Buffalo's Best Bakery

4510 Lake Ave, Blasdell
(716) 823-6500

Recent Reviews

Gary Monica

Really good breakfast sandwiches here! I also had a really good breakfast burrito!

Kaitlyn G.

I have ordered breakfast from this place a couple of times with in the last year. At the time (spring ish) the food was amazing and the portions were really big. I enjoyed it so much I decided that this was gonna be my go to breakfast spot. When I went in the summer the portions were kinda small (maybe considered reasonable by other people) but they food was still good for a decent price. Recently, the size of my order could be compared to a kids portion. That's how small it was and my potatoes were extremely oily, barely any flavor and not fully cooked. I am extremely disappointed and I wish I didn't spend nearly 7.50 for literally scraps. I ordered potato and eggs and I got table scraps

Katie M.

The best breakfast sandwich ever. Such a mom & pop shop, and didn't disappoint. Bought some cookies to go!

Don Carlson

We went in for lunch. The Steak Hogie was very good. The antipasto salad was good. The Pastry is Outrageous. Breakfast all day. 8 to 4pm. Stop in and try it. If you haven't been in a while. You've been missing out on some Great Food.

Brian Krawczyk

Well don't try this place on lunch break as they dont have sliced ready.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eliseo V.

Went here originally on my way to Alfred with some fam. Got the Canadian breakfast sandwich and it was one of the most delicious breakfast sandwiches I ever had. Everything made in house, the potatoes were seasoned perfectly! The scones were fresh with small pieces of green apple and I even got a tiramisu that just melted in my mouth. After getting to Alfred we decided to drive all the way back a few days later because it was that good. The chef even brought us complimentary macaroons because it was a little busy and he wanted to give us something to "snack on" while we were waiting (tip from chef: let them sit a bit as they are made fresh everyday, but left in a chiller to keep freshness). Staff is super nice, honestly one of the best experiences I've ever had at any restaurant. Truly Buffalo's Best Bakery in my opinion.

Ricardo V.

The food was spectacular. I'm from Texas, and I came here to New York, and instead of calling it Buffalo's Best Bakery, they should call it the best bakery in the North. The people are nice, and do their best to get their food to you asap. a small place, vibe is chill.

Dawn C.

Stopped to grab a quick breakfast. The breakfast croissant sandwich was delicious and so were the potatoes. They also served them with a side of fresh strawberries. Very clean and friendly. Will definitely go back when going through the area!

Sherry Calandra

This Bakery never disapoints for our birthday parties !!!! Cakes and cupcakes are always delicious and look beautiful!!!!Thank youBuffalo's Best Bakery !!

Amy K.

Food: 5/5 - we've been passing by this place for years and finally decided to stop in for a breakfast sandwich. 5/5 and totally worth it. The biscuit was soooo good and not at all dry or crumbly. Would get that again. Service: 5/5 - all of the staff were wonderful! They were super helpful and offered us several different treats to try. Spindle candy was freshly dipped and so fresh that we decided to order some. Also the donuts were freshly dried and filled and were so warm and delicious. Amazing baked goods and treats for sure. Ambiance: 4/5 the place is small so it's good to just stop in for a quick bite.

Matthew Carlacci

Not bad pizza. Lunch special is 2 slices and a drink for 6.53. The mushroom on the one pizza las lacking a little topping but good spread of pepperoni. The bread they baked smelled delicious. The baked goods looked and smell delicious and I’d be interested in trying something from here in the future

alcarp

1st time in, will definitely return! Guys behind counter move fast, and all were friendly. Antipasto great and filling. Pizza not as high priced as most, and very good.

David Bucy

Honestly was not to much of a fan. The pizza had plenty of toppings but the flavor was very odd. I asked for something unique. I also had wings which one was supposed to have honey mustard and cajun but definitely no honey mustard was added. I dont discourage you from this place but It is for sure not going to be a place on my go to list in the area

cheryl sutton

Garbage! I only gave it a star because it's the only way I could leave a review. 1/2 cooked pizza and wings order was wrong. Terrible, condescending attitude from the manager. One might question whether I deserved that, but I assure you, I didn't. I was actually quite cool about it when I called. I will NEVER order from there again! Not to mention, the inside of the place looked as though it hasn't been cleaned in 10 years. Obviously they put the money on the outside of the place just to get you in the door. I 100% do not recommend eating here! If it's chef boy r dee pizza your looking for, you've found it!

Riley Micucci

Had a private party booked with the restaurant, Buffalos Best Grill. The restaurant manager, Renee, told us we couldn’t supply our own cake/cupcakes and needed to go through their baker. We called Umesh (the baker), ordered 2 dozen cupcakes for my daughters baptism party at the restaurant. Baptism party came, and no cupcakes were supplied. The baker “forgot”. Extremely frustrating to say the least. Won’t be attempting to use this bakery again.

Load More