Brooklyn Home Slice is a neighborhood favorite, but their service is sub par. Don't order for delivery, the food will take hours or not come. Read my review below or the many others who have said the same thing. Consider ordering from Amorina Cucina Rustica, which has better reviews, is a few blocks away and has a gluten free pizza option. Review below: My husband and I order from them frequently for large events. On 4/16/24, we ordered using UberEats. While I know that UberEats isn't perfect, the food took hours to come to the location the was 2 mins (0.8 miles) away where we were hosting an event. When it arrived, it was missing a gluten free pie. I called them and told them that we're going to order another regular pie and to please send the gluten free pie (it was even written in the order notes.) Brooklyn Home Slice agreed to send the gluten free pie with the new order. When the order arrived it had one regular pie and NO gluten free pie. I went to the location to explain it to how disappointed I was in the service. Instead of owning up to the error or offering a valid solution, they blamed Uber Eats for both mistakes and suggested that we call them to place orders in the future. The event attendees with gluten allergies, did not eat. Here's the thing-- Brooklyn Home Slice don't use a service like UberEats if it doesn't work for your business. Offer solutions instead of blaming Uber Eats drivers for forgetting the pizza (twice) and the customer for not using your restaurant delivery service. If you have a delivery service, then bring the forgotten pizza 5 minutes away to your customer. Or hand the Uber Driver the order and tell them what to take. Going the extra mile is good business, it's that simple. (Uber Eats did refund us for the roughly $200 for both orders since the pizza that did arrive, arrived very late.)
Matteo P.
Friendly neighborhood spot. Not far from my home, I come here often. My friend and I both love the place. We came in earlier today and had another great experience. Unique taste, stands out. service is great here. Looking forward to coming back in the future.
Sergei
White (Bianca) Pizza with fresh basil contained no single piece of basil.
Food: 1
Sera
My friends & I were on a quest for late-night pizza in the Brooklyn neighborhood last Friday, and this was the perfect way to end the night. We went right before closing, but the staff was still so welcoming and friendly and heated our pizzas nice and hot. Bonus points for the staff's generosity as well!The pizza was delicious, the crust was crispy, and the cheese to tomato sauce ratio was just right.I tried the melanzana and grandma styled slice, both were tasty. The Grandma slice was some of the best I've had, with extra herby and crispy crust--highly recommend!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma, Melanzana Pizza Eggplant - Pie
saskeia doris
Best pizza in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Regular, Slice of Pizza, Grandma Pie
Humera Ahmed
By far our favorite pizza place ?? also, having halal pepperoni is a big plus!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Regular
Naomi Gonzalez
This place was horrible. A young man was incredibly rude to
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Sharon Valdez
Best pizza I've eaten in long time&their hot wings are the ??
Food: 5
Service: 5
stephen H
Ordering whole pies has occasionally left me a little disappointed but their slices, garlic knots, and wings are always great. One of my favorite
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Veggie, Regular, White, Slice of Pizza
Samantha D.
Another neighborhood staple. Staff is warm, kind and attentive, service is always quick. Pizza is good, I think the crust stands out the most, it is perfectly crispy. I can't recommend the margarita slice enough times!! I will say, everything I have had beyond pizza (rice balls and garlic knots specifically) were substantially less fresh and no where near as good as any slice at Homeslice. Wish there was more of an indoor seating area, even something casual but appreciate the outdoor seating area when it's warm!
Pretty solid and good slice of pizza in my opinion! Got the Margherita and the peperoni. Both came out crispy, saucy, and delicious! The slice was quite big for me and 1 slice got fill me up for a lunch.
Lourdes Zephier
The Best Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad in this area!!!! The dressing is amazing. Lettuce is always greasy, crisp, and absolutely wonderful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adhiraj Singh
Great pizza, great service
Glo M.
We love their thin crusted pizza! Husband is a fan of their cheese pizza and we'd find a reason to drive to Brooklyn just to get a bite. Friend from Cali loved their bacon buffalo pizza so much that he called it "illegal." Staff are lowkey nice. :)
Kara Fortner
Pizza was great. The garlic knots are even better.
