27 Best Caterers near Bethpage

“Teddy's never fails to impress my guests!!! I ordered a shrimp platter, the turkey, wings, mozzarella sticks, & calamari that was out of this world! They told me how long to heat everything and it all came out moist, delicious and honestly, the calamari was AMAZING! Next year I will order the mashed potatoes too! The quantity, quality, and delivery were perfect and worth every penny!!! And Debbie...well she makes everything so easy to order! I have to give her a little shout out too...thank you Debbie! I give Teddys the highest possible recommendation for any future event!“

“Solid brunch in an unexpected location! I've visited Me & You a few times over the years, as my parents and their friends are quite fond of the place. My most recent visit was during a super busy Sunday brunch rush. We made a reservation but still had to wait a bit. As you could imagine, the place was packed with both boozy brunch crowd AND families with small kids. I had the club sandwich, an item I don't normally go for. It was to offset the sweetness of all of the other entrees we ordered. It was a hefty sandwich, and all of the proportion for the filling was just right. I loved the crunchy sweet potato fries. I had a bit of the blueberry lemon ricotta crepe also. It was sweet but not too sweet as the lemon curd and the blueberries added a nice acidity. Their crepe is not what I think of as crepe, a bit on the thin pancake side than a true French crepe. I've had their other breakfasts before, like the eggs Benedict (ok, nothing to write home about) and the French toast during weekdays, much less busy times. But I felt the food was better despite the Sunday rush. I haven't had drinks here, but they look good, and plenty of tables were drinking it up. The location and the hospitality give them bonus points. Bethpage Station is a skip away. The staff is always friendly. It has the Greek diner vibe without being too old-fashioned. It's nice to have a robust breakfast-y and more lunch-y options both available. Also, they very nicely brought out free dessert for my friend's birthday, though it was clear they were past closing time, and we were some of the last patrons left!“

“My family and I had an amazing time at the New Year Party! The food was amazing. There were so many options for the appetizers and the main course! I especially enjoyed the pav bhaji and butter chicken. You can tell there was quite a bit of preparation that went into the event, everything was so nicely done. They didn't hold back at the bar either as you had all top shelf liquor. The decor, ice sculpture and photo shoot was a nice touch.“

“Literally a 5 star experience and food is worth craving again. I don’t live in the area at all but I had it once and knew I had to come out and have it again. The staff is super friendly, patient and accommodating. And the coffee is amazing. You can make it yourself so it’s just the way you like. 10/10Dietary restrictions: Non-dairy options for coffee“

“Tracy and George are true masters of what they do! All of the food is fresh and delicious, the decor is always beautiful, and staff is just simply amazing and professional. I would highly recommend this business for any party or wedding reception that you may be planning. You will not be disappointed. ❤️“

“I have been to Fred’s a half dozen times and was pleased with the breakfast sandwiches. And that they include a small coffee or OJ was a plus.Fast and Friendly service.Clean looking facility and a nice variety of things to grab and go in the market.“

“We had 2 recent events catered by AAA Royal Catering. A wedding reception in July for 100 guests and this past Thanksgiving Dinner for 45 people! The food was delicious and the staff were exquisite! Tony answered all of my questions and helped me create a menu that fit our budget and palate. I would recommend them for any event or gathering!“

“Compared to any other deli I’ve been to, this establishment is clean, friendly, and has top quality service. The food is always fresh, and they make the plates just how you would’ve made it yourself. The prices are very affordable, worth coming in for lunch / dinner before the gym any day. Jorge is one of the best employees, he always loads up my plate, and scoops the food from the side i always want it from without me even having to tell him. Great service, great people, amazing food, definitely worth checking out! I’m here nearly every day, you would think I live there ?“

“Amazing team of people! My family has gotten their catering for a long time for different gatherings and events. I couldn’t imagine getting any other caterer for mine & my fiancés engagement party. The food is always amazing, the team is always so helpful and get everything done. Everyone at our party was raving about how delicious the food was & how great the drinks were! I will always recommend Felicos!“

“My husband and I decided to try the food at Maya Grill, not knowing what to expect. We were delighted to receive such a friendly greeting upon our arrival and our food and the service we received were outstanding. I strongly recommend the Maya Grill.“

“Volunteered and attended a fund raiser event. Their wifi strength is great which is important for soliciting donations electronically. Parking lot is right across the street and has plenty of room. I think they also have another parking lot a little further down. Staff were very helpful in set and serving food. Ushers provided to help guide prople“

“For me, consistency is a major factor when it comes to choosing where to eat. Gyrolicious is consistently serving up some of the best Greek food I've had outside of Astoria, and the staff is always very welcoming. The portions are very generous, and never lack in flavor. You can tell they really take pride in serving their customers and the quality of the food they put out. Absolutely recommend!“

“Drove by and saw the happy hour sign and decided to drop in immediately was greeted by the friendly host and decided to sit at the bar. The overall ambiance is beautiful. The bartenders were amazing, quick and personable. I enjoyed light conversation and the manager Moses came out to ensure guest were enjoying themselves. As a vegetarian I enjoyed the cheese empanadas they were flavorful. I’d highly recommend the mango Margarita my sister got a blend the bartender made her which was really good ! Overall 5/5“

