The Jon Thomas Inne

91 Howells Rd, Brightwaters
(631) 666-2060

Recent Reviews

Annie Freeman

CLOSED!

Jeff B

Local tradition

Veronica Corrigan

Just found out that they are closed! Supposed to have my son's communion there on Saturday and they closed there doors and didn't have the decency to call me and let me know!!

Donald E.

The food and service both sucked here.No wonder it's closed now. Isn't it interesting how it closed a few months after Super Bowl Sunday? Any guess?

Dawn Frazzitta

Great food and great staff

Catherine S.

Went here for Kentucky Derby. Place was mobbed and that wasn't a problem, the staff was. Here's my question: Why install multiple betting machines when you don't want them there? The owner openly said "He hates this day"! The female barmaid working the day of the race had the nastiest attitude I've ever seen. It's a bar..people expect even a fake smile or some form of hospitality. Shes rude and appears to be doing you a favor by getting you a drink. This was not the first time she has served us and I couldnt believe she was rude again. Get rid of your machines if you dont want to be race forum central. We had a rough time getting a few meals at our table also.. What a shame. We wont be back.

Sam A.

Went recently after not going for like ten years and was impressed. Unfortunately it has gotten worse and worse over the last 4 visits within 2 months. Kept giving benefit of the doubt , like when I asked if the crab was fake in one of their dishes, was assured it was real and was then served fake a** crab in my pasta, but after today I won't ever be back. Ordered a sandwich that came with sautéed onions which I asked to not have put on. Sandwich came with the onions. I returned it and it came back within a minute which made me ask if they just scraped them off. The waitresses reply? Why are you allergic? I said no but I don't like onions and I can still smell them. This isn't like throwing a steak back on that's under cooked this was scraping sautéed onions off of a hot sandwich with melted cheese. That's a sandwich you need to remake. They did offer but after learning how they operate (see above) I didn't care to eat from that kitchen again. Some other lowlights where the chewy st.louis ribs I got instead of the tender baby back I ordered oh and it was 4 dried out ribs for 10 bucks like i said advertised as baby backs and served st. louis. Then there where the drinks we never got, the mayo for my wife burger she never got, the extra bleu cheese for the wings we never got, the nasty burnt coffee, and finally the waitress who forgot we existed when I declined a new sandwich, which by the way they made and brought out anyway, talk about trying to save a check, but like I said I wasn't eating from that kitchen after they attempted to re-serve me that shitty sandwich which also came with swiss instead of the mozzarella I ordered. Don't waste your time here.

Keith Petoske

This was a cool place. Very old school vibe. The kinda of bar your dad hangs out at with much better food. Good place to catch up and have a conversation. Meal was perfect, beer was cold and the bar tender have the perfect amount of attitude to keep you on your toes. But....watch your step, I tripped like 3 times while there! I guess I can blame the beer 😉

Beth Campo

Great atmosphere. Definitely a pub type place but the food is totally "restaurant quality"! The service is very friendly and efficient without hovering. I can't say anything not even close to criticizing. Check it out... you'll be glad you did!! 🌟 🌟🌟 🌟🌟 👍👍

Dennis Vahle

Beware of sports pools in this establishment. A friend of mine won the Super Bowl pool. A substantial amount of money. And the owners area refusing to make good on his winnings. These guys should be ashamed of themselves. Bad business . Words gonna get around. Whould never go back there.

Courtney Leone

Awesome food and service all around!!! The staff is super friendly, I had Patrick and he was attentive, sweet, and caring for my table of 12 AND it was a busy night! Definitely recommend the boccacini, too 😋

Theresa Dieso

After they ripped off a fellow customer of the Super Bowl winnings, I will never go there again. How can you trust thieves to cook for you? Obviously they are running a scam. Their business ethics are so disappointing. I suggest we all boycott at that place until the customer gets what's owed to him. Shame on them! I am sure Karma will be knocking at their door. Hopefully sooner than later.

Kellye C.

The Jon Thomas Inn sold super bowl boxes and is refusing the pay the winners . It's not a small amount of money. It's in the high thousands. They're claiming they don't have the money and they are closing. They STOLE the money people bought the boxes with. One is a 75 year old woman. What type of people do something like this ? That money should have been put away for after the game. Not spent !!! It takes someone with no conscience to do this to people !! No wonder they're going out of business .. they deserve to close down !!

Jennifer H.

This used to be the best restaurant. The food now has gotten horrible. The soup tasted like pure salt. The nachos were like the nachos from 711 but worse. Im 6 months pregnant with a severe stomach ache now from eating there. The place is nice and the staff is nice, but the food is not! Maybe id go there again and hang out at the bar and have a few drinks, but definitely not to eat!

Roger T.

Went there for the 1st time in many yrs. It was a Monday and place wasn't crowded at all. Sat by the fireplace,, food was great portions huge! I had the chicken kio,delicious! Very good drink as well. We didn't plan on going to Jon Thomas but we are glad we did. Chicken sorrentiono was also very good. and of course the french onion soup.

Load More