A.J's Grilled Cheese

182 W Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore
(631) 647-9292

Recent Reviews

Geffrey G

This is my favorite restaurant on long Island. We have lost so much during this pandemic and its such a shame this wonderful restaurant is struggling. These are the best sandwiches I have EVER had and I am holding out hope they reopen because I will be first in line to support them. Amazing service and food every time.

Eric Seibert

Boooo. I go out of my way to come here to find them closed in the middle of the afternoon on a Friday?! I will not be back

Jason Rapaccuiolo

Great food. Grilled cheese was amazing. Chips were really good. Service was great.

Steve

Amazing grilled cheese, Everyone needs to try it. BBQ chicken is my favorite!

Ted Reich

Good service, plentiful food. Good specials. When I paid my bill I told the owner my potato was cold and said not to worry, but he ran right into the kitchen to see why. Good attitude and way to make sure the next customer has a hot potato

Melanie H.

I absolutely love this place and will go out of my way to eat here. My go to is the pulled pork grilled cheese with their awesome chips.

Gleb Beleavski

Great grilled cheese with bacon and chicken. Mac and cheese was great

David J.

I've been very excited to try this place and finally got to go since the temporary change to their hours. Inside everyone was extremely friendly. The food however, was not. The food was as bland as bland can be. We ordered 3 different sandwiches and the tomato bisque soup. If I described the complete lack of taste in every single sandwich you'd think I had covid. Even the soup wasn't good. The best part of the meal honestly were the slices of pickle that came with the sandwiches and it breaks my heart.

Saeeda Thompson

Love this place, even with the limited menu, they really do a great job, staff is really great as well.

Frank Mauro

Didn't go there today but very good. Went next door to Amanda s Bakery, which is very very good.

Ryan P.

Sandwich was worth the visit. Even if it's just toasted sourdough. Sides were not. Unsalted fries, cole slaw came in a 1/2 lb deli container and was bubbling... Idk what's so hard about a trip to restaurant depot, they'd have better fries and coleslaw immediately ‍

Leanne R.

i ordered food from here last night and the grilled cheese and tots were good but i ordered their new s'mores pouch/pocket things for dessert bc i never tried it before and they sounded good and even the employee said they were good but then i got them and they were quite literally hockey pucks they were very burnt and it didn't even seem like there were marshmallows in them either i know they'd prob melt into the dough outside but it didn't even have a marshmallow taste but maybe bc they were too burnt that's why? idk they were terrible bottom line do not order these

C M.

Got take out & by the time I was ready to eat at home it was already cold. Chips were soggy. I don't know if it's because of being packed in a wax lined box instead of wax bag or a paper bag. Chips also didn't have any dipping sauce on side. Grill cheese was chewy & didn't stay together. Maybe it's because it wasn't wrapped in foil lined paper wrapper which would keep heat in equaling gooey cheese. Instead of grill cheese in a taco holder... I also tried the tomato bisque soup. It had way too much cream & I swear dried oregano. It's a shame I really wanted to enjoy this. Especially when it came out to close to $20. If they see this review I'm demanding a refund! This meal should get 0 stars. At least it didn't give me food poisoning which would get negative stars

wfc annie

Went in Saturday morning with my friend and the cook in the back was calling the girl in front babe very loudly and they were flirting in front of us while we were waiting for our food which made us very uncomfortable and i saw the guy next to us make a face as well. i feel like you should save your relationship for outside of work. but anyhow the food was alright, a little expensive and you have to order fries separately for an extra charge.

bizzy izzy

Potato chips had zero salt. Got the apple bacon cheese. Was really looking forward. Sandwich had zero seasoning. very bland.

Load More