Kitty Mulligans Irish Pub

615 E Main St, Bay Shore
(631) 315-3571

Recent Reviews

Michael sparacino

Amazing Saturday night with DJ Ron playing 80s dance and hits non stop. My friends and I had the time of our life laughing and dancing with Mel the bartender. We will definitely be back !!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chili Cheese, Cheese Fries, Chicken Wings, Huge Pretzel, Chicken Bacon Bomber, Shepherd’S Pie

Eileen Bates-Bordies

I brought a bit of a snob from Babylon, but he was truly impressed with the food and the patronage. Corned beef is outstanding.Hugs to all.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Huge Pretzel

Mike Weiner

Nice place to see a band and have some drinks. Pretzel was real

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Huge Pretzel

Donna Briody

Great food, nice bar, friendly

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jacqueline

The staff always goes above and beyond every time I go here. Whether I stop in for a drink or sit down for dinner with friends and family, we’re never disappointed! Food is great and the staff is even better! So friendly and really make sure you’re taken care of, ensuring you’re having a great time! Would definitely

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anthony Tarlentino

Honestly, one of the worst burgers I've ever eaten in my life.... We went for a band. Ordered beers and the first 2 were completely flat, but they tapped a new keg and made up for that so that is fine. The pretzel app was ok but they ran out of cheese and didn't tell us until the pretzel was already out. Wings were bland, slightly overcooked and half didnt even have sauce on them. The fried pickles were the only good item from the whole night. Fish and chips were basically tasteless and the fries were cold. The burger was ordered as super rare, but what was delivered was a bland beyond well done hockey puck with basically 1 slice of the little cherry tomatoes. I can without question say that I had a better at the food court of the bronx zoo. We went as a family of 6 and literally every single person threw half of their meal away because it was that bad. We would have said something about the food but after it was delivered we never saw the waitress again until we finally got tired of waiting and tracked them down to just pay and get out of the place. Without a doubt, one of, if not the worst meal I have ever had to dish out $175 to pay for. Not to mention the fact that when the food came out, they spilt coleslaw on me and just completely ignored it. I honestly don't understand where these good reviews are coming from. I assuming it's a bunch of regulars or staff? As mentioned, without question, the worst meal I have ever had at any eating establishment.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 2

Joann Kutteh

Great food, great service, fun atmosphere. Burger was delicious. Cooked exactly the way I asked for. Drinks were great. Will definitely be back and often.Just read the other reviews, probably from the group of young guys that were so so rude and obnoxious. They most likely just left nasty reviews with no regard to the owners or staff that were working very hard.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chili Cheese, Chicken Wings

Patty Dodge

Great authentic Irish pub with amazing food and great entertainment! the bartenders and staff on pointI recommend this place to

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Mcgrath

Saw the band revival there on Jan 13th. Band was awesome and drew a tremendous crowd in the place. The staff were awesome and handled the crowd great. Food and drinks were great too!!! Loved itParking: No trouble finding a spotWheelchair accessibility: Very handicap friendly place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chili Cheese, Cheese Fries, Chicken Wings, Huge Pretzel, Chicken Bacon Bomber, Shepherd’S Pie

Jamie Casey

I ordered a medium rare burger and it came out grey and overcooked..they RAN OUT OF PICKLES?!?! And didn’t inform us until I’d already gotten our food and had to ask. They appeared to be severely understaffed for the event we came for, which was to see a band play. We also had a reservation, yet when we arrived, there was nobody to tell us where to go or where our table was. We finally found it on our own after searching and found a table that was already there occupied with a family of 6 at the same table. Would not go again, unless it was for the band that played tonight.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Jonathan Nucatola

The band was great everything else was terrible. From ice cold fries and over done burger..no butter or cheese on a giant pretzel? Flat beer. Cold fried pickles. No plates for

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dan

Great bartender staff great waitresses and some of the freshest food on the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Barbeque Chef

Burger for lunch, again?‍♂️Ordered the Black n Blue Burger, without Lettuce, Tomato, n Sauteed Onions, I want the burger, not the rabbit food?‍♂️Came out perfectly cooked to my liking, Medium Rare.I really, really, like the meat they used, it tasted great to me Not sure what blend meat they use, but it's as good as most of the supposed highly rated burgers around..Would definitely returnService was excellent.. Allie , the bartender, was engaging, and professional.What else do you need?My top 10 is getting crowded., but this is definitely up there

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

J Raso

Great local pub! Food is excellent! We had the shepherds pie, chicken bacon bomber, and mozzarella sticks!…everything is fresh and homemade! Nothing frozen. Service is excellent too! Live music is a plus! Will definitely be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

J B

Great service, loved our bartender she was easy to chat with and friendly. Wished they had a couple more comfy seating options but overall we had a good night.

Load More