Many options for flavored cream cheese, good seating area if you wanna get work done
Sadia Javaid
I went here and it was absolutely mid. I got 3 different pastries and a few cookies and my total was $87. It all tasted the same with the same cream and flavors. I got 3 different pastries and they all tasted like a wet cake. Do not recommend and especially don’t get the porcupine cake pop dish.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Ada Y.
I was satisfied with the cake from New York Bakery. Surprisingly, it wasn't overly sweet. The service was good, and while the ambiance wasn't particularly notable, it didn't detract from the experience. Overall, I had a positive experience and I would consider returning.
Geof “Chef Geof” Lambert
Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
gerardo austria
Consistent customer when I'm in Astoria NY visiting parents. Or just plain having the urge to have a desert.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fareha Farzana
It was a good bakery before. Now it’s too bad. Whenever I go there to buy cake that looks delicious but at the end they are all wet and moist taste disgusting. I also send some post for better understanding. It’s a shame how they prepare the cake now. I tried every kind of cake. First I thought it’s a mistake and then I found out it happens every time I buy a cake.
Awesome bakery! Soo many options and nice customer service. Cakes, cannolis, cupcakes, tarts, baklava, etc.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Fruit Tarts
Kevin K. Kim
The best bakery in New York City!!The best bakery in the world ? ❤️ ? ? ❣️ ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Madison
Cute little spot with the friendliest service but I’m not convinced they make their own baked goods…
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Mike R.
I love New York Bakery Cafe's Strawberry Cheesecake! Read why... My love affair with New York Bakery Cafe began 10 years ago when my friend from Astoria introduced me to it on my way out of town. (He was taking my car while I was away and driving me to the airport.) Picked up their Strawberry Cheesecake as a birthday present for old friends from Finland that I was meeting up with, in celebration of one of their birthdays - unaware at the time due to fog I'd have to switch airports from LGA to JFK and be stuck there until late at night. It went into the fridge at my mom's in Florida until the morning and then 3 hours by car to Port St. Lucie. We laughed hysterically when opening the box, seeing the flattening Strawberry Cheesecake (pic) but it was still amazing! We devoured it! Cut to now... when visiting my Astoria friend and his family who have since moved to L.A. Of course, I had to bring them one of New York Bakery Cafe's Strawberry Cheesecake. While this trip wasn't as long, navigating the plane change caused the cake to turn on its side. Arriving at night, we planned on enjoy it together after dinner the next day. Before we opened it up, my friend's wife confessed she couldn't wait! (See 2nd pic.) Even on its side, it's equally delicious! (I can attest to that eating the slice in the 3rd pic.) You're my go-to place for Strawberry Cheesecake, New York Bakery Cafe! Thank you for making one so memorably delicious!
Forgot half of my order! Then we're rude to me when I asked for a refund or my food. Saying they could only give me a store credit for the next time I ordered... um there will be no next time after this time. Are you crazy!?!
Nikolaos Drakopoulos
Expensive 12 melomakarona $24….
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Julia H
Great little neighborhood cafe. Lots to choose from. The Napoleon and cheesecake were delicious. Great, friendly service.
my favorite bakery in astoria! everything is always fresh and the staff is so welcoming :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jean L.
Mostly sweet items but such a wide variety. You will find your traditional cupcakes and various cakes, but will also find baklava, somali, cannolis and spinach pie. The oreo brownies are huge!
Many options for flavored cream cheese, good seating area if you wanna get work done
I went here and it was absolutely mid. I got 3 different pastries and a few cookies and my total was $87. It all tasted the same with the same cream and flavors. I got 3 different pastries and they all tasted like a wet cake. Do not recommend and especially don’t get the porcupine cake pop dish.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
I was satisfied with the cake from New York Bakery. Surprisingly, it wasn't overly sweet. The service was good, and while the ambiance wasn't particularly notable, it didn't detract from the experience. Overall, I had a positive experience and I would consider returning.
Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Consistent customer when I'm in Astoria NY visiting parents. Or just plain having the urge to have a desert.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
It was a good bakery before. Now it’s too bad. Whenever I go there to buy cake that looks delicious but at the end they are all wet and moist taste disgusting. I also send some post for better understanding. It’s a shame how they prepare the cake now. I tried every kind of cake. First I thought it’s a mistake and then I found out it happens every time I buy a cake.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Tiramisu, Oreo Cheesecake, Carrot Cake, Red Velvet Cake, Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake, Serano Cake, Strawberry Tres Leches, Strawberry Cheesecake, Baklava Cheesecake
Awesome bakery! Soo many options and nice customer service. Cakes, cannolis, cupcakes, tarts, baklava, etc.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Fruit Tarts
The best bakery in New York City!!The best bakery in the world ? ❤️ ? ? ❣️ ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cute little spot with the friendliest service but I’m not convinced they make their own baked goods…
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
I love New York Bakery Cafe's Strawberry Cheesecake! Read why... My love affair with New York Bakery Cafe began 10 years ago when my friend from Astoria introduced me to it on my way out of town. (He was taking my car while I was away and driving me to the airport.) Picked up their Strawberry Cheesecake as a birthday present for old friends from Finland that I was meeting up with, in celebration of one of their birthdays - unaware at the time due to fog I'd have to switch airports from LGA to JFK and be stuck there until late at night. It went into the fridge at my mom's in Florida until the morning and then 3 hours by car to Port St. Lucie. We laughed hysterically when opening the box, seeing the flattening Strawberry Cheesecake (pic) but it was still amazing! We devoured it! Cut to now... when visiting my Astoria friend and his family who have since moved to L.A. Of course, I had to bring them one of New York Bakery Cafe's Strawberry Cheesecake. While this trip wasn't as long, navigating the plane change caused the cake to turn on its side. Arriving at night, we planned on enjoy it together after dinner the next day. Before we opened it up, my friend's wife confessed she couldn't wait! (See 2nd pic.) Even on its side, it's equally delicious! (I can attest to that eating the slice in the 3rd pic.) You're my go-to place for Strawberry Cheesecake, New York Bakery Cafe! Thank you for making one so memorably delicious!
Restaurantji Recommends
Forgot half of my order! Then we're rude to me when I asked for a refund or my food. Saying they could only give me a store credit for the next time I ordered... um there will be no next time after this time. Are you crazy!?!
Expensive 12 melomakarona $24….
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Great little neighborhood cafe. Lots to choose from. The Napoleon and cheesecake were delicious. Great, friendly service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Napoleon, Strawberry Cheesecake
my favorite bakery in astoria! everything is always fresh and the staff is so welcoming :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mostly sweet items but such a wide variety. You will find your traditional cupcakes and various cakes, but will also find baklava, somali, cannolis and spinach pie. The oreo brownies are huge!