Just passing through and stumbled upon this place tucked in the corner. Everything was delicious, 10/10 would pass through again
Paul Federico
great pizza! the grandma is phenomenal
Belle B
I go there all the time food is very good. But the last 3 times I have been there they have messed up the order. Brought pizza to Florida for my parents was supposed to be sausage and pepperoni slices I got sausage and peppers. Didn't realize it until we got to Florida. The next time same thing I called to order slices ordered 4 slices 2 of those slice again sausage and pepperoni got sausage and peppers and they complained that I called in slices I was still on the phone as they complained took that back but it was after I drove all the way home. Tonight ordered a pie half cheese the other half with sausage and pepperoni all over it I got one side sausage and the other side pepperoni. And the guy repeated it to me and still got it wrong. One time I would like to get the correct order.
Bellana F.
I ordered a grandpa pie and garlic knots. I'll give the pie a 6/10 and the knots a 3/10 The star of the pizza was the sauce however the cheese while not that much overwhelmed the flavor profile. The dough is pretty solid. The knots were a 3/10 only because there was no garlic and hardly any butter on them which I'm sure isn't how they're supposed to be. I did eat most of them though because the sauce it came with is phenomenal. I might try another pizza from here again because I did expect more, it looked amazing.
Kenneth Cieri
Purchased a calzone and the ricotta cheese was still cold inside when i took a bite. Place looked dead and had 5 employees standing around and still wasted my money. Never again trash food
Renee D.
Place was great when they first opened and Stefano was there. Since he's gone I find it's not as good. Last night was my last time there. I ordered a pie half black olives and half pepperoni. I got home to see it was green olives. I called and the person was apologetic and said he's made a new pie. Then the owner called and said the reason they put green olives in was because they were out of black, they didn't get the delivery. Soo I paid for a pie I didn't want, and the explanation was ridiculous. They should have called and asked not just assumed that's what I wanted.
Paula B.
Way too much garlic in the sauce on the Grandma pizza. It should be sweet. Adolescent boys maki g noise and generally a silly ruckus. Second visit for me and they were there both times. Not conducive to a peaceful meal. The boys seem to be related to people there. I won't be coming back.
Elizabeth S.
Just moved out to bay shore a couple weeks ago from New Jersey where I had my favorite local pizza spot. The classic New York pizza joint is exactly what I had been looking for. The pizza is incredible. You won't be disappointed. I will be returning time and time again!
Jennifer S.
I was craving a spinach and artichoke slice and have yet to try this pizzeria, but saw they had it on their menu so I picked up a slice of that as well as a Buffalo chicken slice. If you like a really solid crust; one that is light and airy, yet crispy then this place won't disappoint... Both slices had a great crust...the spinach crust was a little thinner while the Buffalo was a bit thicker, but they were both excellent crusts. For the pizza itself; the spinach and artichoke wasn't as good as I had hoped for...while it was loaded with the toppings and looked beautiful, I was lost on finding any cheese...it has a creamy texture, but I felt it was missing something, and I think some mozzarella would definitely go a long way and give it the extra oomph it needs to bring it all together...I was hoping for a slice that would remind me of the famous spinach and artichoke pizza from Artichoke Basille's in the city (which I know is a lot to ask for being they specialize in this pizza)... The Buffalo slice was pretty tasty...the chicken is actually spicy and loaded up on the slice. There's some mozzarella (I would've liked a little more), then the chicken, and a drizzle of blue cheese...the chicken is all white meat and is not breaded...I like to add my own blue cheese dressing for the chunks as opposed to it being drizzled on, but many places do this now, so I ask for a side and get some of the chunks out and add it on myself. I would definitely try them again, but I would opt for a more traditional slice like Sicilian to get a better gauge on sauce and cheese ratio...also to try their pizza sauce. I rated 4 stars (but lean towards a 3.5) because of the crust and overall quality of the ingredients...I think adding mozzarella would make the spinach pizza much better and the Buffalo slice needs to be eaten fresh out of the oven or served extremely hot...I like when you take a bite and the cheese is melty and gooey and stretches and I was missing that here with both slices.
damian a.
I went there once when they first opened and it was good. The second time I tried to order using a coupon I received in the mail. It was going to be like a $35 order but they said they only accept coupons Monday thru Thursday? Why didn't the coupon specify that? Then again I tried to order a $60 order thru Uber eats, after waiting 45 minutes the order was cancelled by the business? What's the deal?
Worst pizza I have had ever, I came because of the good reviews, ingredients tasted rotting, super over priced. Plus the cashier kept refusing and trying to change what I wanted to order even after I agreed to wait they gave me a hard to time on anything I ordered. This is a pizza place right, and they don’t make pizza just whatever they want to feed customers.
Jerry Killane
The Stephano slice and the New York slice and white slice were excellent especially the sauce on the New York slice! Friendly staff, highly recommend!
DDoolz50
I saw the new pizzaria, said,”lets try”. MISTAKE! Brooklyn pie and regular pie. No flavor at all! No good! Had no problems with service or cleanliness. Just bad pizza. Beware of 5 star reviews.
High Pitch Eric Stern
Best pizza i ever had. I don’t really eat much pizza.Throughout my life I’ve been in many pizza places around Patchogue. Funny how all the good ones are in or near Nassau county
Chris M.