“I recently had the pleasure of working with Delicious Moments for our church gala event, and I couldn't be more impressed. The appetizers were a true delight—each dish showcased both creativity and exceptional quality. From the exquisite presentation to the rich flavors, every detail was impeccable. Steve's professionalism was outstanding, and he seamlessly accommodated our specific requests. It was a culinary experience that elevated our event to a whole new level. Highly recommend Delicious Moments for their top-notch service and culinary expertise!“

“Thanks for making Amy's Sweet 16 so special. Everyone was so helpful and professional. The food was delicious and everyone enjoyed it all from the cocktail hour to the cotton candy and chocolate fountain. Thanks for helping to make her party a night she will remember.“

“When we were planning our wedding, we knew we wanted it at the Riviera Waterfront Mansion, and we are so glad that we chose them for our wedding day! Irene and Tara were both fabulous to work with, and would be responsive to any and all inquiries from me (the bride) and my mom as well. The staff went above and beyond for my brother with special needs and everyone raved about the actual reception! The vendors that were recommended were also amazing - very professional and kind individuals. We cannot say enough good things about the Riviera! 5/5 stars“

“Olivia's food is amazing - delicious, healthy, fresh, and a HUGE helper for busy people. She is the consummate pro, and wonderfully attuned to the needs of her clients. Her meals are truly fabulous self-care and also make wonderful gifts. Cannot recommend her highly enough!“

“Excellent selection of everything you can imagine. Fantastic seafood section Steaks Many varieties of bread, just a wide array of fresh Foods to Choose from when you’re out and about, And you See StewLeonardsStop and check it out you will not be disappointed! Enjoy“

“We ordered Breakfast for Yom Kippur. Corinne and her staff put together a meal that went beyond our requests. In this age of zero customer service, we were overjoyed with the quality of the food and the beautiful presentation! Our guests sat down to a gorgeous and satisfying meal. No fuss. No muss. Worth every penny! Thank you, Corinne.“

“The night me and my soon to be wife laid eyes on the royal palm we knew we had to have the place . Paola was amazing in assisting us with everything we ever needed for our night. The whole process was just as important as the planning everything for that night and both went off without even a hiccup, the staff was great and the food was amazing. Thank you all that assisted that night, these newlyweds can’t be any happier.“

“I love Broadway pizza I have been to many of pizza places and I always say Broadway Pizza is the best Guy is a great person He has helped when my daughter and son in law were killed in a horrific accident in Mastic Beach, Guy donated food I couldn’t ask for a better place then Broadway Pizza Always busy and always good“

“I've been to this location a few times now. I must say, this is now a fave spot that I can enjoy anytime of the day or week.Food:I can speak for the sandwiches, they are unique and constructed with fresh tasty ingredients (that result in a delicious flavor that you will crave in the future).I highly recommend the Mamma Mia Pizza Bagel:Chicken cutlet,melted mozzarella, roasted peppers, baby spinach, pesto mayo on a pizza bagelAND also the Angry BLT:Crispy bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, avocados, chipotle aioli, everything seeds on a toasted bagel*Both come with a side*The coffee is delicious and fresh anytime of day, and they have so many drinks to choose from. I usually go with the Hal's or Fruit Punch Snapple.Can't wait to try the Pancakes or French toast, everything looks drool-worthy. Check their full menu out!Staff:They are very helpful, and make great sandwiches. They also keep the shop very clean too (someone is always cleaning or restocking something).Inside:There's plenty of seating, a restroom, and a decent sized parking lot (not too large, but perfect for their location).“

“Dreamstreet catered my daughter's bridal shower of 65 women. The food was out of this world, everyone was raving about it. I didn't want just typical party platters and they did not disappoint. Danielle was a pleasure to work with and came up with a menu that I was very happy with. I will definitely use them again!!“

“Rich catered a party for us that had many food critics in attendance. Everyone was in love with the food so we all had seconds and thirds. Delicious top quality food at very reasonable prices. Definitely can't forget to mention the server that rich sent. Concetta was wonderful, she was like part of the family by the end of the party. We couldn't have asked for a better experience. thank you!!“

“We ordered a heart shaped red velvet cake for our small get together because we got married and everyone loved it! It was moist and flavorful. Nikkie is so sweet. We will DEFINITELY 100% be ordering from her again! She gained a forever customer!“

“Went for the first time and didn’t know what to expect. We ordered the paper dosa and cheese dosa. These are huge! Plenty of food for 4 people. Everything was delicious! I would definitely recommend to others and return for another night.“

“Our office catered food for a co-worker and his family who lost a loved one. We didn’t realize that the food needed to meet certain dietary requirements prior to ordering. Because we did not want to let the food go to waste, we wanted to have it delivered to a local food bank. The Deli arranged for it to be delivered in memory of our lost one. In addition, they improved the menu by combining their cold and hot food packages. Furthermore, they chose to add to our donation by donating themselves in the memory of our lost one. Obviously, we can’t speak for the food, but we can certainly praise this Deli’s customer service, compassion, and exemplary effort to go above and beyond. This reflects great credit on Nina’s Deli & Catering and East Meadow.“