The Arch Restaurant

1292 NY-22, Brewster
(845) 279-5011

Recent Reviews

Yudit Maros

Mother's Day brunch, oh my! Paid near $1,000 for 9 of us, oh my! For what, you ask? Mediocre, lackluster food. Nothing had a flavor to speak of, unfailingly bland fare, from soup to dessert. Nice athmosphere, soft music are a welcome change from the typical, noisy meal out, but didn't compensate for blah service, an hour wait for our apps, or the waiter's scowl for returning the wrong order - not to speak of the hefty bill!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Yuliana

Nice spot. Giving overall 3 stars because food is OK but not great and they charge credit card fee (so be aware on a $100+ dinner bill you will pay $6 fee). Great French music on the background. Beautiful outdoor space, but can get noisy with the highway. Tried liver , which was good but not great (lacked flavor and spices and not sure onion pearls are the right compliment for the liver); lobster pasta special penne was good but not $62 good, so overpriced for what it was. Artichoke appetizer was excellent at $19 fair price. Wine options reasonable from $40 per bottle to $100+++. Desert: limited, only 3 options. Chocolate desert which was similar to chocolate mousses was really nice because it wasn’t over sweet. Cocktails the bar are excellent. Great ambiance for a quiet dinner out. It’s semi romantic because the lights are a bit too bright.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Karolina Chodkiewicz

Great little gem in a beautiful location.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ron Belanger

Great food and great service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Petri

Great atmosphere. Food was undesirable for Easter brunch. Ribeye was tough.Vegetables were great. Mash potatoes great. For a 650$ tab I expected more then a 1/2" ribeye that was tough

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Endrit Balidemaj

Very good restaurant. Nice ambiance. Great service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Max

All around awful experience. Food and service were terrible. Food was not fit for a pig. Server was mean and rude. Do not go here.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Chris Neylan

Great all around. The beef wellingtons were cooked about a measure too hot, i.e. one ordered rare, arrived medium, another ordered medium-rare arrived medium-well, albeit delicious. Souffle and Creme Brulee were excellent.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Crisp Honey Orange Roasted Duckling Bing Cherries, Beef Wellington, Crab and Lobster Cake

Ron K.

I can honestly say this restaurant, is by far, our favorite place to dine. From the intimacy of the dining areas, the attentive staff and incredible cuisine. Many time you go out to eat where one of the courses is good. Here EVERYTHING is amazing. From appetizer to dessert it's all delicious. The hardest decision is what to order. My favorite is the cheese soufflé as a starter then the Beef Wellington and finish with their amazing chocolate soufflé. Our go to for special occasions or just a night out to spoil one self. This is a "don't miss"!

Juan O.

What can I say? Outstanding all the way around. The ambience was amazing. The food was fantastic and the service was beyond 5 stars. We highly recommend Arch. The food serving was huge and we took a bunch of stuff home. The Concierge was professional, happy, warm and inviting. Our visit could not have gotten any better.

Zane Dargaty

Great people, great atmosphere, great food! Wonderful selection on the brunch menu. Relaxed dining at its best.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom S.

Was recently back in town on business and decided to treat myself and my client to The Arch Friday night. The escargot was the best I've had. Followed up with the special halibut with brown butter and basil sauce. What a beautiful, delicious dish. I was too full for dessert but the house cabernet finished off the meal well. Great ambiance and great value for the evening!

Mark Schulman

Excellent ambiance, service and quality cocktails as well as

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Seasonal Soup, Crisp Honey Orange Roasted Duckling Bing Cherries, Crab and Lobster Cake

Hal Ginny

We were driving through Brewster N.Y and decided to try the Arch restaurant, the atmosphere was very delicate!The service and the food was wonderful. We had a good time ! recommend it!Kid-friendliness: Nice place for kids!Parking: The parking lot was very convenient!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Hotelie H

The Arch is truly a hidden gem! My husband and I went on a date night and it did not disappoint. The food, ambiance and service are excellent and sophisticated. The chef and owner George is very charming and talented. He came to our table to say hello and made sure we were enjoying our meal. The escargot, cheese soufflé, beef buorguignon, and grand marnier soufflé were outstanding! As New Yorkers, we were very impressed with everything about the Arch and the price is very reasonable. We will definitely return. We highly recommend it!

Load More