Tried Brooklyn Pizza Crew for delivery and was very pleased. It's always risky trying a new pizza spot and Brooklyn Pizza Crew did not dissapoint :/ The highlights were the garlic knots---absolutely outstanding! They're larger than most and come in four per order. If you don't like sharing, get your own lol! The Margherita pizza is decent, not my favorite overall but I'm eager to try their grandma pizza next time and individual slices since those seem to be consistently good.
Rain Storm
Margarita pizza 2 slices ? I enjoyed yum.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
chef “brian” TYB
update: still eat slices from here all the time but i’m reluctant to trust management to follow through on the offer they put in the comment on my review. that being said i think imma drop the stars because it’s a very dishonest practice to communicate with someone but not follow through. they even went as far as deleting the comment.really solid pizza spot. the dough is delicious but was kinda underwhelmed by the undercarriage of the pizza completely lacking color everywhere but the crust, but the sauce and cheese ratio was proper and it had good garlic and basil profile. the salad was pretty delicious and i liked the pitted black olives. kinda wish they just toss the pizza without a pan back in the oven for a hot second to complete the delicious crust profile at the base.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
m “TYB brian” d
update: still eat slices from here all the time but i’m reluctant to trust management to follow through on the offer they put in the comment on my review. that being said i think imma drop the stars because it’s a very dishonest practice to communicate with someone but not follow through. they even went as far as deleting the comment.really solid pizza spot. the dough is delicious but was kinda underwhelmed by the undercarriage of the pizza completely lacking color everywhere but the crust, but the sauce and cheese ratio was proper and it had good garlic and basil profile. the salad was pretty delicious and i liked the pitted black olives. kinda wish they just toss the pizza without a pan back in the oven for a hot second to complete the delicious crust profile at the base.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
danny krantor
Great food, great service!!! Love coming here. I try to come at least once a week!!! Amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Co Mo
Best pizza spot in Crown Heights. The new guy though isn’t too friendly. Lighten up, new guy!
OG Papafern
Where's Brooklyn at?? Right here!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tam M-Dolcy
We order pizza here at least once a week- the last three weeks have pretty bad- a burnt pie, an over sauced pie with virtually no cheese and now a pie that's stale. The first two occasions we informed the staff of the issues and all we got was- Sorry. We will no longer be ordering from Brooklyn pizza crew. This location used to have great customer service but we can no longer rely on food quality or customer service. Please check your order before you leave the store.
Semaj B.
I love love love Williamsburg Pizza / the brooklyn pizza crew! from not only throwing amazing live events and having sick merch and now a cool new rewards app WBP makes a really solid slice! my favorite is thejr grandma slice, the crust is soft and buttery , the sauce is light and zesty and the cheese super fresh!!! I always go here when I can! they also make a killer heart shaped pizza that is customizable which is great for parties and special events
Tamara M.
We order pizza here at least once a week- the last three weeks have pretty bad- a burnt pie, an over sauced pie with virtually no cheese and now a pie that isn't fresh. The first two occasions we informed the staff of the issues and all we got was- Sorry. We will no longer be ordering from Brooklyn pizza crew. They have definitely changed ownership, as this location used to have great customer service. But now we can no longer rely on food quality or customer service. Also-Please check your order before you leave the store.
Our family orders a large pie every week; unfortunately, it has been burnt several times in the past months. Service has also dropped dramitically; it's time for a new spot...
Daniel Pino
Layout/atmosphere*Two picnic tablesFood/drink*The Bianco (Fresh mozzarella, ricotta, parsley and parmigiano reggiano) - very good; ricotta creamy; slice overall little greasy*The Grandma (Basil, parmigiano reggiano, olive oil, fresh mozzarella and tomato sauce; square slice) - Good; thin crust
Isabel Henderson
Great vegan pizzas!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ximena Del Cerro
Great slide place. Pepperoni cups, garlic knots, grandma's square, all excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma, The Brooklyn Pizza, Grandma Pizza, Garlic Knots
Nancy A.
Garlic knots taste so good here! They look so authentic and baked from scratch! Doesn't look like it's frozen and very freshly made! Margherita pizza is on par and fresh too. Not overly saucy or over seasoned. All the condiments and ingredients on the pizza make the taste exact to the touch! I will come by again!
