Honestly, the best of the best.Mi amori! Salute!Excellente!The seafood is great! All the food is great.GOD BLESS BROOKLYN!I do not own the restaurant.
Ju
Nice Italian restaurant. Our server was fun, attentive, and so accommodating. Food was good and came out hot and quick.
George N
Just fantastic! Solid food. Amazing value and the staff is hilarious and so hospitable.Just a great feel good place
Jeff Touti
Every once in awhile you accidentally find a GemAnd this place is exactly That....Old school Italian Restaurant with Amazing Brick oven Pizza.Very Friendly owner/staffThe Food and the Vibe is DeliciousI would Diffently come back !!!!
Zal B.
The best Italian place in prospect heights. They've been around and will continue to keep serving home style Italian food. Don't expect some pretentious bk Italian place, Cataldos is good food by good people at great prices
Izzy N.
A great family owned Resturant in Brooklyn where owner gave us some history about location. 14 years of business what a great place to come with your family I Started with fresh fried calamari & 12" Margarita pizza. Yes, I over did it but I was hungry So delicious
Gary McCrear
I love coming to this restaurant as it is always peaceful and I can always ensure i’m going to have a wonderful experience. The service is always quick and I feel the love in every meal I have.
Arnie Schlissel
Just a great local joint that slings classic Italian American comfort food. HUGE portions, very reasonable prices.
Ty G.
Cataldo's was a cute Italian restaurant. Very spacious, but uncomfortably quiet. The food was pretty good and the portions were a good size, enough to bring home leftovers. There was one waitress that reminded me of the Italian Nona's I see on tv, who took orders on an old fashioned note pad. She was very pleasant.
Nadia B.
Delicious pizza and penne vodka ! Delivery was fast. Would definitely recommend for good comfort food.
Excellent red sauce. Real friendly neighborhood Italian restaurant, especially the servers.
Scott Eisenberg
I know it says pizza place but the Italian food here is great. Had veal parm and it was excellent. Kind of an ‘old school NYC’ Italian and that’s what makes it great.Run by Sal, his wife and daughter. Really, do go!Wish I’d taken a photo of the veal but I was too busy eating it.
Julia Ofman
A hidden gem in Prospect Heights! Super solid Italian food at very reasonable prices. Especially great spot during Open Streets. Feels like a real neighborhood, family place. Don't miss it!
Wave Yaki
Absolutely delicious, if you want a classic Italian meal this is where you go
Bobbye Gordon
OMG, the worst caprese salad I've ever been served. The tomato wasn't ripe, the arugula was swimming in oil & vinegar. Shame on their kitchen for sending it out to a diner.
Honestly, the best of the best.Mi amori! Salute!Excellente!The seafood is great! All the food is great.GOD BLESS BROOKLYN!I do not own the restaurant.
Nice Italian restaurant. Our server was fun, attentive, and so accommodating. Food was good and came out hot and quick.
Just fantastic! Solid food. Amazing value and the staff is hilarious and so hospitable.Just a great feel good place
Every once in awhile you accidentally find a GemAnd this place is exactly That....Old school Italian Restaurant with Amazing Brick oven Pizza.Very Friendly owner/staffThe Food and the Vibe is DeliciousI would Diffently come back !!!!
The best Italian place in prospect heights. They've been around and will continue to keep serving home style Italian food. Don't expect some pretentious bk Italian place, Cataldos is good food by good people at great prices
A great family owned Resturant in Brooklyn where owner gave us some history about location. 14 years of business what a great place to come with your family I Started with fresh fried calamari & 12" Margarita pizza. Yes, I over did it but I was hungry So delicious
I love coming to this restaurant as it is always peaceful and I can always ensure i’m going to have a wonderful experience. The service is always quick and I feel the love in every meal I have.
Just a great local joint that slings classic Italian American comfort food. HUGE portions, very reasonable prices.
Cataldo's was a cute Italian restaurant. Very spacious, but uncomfortably quiet. The food was pretty good and the portions were a good size, enough to bring home leftovers. There was one waitress that reminded me of the Italian Nona's I see on tv, who took orders on an old fashioned note pad. She was very pleasant.
Delicious pizza and penne vodka ! Delivery was fast. Would definitely recommend for good comfort food.
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent red sauce. Real friendly neighborhood Italian restaurant, especially the servers.
I know it says pizza place but the Italian food here is great. Had veal parm and it was excellent. Kind of an ‘old school NYC’ Italian and that’s what makes it great.Run by Sal, his wife and daughter. Really, do go!Wish I’d taken a photo of the veal but I was too busy eating it.
A hidden gem in Prospect Heights! Super solid Italian food at very reasonable prices. Especially great spot during Open Streets. Feels like a real neighborhood, family place. Don't miss it!
Absolutely delicious, if you want a classic Italian meal this is where you go
OMG, the worst caprese salad I've ever been served. The tomato wasn't ripe, the arugula was swimming in oil & vinegar. Shame on their kitchen for sending it out to a diner.