Great lunch sandwiches. Friends rave about the breakfast egg sandwichs, will give 'em a try and update review. Guys are always busy working!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Turkey Wrap, Virginia Ham, Egg Salad, Roast Beef Melts
Christopher S.
This is your classic Long Island deli with bagels. I grew up about 7 minutes away. I love it so much! Bright Bay definitely has the best egg sandwich in Bay Shore! Their poppy seed rolls are so fresh and their eggs are always cooked to order. The quality of their bacon and cheese complement the eggs so eloquently to make this BEC sandwich the best tasting in Suffolk County. My mom says their chicken salad is very tasty too and their lunch sandwich options are banging! The workers are very kind and make your order just the way you like it without any flaws. They have a large fridge with plenty of beverage options and a coffee station to brew up the Joe prepared to your liking! The vibe inside reminds you of home if you're from the island.
Kendy Cordova
moving out to Suffolk I was concerned that I wasnt going to be able to find a good breakfast deli near me. I tried so many different delis until I came upon Bright Bays Deli. They make such great sandwitches and they dont overcharge like most places do now! I would definitly reccomend this deli to all my friends & family!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rolls, Hero
Brigid C.
I almost don't want to share this bc I don't want long lines. But, this is the best deli in town. It hits all the spots - freshest basic coffee. Always hot, always new. BECs, pastrami, bagels, and homemade cookies! And, if your kids have manners, Sharon might sneak them a cookie while they wait. They also support local community organizations and teams! Best spot in town!
Alexandra Gleason
We didn’t even eat our food yet but need to give 5 stars based off service. My wife and I called an order in for hero’s and we had the NICEST person assisting. I wish I got his name! He was so happy to be there- happy to help. Accommodated my 4738574 requests with a smile on his face. We found you off Google and ensured to check the reviews before- and just thankful to have someone young, who was happy to be there and assist us. He pounded us on the way out- ….! Shows so much about a personality and making an environment for people to want to come back! I don’t know his name- but he deserves a raise! It was 10/25 at 1:45pm. Thank you thank you thank you!
AJ Buquicchio
Basically, a line out the door tells you a lot about a deli.. egg sandwiches were very good.. staff was friendly, helpful & organized. Def will be back..
Alissa Penso
I wish I had more stars to give. We order the 50 person catering package for my mother in laws surprise party. Everything was amazing. Chris came to drop off all the food and supplies. The package included trays of food, heros, salads, paper goods, rolls, cookies and fruit platters. They brought the racks, trays and sternos. They helped set all the food up and it was effortless. The food was delicious and everyone left with bags to go! I highly recommend bright bay deli for catering and all her deli needs!
James Steele
Really need to get their act together. Just waited in line for 15 mins for them to help everyone around me. Ended up leaving with nothing. It’s not that hard to run an efficient deli.
Angelina B.
Always good breakfast sandwiches.
LiliG
Tried this deli for the first time today. Ordered The Cowboy sandwich. It was fantastic! Reminiscent of a Chicago Italianbeef sandwich (minus the gardiniera of course). It could have been heated a little better to melt the mozz but it was still great. Also picked up some cold cuts and rolls. Everything was cut properly and fresh. Will definitely be returning.
The last two times I’ve been in here my sandwiches. I’ve been all screwed up the time before this one now was about two months ago hadn’t been in here since I was passing it today and I said let’s go in and get lunch. I ask for a wrap with grilled chicken chopped lettuce, pepper, jack cheese, with mayo, and a little bit of blue cheese. This is what I got I use to get lunch he two three times a week today is my last timeI picked it open to see what was inside
Tommy Chic
One of the last great Deli's around!
K O
July 2nd 20234ft American/Italian heroLoaded and delicious.Half tray of sausage and peppers the best around here. Great prices, awesome service and the most pleasant and helpful people. Love this deli for everyday and catering needs.
Renaica Harris
Food is good but pricey. They are very busy in the morning.
