Great food, but beware. My husband ordered their "buy 2, get 1 free" deal on Tuesday night, cash only. They knowingly over charged him about $25. Since it was paid in cash and we didn't have the receipt, there was no proof. But the cashier must've been pocketing money is how it seemed. We ordered 2 salad with grilled chicken and penne a la vodka. Should've come to $38, my husband was charged $62. Exact words when my husband asked for a price breakdown were, "salads were $20 each, then plus the chicken, and the pasta was free". There isn't even a $20 salad on the menu. Check your receipts. Food is great but not worth a scam.
Raymond guardado
This the best pizza in bayshore definitely I recommend
Doryan M.
The customer service is AMAZING far better than any other pizza spot we've been too. My family is very happy with the quality of the food. The pizza is superb, we can just tell the ingredients are high quality just be the smell the pizza gives. Shout out to the owner Joe such a nice fella me and him were having a very engaging conversation. He made my family feel very loved and welcomed in his shop. The environment is very clean. I love the ambiance the place gives off, i just can over the way the place made me feel. I very much recommend this place for anyone that is looking for a great time!
I absolutely LOVE this pizzeria. The sauce is so good! My favorites are the plain pizza, pepperoni pizza, and the pepperoni pinwheel. But everything I’ve ever had from the pizzeria has been great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jaime Carballo
I order from this place quite a bit. Pick up is normally ready for me like 15 minutes after I order every time. The pizza is fresh, hot and always waiting for me when I get there. The pizza is also very good. Staff is friendly and efficient and I've never had a problem with my order. Overall good food, good service, and good experience. I will continue to do business with this place. Would also recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Brooklyn Pizza
Mal
Come here weekly. Love everything, especially the chicken bruschetta salad!
Food: 5
Kaitlyn Boland
Absolutely terrible service. I placed a delivery order at 6 pm, and by 7:40 pm the order still did not arrive. When I called the pizzeria and spoke to the manager about this issue, she actually started laughing on the phone. That was the worst service experience I ever had. I will never order from here again. Absolutely awful!
Service: 1
David Rivera
The worst Pizza I ever had it was a greasy mess I don't recommend it
Been going here for over a decade and still by far the best and closest to NY pizza. All time favorite dish is the pene with vodka sauce and breaded chicken! My top fav slice would have to be the Cesar salad slice but honestly you can’t go wrong with anything on the menu10/10 for sure reccomend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Ceasars Slice
Norm A.
The pizza is superb! The staff is friendly. The restaurant is clean. I highly recommend Buseto Pizzeria. I've been coming here for 6 years and we love it!
Carlos Franchino
Excellent quality. Good prices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Danielle lynn
Terrible service had to wait 20 min for zeppoles when they said 5 min called in order get the food and has literally no powered on it smh called to let them know they said sorry our oven is down the people in the back made
Great food, but beware. My husband ordered their "buy 2, get 1 free" deal on Tuesday night, cash only. They knowingly over charged him about $25. Since it was paid in cash and we didn't have the receipt, there was no proof. But the cashier must've been pocketing money is how it seemed. We ordered 2 salad with grilled chicken and penne a la vodka. Should've come to $38, my husband was charged $62. Exact words when my husband asked for a price breakdown were, "salads were $20 each, then plus the chicken, and the pasta was free". There isn't even a $20 salad on the menu. Check your receipts. Food is great but not worth a scam.
This the best pizza in bayshore definitely I recommend
The customer service is AMAZING far better than any other pizza spot we've been too. My family is very happy with the quality of the food. The pizza is superb, we can just tell the ingredients are high quality just be the smell the pizza gives. Shout out to the owner Joe such a nice fella me and him were having a very engaging conversation. He made my family feel very loved and welcomed in his shop. The environment is very clean. I love the ambiance the place gives off, i just can over the way the place made me feel. I very much recommend this place for anyone that is looking for a great time!
Awesome heros & pizza. Don't hesitate❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Pizza Chicken Parmigiana, Garlic Knots
Terrible service
I absolutely LOVE this pizzeria. The sauce is so good! My favorites are the plain pizza, pepperoni pizza, and the pepperoni pinwheel. But everything I’ve ever had from the pizzeria has been great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I order from this place quite a bit. Pick up is normally ready for me like 15 minutes after I order every time. The pizza is fresh, hot and always waiting for me when I get there. The pizza is also very good. Staff is friendly and efficient and I've never had a problem with my order. Overall good food, good service, and good experience. I will continue to do business with this place. Would also recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Brooklyn Pizza
Come here weekly. Love everything, especially the chicken bruschetta salad!
Food: 5
Absolutely terrible service. I placed a delivery order at 6 pm, and by 7:40 pm the order still did not arrive. When I called the pizzeria and spoke to the manager about this issue, she actually started laughing on the phone. That was the worst service experience I ever had. I will never order from here again. Absolutely awful!
Service: 1
The worst Pizza I ever had it was a greasy mess I don't recommend it
Restaurantji Recommends
Food is always good, favorite local spot for
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Been going here for over a decade and still by far the best and closest to NY pizza. All time favorite dish is the pene with vodka sauce and breaded chicken! My top fav slice would have to be the Cesar salad slice but honestly you can’t go wrong with anything on the menu10/10 for sure reccomend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Ceasars Slice
The pizza is superb! The staff is friendly. The restaurant is clean. I highly recommend Buseto Pizzeria. I've been coming here for 6 years and we love it!
Excellent quality. Good prices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terrible service had to wait 20 min for zeppoles when they said 5 min called in order get the food and has literally no powered on it smh called to let them know they said sorry our oven is down the people in the back made
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1