Jersey Mike's Subs

8100 Transit Rd Suite 300, Amherst
(716) 235-2259

Recent Reviews

Bill Hliwa

We have gotten a few subs here and they have all been very good. Ordered online and ready for pickup on time! Turkey sub with bacon, and tuna sub were both good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Tuna Fish

David Pattison

First time there . It was ok . They were super busy . I didn't really understand the whole concept . They put on alot of meat , which was good . But the selection of toppings and sauces wasn't great . Very pricey too . I didn't get all the hype . I'd rather have Subway to tell you the truth .

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 3

Eric You

Sub was bland, too much mayonnaise, table dirty, cold inside building, it was my first time there. I would go to 1st to firehouse sub, 2nd subway, then sub shop around corner. Will not return.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Marygrace Young

Went to Jersey Mike's for the 1st time. We were very disappointed with their sub. Hardly any toppings to choose from. No hot subs either, only cold ones. They do slice the meat and cheese right in front of you. That part was nice!! No green peppers or olives, which I expected. The place was freezing and hardly any seating. Staff was nice and pleasant. But the taste of the sub itself was nothing to brag about and very bland to me. We won't go back there for subs again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Michele V.

I had their steak and peppers sub about three or four times. I love it!I would recommend this business.

Robert LaPorte

The closest thing to a "New Jersey" sub that you can get around here. Meat is sliced fresh right in front of you.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Perry O

My first time. I saw a Sub made on "You Tube" from Jersey Mike.They called it a "99". Which is a 46/53. Specific assembled sub.Look really good. I went in andThe older server. Said he never heard of it and he has worked at several Mike's. He thought maybe I saw it incorrectly?So I said I would like a Philly Cheese Sub. I got the basic, to go. I was looking at their sizes?They have their own scale for sizes? They must serve a lot of girls...because their basic is not even 6". I just drove +70 milesto try this sub and go to Wegmanns. My phone wasn'tworking inside...So headed for groceries and home.Got home...before unloading.I sat down and ate that Sub...Wow! That was really good. The Server chose wisely. Thanks.I will try the #99 next time. Elmer Approved... Perry

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Mike's Famous Philly

Gary D'Amico

Ordered two xlg Philly steak subs, one reg and one as a wrap. Steak in both was severely overcooked and tasteless dry. Waste of $40.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Val C.

This is the second worst sub I ever had in my life. This is only because there has to be a sub (somewhere in the world) worse than this. But it is the worst sub I ever had for the price. It's the most expensive sub I ever paid for including the higher-end pizza joints that have great but expensive subs. The bread sucks. They put hardly any meat on your sub. It's just all bread and lettuce. It tastes like a low end supermarket sub or Subway. It's hard to believe you pay almost $20 with tax. I would rather have McDonald's. Will never, ever eat here again. Overhyped and overrated.

Christine Hare

Was very expensive for what you got. The music was so load in dining area.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Sandwich

Tony Casey

transit rd..i politely ask the employee 3 times what kind of meat was on the sub in front of us and 3 times he says Italian....um hello anybody home???then he wants to cash me out with only half my order,i said excuse me but i ordered a whole sub,he says no the sub in front of me at cash out is not mine. He didn't explain what he was doing so i told him so, then he insults me by saying the grill is in the back not the front??ok.then the fat one with green hair muttered foul i couldn't understand what she wanted me to hear but it was defiantly sounded insulting.Just another chain rest shaving a dime every wich way. The entitled post millennial employees at this location could care less.besides dibellas subs is much better

Chelsea Fisher

Order was wrong, no one will even say hi to you or acknowledge you if you are waiting for pick up , all around not great I like jersey mikes food but I get let down here a lot

Jaide Holdsworth

Food was alright definitely not the jersey Mike's experience I've got at other stores, didn't get greeted for a while and the crew seemed to have no idea what was going on, messing up sub after sub and I mean quite literally back to back, it was embarrassing to watch. No one taking charge, crew basically avoiding customer contact at all.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

YYZREVIEW

Is my first time ever trying Jersey Mike's subs. I was very very impressed with the food the sub was great the staff were very friendly and helpful making us first-timers decide which great sub to try. The whole concept is amazing open-concept you could see your cold cuts gets sliced in front of you. After some hard decisions I ended up trying Turkey Club. There is absolutely nothing you could say about this. A big commandment to the staff that helped us sorry I didn't get your name. Thanks for making our experience amazing and having one of the best subs I've ever tried

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

melissa iannello

The people there were super super nice to me. I told them it was my first time in there and the food was very fresh. I enjoyed the sub very much. 1000% better than Subway could ever dream of being.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Turkey and Provolone, The Original Italian

Load More