Lauren Kondracke
Really friendly, really tasty. This hometown deli is a hidden gem!
Great lunch sandwiches. Friends rave about the breakfast egg sandwichs, will give 'em a try and update review. Guys are always busy working!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Turkey Wrap, Virginia Ham, Egg Salad, Roast Beef Melts
This is your classic Long Island deli with bagels. I grew up about 7 minutes away. I love it so much! Bright Bay definitely has the best egg sandwich in Bay Shore! Their poppy seed rolls are so fresh and their eggs are always cooked to order. The quality of their bacon and cheese complement the eggs so eloquently to make this BEC sandwich the best tasting in Suffolk County. My mom says their chicken salad is very tasty too and their lunch sandwich options are banging! The workers are very kind and make your order just the way you like it without any flaws. They have a large fridge with plenty of beverage options and a coffee station to brew up the Joe prepared to your liking! The vibe inside reminds you of home if you're from the island.
moving out to Suffolk I was concerned that I wasnt going to be able to find a good breakfast deli near me. I tried so many different delis until I came upon Bright Bays Deli. They make such great sandwitches and they dont overcharge like most places do now! I would definitly reccomend this deli to all my friends & family!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rolls, Hero
I almost don't want to share this bc I don't want long lines. But, this is the best deli in town. It hits all the spots - freshest basic coffee. Always hot, always new. BECs, pastrami, bagels, and homemade cookies! And, if your kids have manners, Sharon might sneak them a cookie while they wait. They also support local community organizations and teams! Best spot in town!
We didn’t even eat our food yet but need to give 5 stars based off service. My wife and I called an order in for hero’s and we had the NICEST person assisting. I wish I got his name! He was so happy to be there- happy to help. Accommodated my 4738574 requests with a smile on his face. We found you off Google and ensured to check the reviews before- and just thankful to have someone young, who was happy to be there and assist us. He pounded us on the way out- ….! Shows so much about a personality and making an environment for people to want to come back! I don’t know his name- but he deserves a raise! It was 10/25 at 1:45pm. Thank you thank you thank you!
Basically, a line out the door tells you a lot about a deli.. egg sandwiches were very good.. staff was friendly, helpful & organized. Def will be back..
I wish I had more stars to give. We order the 50 person catering package for my mother in laws surprise party. Everything was amazing. Chris came to drop off all the food and supplies. The package included trays of food, heros, salads, paper goods, rolls, cookies and fruit platters. They brought the racks, trays and sternos. They helped set all the food up and it was effortless. The food was delicious and everyone left with bags to go! I highly recommend bright bay deli for catering and all her deli needs!
Really need to get their act together. Just waited in line for 15 mins for them to help everyone around me. Ended up leaving with nothing. It’s not that hard to run an efficient deli.
Always good breakfast sandwiches.
Tried this deli for the first time today. Ordered The Cowboy sandwich. It was fantastic! Reminiscent of a Chicago Italianbeef sandwich (minus the gardiniera of course). It could have been heated a little better to melt the mozz but it was still great. Also picked up some cold cuts and rolls. Everything was cut properly and fresh. Will definitely be returning.
Restaurantji Recommends
The last two times I’ve been in here my sandwiches. I’ve been all screwed up the time before this one now was about two months ago hadn’t been in here since I was passing it today and I said let’s go in and get lunch. I ask for a wrap with grilled chicken chopped lettuce, pepper, jack cheese, with mayo, and a little bit of blue cheese. This is what I got I use to get lunch he two three times a week today is my last timeI picked it open to see what was inside
One of the last great Deli's around!
July 2nd 20234ft American/Italian heroLoaded and delicious.Half tray of sausage and peppers the best around here. Great prices, awesome service and the most pleasant and helpful people. Love this deli for everyday and catering needs.
Food is good but pricey. They are very busy in the morning.
Really friendly, really tasty. This hometown deli is a hidden gem!