Brooklyn Home Slice is a neighborhood favorite, but their service is sub par. Don't order for delivery, the food will take hours or not come. Read my review below or the many others who have said the same thing. Consider ordering from Amorina Cucina Rustica, which has better reviews, is a few blocks away and has a gluten free pizza option. Review below: My husband and I order from them frequently for large events. On 4/16/24, we ordered using UberEats. While I know that UberEats isn't perfect, the food took hours to come to the location the was 2 mins (0.8 miles) away where we were hosting an event. When it arrived, it was missing a gluten free pie. I called them and told them that we're going to order another regular pie and to please send the gluten free pie (it was even written in the order notes.) Brooklyn Home Slice agreed to send the gluten free pie with the new order. When the order arrived it had one regular pie and NO gluten free pie. I went to the location to explain it to how disappointed I was in the service. Instead of owning up to the error or offering a valid solution, they blamed Uber Eats for both mistakes and suggested that we call them to place orders in the future. The event attendees with gluten allergies, did not eat. Here's the thing-- Brooklyn Home Slice don't use a service like UberEats if it doesn't work for your business. Offer solutions instead of blaming Uber Eats drivers for forgetting the pizza (twice) and the customer for not using your restaurant delivery service. If you have a delivery service, then bring the forgotten pizza 5 minutes away to your customer. Or hand the Uber Driver the order and tell them what to take. Going the extra mile is good business, it's that simple. (Uber Eats did refund us for the roughly $200 for both orders since the pizza that did arrive, arrived very late.)
Friendly neighborhood spot. Not far from my home, I come here often. My friend and I both love the place. We came in earlier today and had another great experience. Unique taste, stands out. service is great here. Looking forward to coming back in the future.
White (Bianca) Pizza with fresh basil contained no single piece of basil.
Food: 1
My friends & I were on a quest for late-night pizza in the Brooklyn neighborhood last Friday, and this was the perfect way to end the night. We went right before closing, but the staff was still so welcoming and friendly and heated our pizzas nice and hot. Bonus points for the staff's generosity as well!The pizza was delicious, the crust was crispy, and the cheese to tomato sauce ratio was just right.I tried the melanzana and grandma styled slice, both were tasty. The Grandma slice was some of the best I've had, with extra herby and crispy crust--highly recommend!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma, Melanzana Pizza Eggplant - Pie
Best pizza in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Regular, Slice of Pizza, Grandma Pie
By far our favorite pizza place ?? also, having halal pepperoni is a big plus!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Regular
This place was horrible. A young man was incredibly rude to
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Best pizza I've eaten in long time&their hot wings are the ??
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordering whole pies has occasionally left me a little disappointed but their slices, garlic knots, and wings are always great. One of my favorite
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Veggie, Regular, White, Slice of Pizza
Another neighborhood staple. Staff is warm, kind and attentive, service is always quick. Pizza is good, I think the crust stands out the most, it is perfectly crispy. I can't recommend the margarita slice enough times!! I will say, everything I have had beyond pizza (rice balls and garlic knots specifically) were substantially less fresh and no where near as good as any slice at Homeslice. Wish there was more of an indoor seating area, even something casual but appreciate the outdoor seating area when it's warm!
Restaurantji Recommends
Pretty solid and good slice of pizza in my opinion! Got the Margherita and the peperoni. Both came out crispy, saucy, and delicious! The slice was quite big for me and 1 slice got fill me up for a lunch.
The Best Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad in this area!!!! The dressing is amazing. Lettuce is always greasy, crisp, and absolutely wonderful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza, great service
We love their thin crusted pizza! Husband is a fan of their cheese pizza and we'd find a reason to drive to Brooklyn just to get a bite. Friend from Cali loved their bacon buffalo pizza so much that he called it "illegal." Staff are lowkey nice. :)
Pizza was great. The garlic knots are even better.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pepperoni Slice