New fav pizza place Specialty slices are amazing Stefanos special is not to be missed Nicest owners too
Just passing through and stumbled upon this place tucked in the corner. Everything was delicious, 10/10 would pass through again
great pizza! the grandma is phenomenal
I go there all the time food is very good. But the last 3 times I have been there they have messed up the order. Brought pizza to Florida for my parents was supposed to be sausage and pepperoni slices I got sausage and peppers. Didn't realize it until we got to Florida. The next time same thing I called to order slices ordered 4 slices 2 of those slice again sausage and pepperoni got sausage and peppers and they complained that I called in slices I was still on the phone as they complained took that back but it was after I drove all the way home. Tonight ordered a pie half cheese the other half with sausage and pepperoni all over it I got one side sausage and the other side pepperoni. And the guy repeated it to me and still got it wrong. One time I would like to get the correct order.
I ordered a grandpa pie and garlic knots. I'll give the pie a 6/10 and the knots a 3/10 The star of the pizza was the sauce however the cheese while not that much overwhelmed the flavor profile. The dough is pretty solid. The knots were a 3/10 only because there was no garlic and hardly any butter on them which I'm sure isn't how they're supposed to be. I did eat most of them though because the sauce it came with is phenomenal. I might try another pizza from here again because I did expect more, it looked amazing.
Purchased a calzone and the ricotta cheese was still cold inside when i took a bite. Place looked dead and had 5 employees standing around and still wasted my money. Never again trash food
Place was great when they first opened and Stefano was there. Since he's gone I find it's not as good. Last night was my last time there. I ordered a pie half black olives and half pepperoni. I got home to see it was green olives. I called and the person was apologetic and said he's made a new pie. Then the owner called and said the reason they put green olives in was because they were out of black, they didn't get the delivery. Soo I paid for a pie I didn't want, and the explanation was ridiculous. They should have called and asked not just assumed that's what I wanted.
Way too much garlic in the sauce on the Grandma pizza. It should be sweet. Adolescent boys maki g noise and generally a silly ruckus. Second visit for me and they were there both times. Not conducive to a peaceful meal. The boys seem to be related to people there. I won't be coming back.
Just moved out to bay shore a couple weeks ago from New Jersey where I had my favorite local pizza spot. The classic New York pizza joint is exactly what I had been looking for. The pizza is incredible. You won't be disappointed. I will be returning time and time again!
I was craving a spinach and artichoke slice and have yet to try this pizzeria, but saw they had it on their menu so I picked up a slice of that as well as a Buffalo chicken slice. If you like a really solid crust; one that is light and airy, yet crispy then this place won't disappoint... Both slices had a great crust...the spinach crust was a little thinner while the Buffalo was a bit thicker, but they were both excellent crusts. For the pizza itself; the spinach and artichoke wasn't as good as I had hoped for...while it was loaded with the toppings and looked beautiful, I was lost on finding any cheese...it has a creamy texture, but I felt it was missing something, and I think some mozzarella would definitely go a long way and give it the extra oomph it needs to bring it all together...I was hoping for a slice that would remind me of the famous spinach and artichoke pizza from Artichoke Basille's in the city (which I know is a lot to ask for being they specialize in this pizza)... The Buffalo slice was pretty tasty...the chicken is actually spicy and loaded up on the slice. There's some mozzarella (I would've liked a little more), then the chicken, and a drizzle of blue cheese...the chicken is all white meat and is not breaded...I like to add my own blue cheese dressing for the chunks as opposed to it being drizzled on, but many places do this now, so I ask for a side and get some of the chunks out and add it on myself. I would definitely try them again, but I would opt for a more traditional slice like Sicilian to get a better gauge on sauce and cheese ratio...also to try their pizza sauce. I rated 4 stars (but lean towards a 3.5) because of the crust and overall quality of the ingredients...I think adding mozzarella would make the spinach pizza much better and the Buffalo slice needs to be eaten fresh out of the oven or served extremely hot...I like when you take a bite and the cheese is melty and gooey and stretches and I was missing that here with both slices.
I went there once when they first opened and it was good. The second time I tried to order using a coupon I received in the mail. It was going to be like a $35 order but they said they only accept coupons Monday thru Thursday? Why didn't the coupon specify that? Then again I tried to order a $60 order thru Uber eats, after waiting 45 minutes the order was cancelled by the business? What's the deal?
Restaurantji Recommends
Worst pizza I have had ever, I came because of the good reviews, ingredients tasted rotting, super over priced. Plus the cashier kept refusing and trying to change what I wanted to order even after I agreed to wait they gave me a hard to time on anything I ordered. This is a pizza place right, and they don’t make pizza just whatever they want to feed customers.
The Stephano slice and the New York slice and white slice were excellent especially the sauce on the New York slice! Friendly staff, highly recommend!
I saw the new pizzaria, said,”lets try”. MISTAKE! Brooklyn pie and regular pie. No flavor at all! No good! Had no problems with service or cleanliness. Just bad pizza. Beware of 5 star reviews.
Best pizza i ever had. I don’t really eat much pizza.Throughout my life I’ve been in many pizza places around Patchogue. Funny how all the good ones are in or near Nassau county
New fav pizza place Specialty slices are amazing Stefanos special is not to be missed Nicest owners too