Cooperage Inn

2218 Sound Ave, Baiting Hollow
(631) 727-8994

Recent Reviews

C Sjoen

Always the best food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ginny Butera

Kerri is the best .... we always have a blast w. her !!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dawn DeGraw

Creme Brulee is

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cape coral Steve

Stuff clams are phenomenal, food,staff was excellent! Definitely try their homemade pot pies to go

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Overstuffed Baked Clams, Chicken Pot Pie, Key Lime Pie, Braised Short Rib Pot Pie

Joe Ribaudo

Very good food. Everything on the menu is awesome.Parking: Lots of parking in rearWheelchair accessibility: Handicap parking no stairs to get in

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Overstuffed Baked Clams, Key Lime Pie, Calamari, French Onion Soup Du Jour, Crab Cakes, Rosemary & Garlic Marinated Rack of Lamb, Jumbo Shrimp & Chicken Francaise, Braised Short Rib Pot Pie, Seafood

The bar area is chill, with hi top and sports tv no sound. Drinks were interesting and wine choices varied. My paella was perfect in flavor and quantity. Flan desert devilish. Server Bella was attentive and friendly. Priced just right. 24 years coming here!

My wife and I had a late lunch a 3 PM seating. I had the chicken pot pie and it was amazing. My wife had the pork chop. She ordered the single which was more than enough for her. I should note we shared the mac and cheese appetizer. We each ordered our own dessert. That was a mistake because I was really good but we could not finish it ?. We should have shared it. When we left we purchased a frozen pot pie next to the restaurant (walkable) The portions were more than adequate, our waitress was friendly and professional. We live an hour away and will definitely be back. John

Rich Zbik

When you're on your on.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Pot Pie, French Onion Soup Du Jour, Soup, Short Rib Pot Pie, Braised Short Rib Pot Pie, Seafood

Bruce Boziwick

Excellent food. The staff is great. Nice dinner music.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Pot Pie, Bread Basket

DocT

Consistently good, comfort food, with other more contemporary dishes available. Service always great! Noise level varies, this last time a bit too loud for table conversation between us seniors. Still, my go to place for a good meal.

Maureen Felitti

My family and I Love goin to the Cooperage every Occasion we have. Its always beautifully decorated. Especially in The fall and Christmas. The food and drinks are amazing. The staff is always very professional and friendly..Everyone should check this place out when on the North Fork..

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Overstuffed Baked Clams, Key Lime Pie, French Onion Soup Du Jour, Coconut Cream Pie, Jumbo Shrimp & Chicken Francaise, Potato, Soup, Seafood

Eileen Jones

Everything and everyone were fantastic for my Mom’s funeral luncheon with close family and friends just recently on 4/5/2024. The room was set up as requested. Our main Server Joanne was excellent; friendly, kind, respectful, responsive and was quick to serve and adapt to our group of 31. The food was delicious. It was an intimate setting. Everything was just lovely. Joanne was superb.Parking: Our guests provided our family with great reviews as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Crab Cakes

We arrived and were greeted by a wonderful hostess who wished us a happy anniversary (I had entered that in our reservation). But to have her wish us one was just a nice touch. Our table was in the corner, which was perfect. Our waiter Wade was awesome. We never felt rushed and our meals were delicious. We will definitely be going back again!!

MaryJ

We saw an ad for Cooperage Inn in the Southampton Press magazine and decided to try it. What a great place! It's big and bustling with very friendly desk, wait, and bus staff. The menu is creative, and there are also specials. I had the blackened "catch of the day" which was mahi mahi. It was perfectly cooked and seasoned, accompanied by a good serving of mixed vegetables that were scrumptions. The garlic mashed potatoes were also wonderful. I started with a Cooperage salad, also great. My date had the fried calalmari -- fluffy, crisp, and not one bit greasy with a big bowl of marinara for dipping. His main course was short rib goulash on wide noodles. He's a big guy but he had to take half of it home. The wine list was extensive with wines of the US, the world, and especially Long Island. We also bought a short rib pot pie and key lime pie to go. Can't go back soon enough.

JeannineM

Have eaten at Cooperage Inn several times and never had a bad meal - especially love their signature salad. The menu offers alot of variety, we are able to try something different each time we visit. Desserts are delicious, we tried the special lemon pie this time, it was great. Service was outstanding, we felt well attended to. Restaurant is clean with a warm atmosphere. Can't wait to go again.

Load More