Tried Brooklyn Pizza Crew for delivery and was very pleased. It's always risky trying a new pizza spot and Brooklyn Pizza Crew did not dissapoint :/ The highlights were the garlic knots---absolutely outstanding! They're larger than most and come in four per order. If you don't like sharing, get your own lol! The Margherita pizza is decent, not my favorite overall but I'm eager to try their grandma pizza next time and individual slices since those seem to be consistently good.
Margarita pizza 2 slices ? I enjoyed yum.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
update: still eat slices from here all the time but i’m reluctant to trust management to follow through on the offer they put in the comment on my review. that being said i think imma drop the stars because it’s a very dishonest practice to communicate with someone but not follow through. they even went as far as deleting the comment.really solid pizza spot. the dough is delicious but was kinda underwhelmed by the undercarriage of the pizza completely lacking color everywhere but the crust, but the sauce and cheese ratio was proper and it had good garlic and basil profile. the salad was pretty delicious and i liked the pitted black olives. kinda wish they just toss the pizza without a pan back in the oven for a hot second to complete the delicious crust profile at the base.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
update: still eat slices from here all the time but i’m reluctant to trust management to follow through on the offer they put in the comment on my review. that being said i think imma drop the stars because it’s a very dishonest practice to communicate with someone but not follow through. they even went as far as deleting the comment.really solid pizza spot. the dough is delicious but was kinda underwhelmed by the undercarriage of the pizza completely lacking color everywhere but the crust, but the sauce and cheese ratio was proper and it had good garlic and basil profile. the salad was pretty delicious and i liked the pitted black olives. kinda wish they just toss the pizza without a pan back in the oven for a hot second to complete the delicious crust profile at the base.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Great food, great service!!! Love coming here. I try to come at least once a week!!! Amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza spot in Crown Heights. The new guy though isn’t too friendly. Lighten up, new guy!
Where's Brooklyn at?? Right here!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We order pizza here at least once a week- the last three weeks have pretty bad- a burnt pie, an over sauced pie with virtually no cheese and now a pie that's stale. The first two occasions we informed the staff of the issues and all we got was- Sorry. We will no longer be ordering from Brooklyn pizza crew. This location used to have great customer service but we can no longer rely on food quality or customer service. Please check your order before you leave the store.
I love love love Williamsburg Pizza / the brooklyn pizza crew! from not only throwing amazing live events and having sick merch and now a cool new rewards app WBP makes a really solid slice! my favorite is thejr grandma slice, the crust is soft and buttery , the sauce is light and zesty and the cheese super fresh!!! I always go here when I can! they also make a killer heart shaped pizza that is customizable which is great for parties and special events
We order pizza here at least once a week- the last three weeks have pretty bad- a burnt pie, an over sauced pie with virtually no cheese and now a pie that isn't fresh. The first two occasions we informed the staff of the issues and all we got was- Sorry. We will no longer be ordering from Brooklyn pizza crew. They have definitely changed ownership, as this location used to have great customer service. But now we can no longer rely on food quality or customer service. Also-Please check your order before you leave the store.
Restaurantji Recommends
Our family orders a large pie every week; unfortunately, it has been burnt several times in the past months. Service has also dropped dramitically; it's time for a new spot...
Layout/atmosphere*Two picnic tablesFood/drink*The Bianco (Fresh mozzarella, ricotta, parsley and parmigiano reggiano) - very good; ricotta creamy; slice overall little greasy*The Grandma (Basil, parmigiano reggiano, olive oil, fresh mozzarella and tomato sauce; square slice) - Good; thin crust
Great vegan pizzas!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great slide place. Pepperoni cups, garlic knots, grandma's square, all excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma, The Brooklyn Pizza, Grandma Pizza, Garlic Knots
Garlic knots taste so good here! They look so authentic and baked from scratch! Doesn't look like it's frozen and very freshly made! Margherita pizza is on par and fresh too. Not overly saucy or over seasoned. All the condiments and ingredients on the pizza make the taste exact to the touch! I will come by again!