like fr. After saying delivery would pick it up and there's other orders I'm getting from them needless to say the pizza was great arrived ice cold because I'm damn sure they didn't understand what for this time meant. Sorry to say but my lanta get that girl off the phone.“

“Ordered a pizza + garlic fingers for delivery to our truck, and I must say it is the best pizza I've had in a while! We will be enjoying it on our long drive home. If we're ever in the area again, we will definitely be stopping in/ordering again.“