I’ve been ordering food from Cobblestone for four years and everything is always delicious, fresh, and beautifully presented. I’ve worked with them for everything from thanksgiving dishes to passed hors d’oeuvres to weeknight dinner party meals. Everything always exceeds my expectations. And the prices can’t be beat!
Susie Brandmeyer
Evan and Seth did a fantastic job - they organized the space, served drinks and food and were beyond friendly and professional. The food was also great - as always. Thank you!
Julia Egli
My firm used Cobblestone to cater at one of our partner's homes this week and we were extremely pleased. This partner has used Cobblestone for many of their events that they host at home and they are always happy to the food, customer service, and attention to detail. Jeremy in particular is great to work with and always very responsive. Definitely recommend!
Jessica Kleeman
I have no idea why there are any bad reviews for Jeremy and his team at Cobblestone. They catered my wedding at The Foundry in May 2022 and everything was PERFECT. The drinks and food were truly SO GOOD. My guests are still talking about how good our food was, some saying it's the best wedding food they have ever had. I spoke with many other caterers and I am extremely picky and I can promise you (and save you the time) that Cobblestone is the best choice BY FAR. We had a lot of special food restrictions and I had a lot of crazy and speciality drink requests and they handled every request without any questions asked. They even spent months sourcing mini patrol tequila bottles for me. Thank you so much for making my wedding day so amazing I am forever grateful!!!! I hope to work with you guys again for another event soon.
Aimee Phelps
We hired Pizza Moto to cater our wedding and it turns out they handle the food but actually partner with Cobblestone Catering to handle the events planning and execution. Wedding was last weekend and it was a huge success! Food was awesome and Jeremy and his team did such an amazing job setting up not only for the dinner, but also the ceremony which was in the same space. It was a beautiful ceremony and then they had 1 hour to flip the room into an equally beautiful reception space. I honestly don’t know how they did it. Jeremy also helped me through the planning process, rentals, etc. I would highly recommend!
Sophie C'est la Vie
Cobblestone Catering along with their partner Pizza Moto catered our wedding and they did an incredible job. Jeremy the owner did the tasting with us for the small bites menu and was so professional and knowledgable about event coordination which was a huge help. At the walk thru on site at the venue, he was proactive in asking questions that we didn't even think of and had lots of insight that really was helpful. The food was fantastic, delicious and served beautifully, our guests raved about it. They went above and beyond our expectations and we would highly recommend them for any catering needs!
Caitlin Jones
This company is extremely unprofessional. The managers do not know what they are doing, and are not equipped to run a high end event, nor any event for that manner. The owner, Jeremy, is completely out to lunch. Not only that, the food is subpar and the prices are outrageous for what you get. There are many other catering companies in NYC. Use ANYONE else if you care about your event and and have the slightest bit of self-esteem.
Brooke P.
Unfortunately, the Cobblestone I remember must have peaked in 2012, and after being a long time customer, I will never return. The storefront has always have been overpriced ( par for the course on Court Street & Atlantic Ave) it's not even the worst part of their business model. The worst part is they will overpack portions ( so you pay more for the extra weight) and when you get home you will find your food might be rancid ( have had this specific experience with Quinoa salad, Broccoli & several other roasted veggie side dishes). The staff constantly looks displeased when you ask them questions or take any time trying to decide what to order, and the Manager is usually present during these interactions - but if your not booking him for a large event or a high society Hamptons Classic party over the summer, he's not interested in helping you. Spend your money elsewhere and skip this joint because they are not at all interested in making sure the ordinary neighborhood folks receive a delicious meal or quality customer service.
Miriam K.
Imagine my surprise when I ordered dinner for 6 for $375 when I saw they added a tip of $190....and the food wasn't even good. I spoke to the owner and he felt he deserved that tip. I obviously didn't agree. Buyer Beware!
Elizabeth Boenigk
This company used the pandemic as an excuse to steal $1500 from us for services and food we paid for but was never provided. Do not work with them. They are thieves and should be ashamed of themselves.
We paid this company close to $1500 for cocktail hour catering for our wedding, the pandemic hit only a couple weeks later so we had to cancel, and they used that as an excuse to keep our money without providing any services or food. Do not work with them they are thieves.
Eliza C.
We paid this company close to $1500 for cocktail hour catering for our wedding, the pandemic hit only a couple weeks later so we had to cancel, and they used that as an excuse to keep our money without providing any services or food. Do not work with them they are thieves.
Bill McBreen
These guys were great for Thanksgiving, highly recommend for sides and anything you need for meals.
alan silverman
Great food and service
Reema K.
