Great looking pizza. It is however cracker crust style. The toppings are great the sauce is good, just not a fan of cracker style. Tad greasy on the bottom with a grease aftertaste. Cheese leaves no pools of oil with is great. Next time will go with the sandwiches. For folders, not foldable.Cash only, order at the bar. We did toss out the half that we were taking home. I know they love cracker style in St. Louis, they must have too much lead in their water.
Klaire B.
I paid 36$ for a cardboard pie and waited 40 minutes. Only good thing about this is we got to get a margarita upstairs while we waited. If you are in Alex Bay go to Josie's pizza instead.
Keith Wright
Pay attention, you can figure out most the people giving good reviews are locals. Horrible customer service, Pete the owner is racist and thinks he's above everyone besides family members. Chicken is kept in open containers in a cooler that staff from 2 different establishments can use. Wich I see as a serious health code violation. Nothing good about any of the food, it's all gross.
Michael Sortino
The pizza was very good. It was a little pricey, and they did not take credit cards. Everything was self service. There is an ATM on site, but the service fee was not posted so I did not even attempt it
Stacey Hares
All I can speak to is the owner. The place was closed and I parked in the lot to run across the street to grab a slice from josies. I was immediately confronted by a man screaming that I can't park there. I pointed out that I was in a parking space and he stated that I was on his property in front of his business. I told him I would only be 5 minutes. He said if I was not back in 5 he would have my car towed. Pretty harsh especially when the place was closed. Guess I won't be going there
Keith Baxter
Gr8 place for a meal and excellent staff. Great view with outdoor seating.
Birgit Dechant
In New York, Cavallario's Bayside is a culinary gem that has won my heart with its superb Italian food and cozy, welcoming atmosphere. A hidden gem, this family-run eatery offers an exceptional dining experience that will leave you wanting more.When you walk inside Cavallario's Bayside, a charming and welcoming ambiance greets you. Every visit seems exceptional because of the authentic Italian atmosphere that is created by the rustic furnishings, low lighting, and relaxing music.
Jenna Styliadis
My kids said it was the best pizza they’ve ever had. It was good and so was the rest of our food. Loved eating by the water. Order at the counter and pick up your food after. Little wait but we went before the dinner rush and didn’t have to wait to long
I have been visiting Cavallario's from Ontario for over 25 years. Our favorite is the veggie pizza & the wings are delicious too. The owner Pete always remembers us . The service is great and the view to the river is beautiful! Worth a visit!
Bob Flammia
The food was mediocre at best. It was basically a self service setting like McDonalds, place your order carry back to table on a tray and then bus your
karen verno
Waited far too long for pizza and a sandwich. It wasn't crowded and when we questioned Mr Personality at the register he literally gave us dirty looks. Unacceptable!!! He also made us wait far too long at the counter before taking our order. Never again!
Amy Hakala
The Gluten free pizza was delicious! Did not taste like gluten free!
Leonardo Cicerone
I see some negative reviews, but I am kind of a fussy guy and my wife and I had a wonderful time there with family and friends. Food was fantastic. Staff was very cooperative. Understanding food was great.
Great spot for drinks on the river ?
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Great looking pizza. It is however cracker crust style. The toppings are great the sauce is good, just not a fan of cracker style. Tad greasy on the bottom with a grease aftertaste. Cheese leaves no pools of oil with is great. Next time will go with the sandwiches. For folders, not foldable.Cash only, order at the bar. We did toss out the half that we were taking home. I know they love cracker style in St. Louis, they must have too much lead in their water.
I paid 36$ for a cardboard pie and waited 40 minutes. Only good thing about this is we got to get a margarita upstairs while we waited. If you are in Alex Bay go to Josie's pizza instead.
Pay attention, you can figure out most the people giving good reviews are locals. Horrible customer service, Pete the owner is racist and thinks he's above everyone besides family members. Chicken is kept in open containers in a cooler that staff from 2 different establishments can use. Wich I see as a serious health code violation. Nothing good about any of the food, it's all gross.
The pizza was very good. It was a little pricey, and they did not take credit cards. Everything was self service. There is an ATM on site, but the service fee was not posted so I did not even attempt it
All I can speak to is the owner. The place was closed and I parked in the lot to run across the street to grab a slice from josies. I was immediately confronted by a man screaming that I can't park there. I pointed out that I was in a parking space and he stated that I was on his property in front of his business. I told him I would only be 5 minutes. He said if I was not back in 5 he would have my car towed. Pretty harsh especially when the place was closed. Guess I won't be going there
Gr8 place for a meal and excellent staff. Great view with outdoor seating.
In New York, Cavallario's Bayside is a culinary gem that has won my heart with its superb Italian food and cozy, welcoming atmosphere. A hidden gem, this family-run eatery offers an exceptional dining experience that will leave you wanting more.When you walk inside Cavallario's Bayside, a charming and welcoming ambiance greets you. Every visit seems exceptional because of the authentic Italian atmosphere that is created by the rustic furnishings, low lighting, and relaxing music.
My kids said it was the best pizza they’ve ever had. It was good and so was the rest of our food. Loved eating by the water. Order at the counter and pick up your food after. Little wait but we went before the dinner rush and didn’t have to wait to long
Restaurantji Recommends
I have been visiting Cavallario's from Ontario for over 25 years. Our favorite is the veggie pizza & the wings are delicious too. The owner Pete always remembers us . The service is great and the view to the river is beautiful! Worth a visit!
The food was mediocre at best. It was basically a self service setting like McDonalds, place your order carry back to table on a tray and then bus your
Waited far too long for pizza and a sandwich. It wasn't crowded and when we questioned Mr Personality at the register he literally gave us dirty looks. Unacceptable!!! He also made us wait far too long at the counter before taking our order. Never again!
The Gluten free pizza was delicious! Did not taste like gluten free!
I see some negative reviews, but I am kind of a fussy guy and my wife and I had a wonderful time there with family and friends. Food was fantastic. Staff was very cooperative. Understanding food was great.