Their rotisserie chicken is excellent, but do not miss their soups. Their tomato soup is my favorite. It is vegan and soooo creamy. I checked the ingredients more than once, expecting to find cream and/or cashews, but no. Just good old roasted veggies. The staff is awesome!
I’ve been ordering food from Cobblestone for four years and everything is always delicious, fresh, and beautifully presented. I’ve worked with them for everything from thanksgiving dishes to passed hors d’oeuvres to weeknight dinner party meals. Everything always exceeds my expectations. And the prices can’t be beat!
Evan and Seth did a fantastic job - they organized the space, served drinks and food and were beyond friendly and professional. The food was also great - as always. Thank you!
My firm used Cobblestone to cater at one of our partner's homes this week and we were extremely pleased. This partner has used Cobblestone for many of their events that they host at home and they are always happy to the food, customer service, and attention to detail. Jeremy in particular is great to work with and always very responsive. Definitely recommend!
I have no idea why there are any bad reviews for Jeremy and his team at Cobblestone. They catered my wedding at The Foundry in May 2022 and everything was PERFECT. The drinks and food were truly SO GOOD. My guests are still talking about how good our food was, some saying it's the best wedding food they have ever had. I spoke with many other caterers and I am extremely picky and I can promise you (and save you the time) that Cobblestone is the best choice BY FAR. We had a lot of special food restrictions and I had a lot of crazy and speciality drink requests and they handled every request without any questions asked. They even spent months sourcing mini patrol tequila bottles for me. Thank you so much for making my wedding day so amazing I am forever grateful!!!! I hope to work with you guys again for another event soon.
We hired Pizza Moto to cater our wedding and it turns out they handle the food but actually partner with Cobblestone Catering to handle the events planning and execution. Wedding was last weekend and it was a huge success! Food was awesome and Jeremy and his team did such an amazing job setting up not only for the dinner, but also the ceremony which was in the same space. It was a beautiful ceremony and then they had 1 hour to flip the room into an equally beautiful reception space. I honestly don’t know how they did it. Jeremy also helped me through the planning process, rentals, etc. I would highly recommend!
Cobblestone Catering along with their partner Pizza Moto catered our wedding and they did an incredible job. Jeremy the owner did the tasting with us for the small bites menu and was so professional and knowledgable about event coordination which was a huge help. At the walk thru on site at the venue, he was proactive in asking questions that we didn't even think of and had lots of insight that really was helpful. The food was fantastic, delicious and served beautifully, our guests raved about it. They went above and beyond our expectations and we would highly recommend them for any catering needs!
This company is extremely unprofessional. The managers do not know what they are doing, and are not equipped to run a high end event, nor any event for that manner. The owner, Jeremy, is completely out to lunch. Not only that, the food is subpar and the prices are outrageous for what you get. There are many other catering companies in NYC. Use ANYONE else if you care about your event and and have the slightest bit of self-esteem.
Unfortunately, the Cobblestone I remember must have peaked in 2012, and after being a long time customer, I will never return. The storefront has always have been overpriced ( par for the course on Court Street & Atlantic Ave) it's not even the worst part of their business model. The worst part is they will overpack portions ( so you pay more for the extra weight) and when you get home you will find your food might be rancid ( have had this specific experience with Quinoa salad, Broccoli & several other roasted veggie side dishes). The staff constantly looks displeased when you ask them questions or take any time trying to decide what to order, and the Manager is usually present during these interactions - but if your not booking him for a large event or a high society Hamptons Classic party over the summer, he's not interested in helping you. Spend your money elsewhere and skip this joint because they are not at all interested in making sure the ordinary neighborhood folks receive a delicious meal or quality customer service.
Imagine my surprise when I ordered dinner for 6 for $375 when I saw they added a tip of $190....and the food wasn't even good. I spoke to the owner and he felt he deserved that tip. I obviously didn't agree. Buyer Beware!
This company used the pandemic as an excuse to steal $1500 from us for services and food we paid for but was never provided. Do not work with them. They are thieves and should be ashamed of themselves.
Restaurantji Recommends
We paid this company close to $1500 for cocktail hour catering for our wedding, the pandemic hit only a couple weeks later so we had to cancel, and they used that as an excuse to keep our money without providing any services or food. Do not work with them they are thieves.
We paid this company close to $1500 for cocktail hour catering for our wedding, the pandemic hit only a couple weeks later so we had to cancel, and they used that as an excuse to keep our money without providing any services or food. Do not work with them they are thieves.
These guys were great for Thanksgiving, highly recommend for sides and anything you need for meals.
Great food and service
Their rotisserie chicken is excellent, but do not miss their soups. Their tomato soup is my favorite. It is vegan and soooo creamy. I checked the ingredients more than once, expecting to find cream and/or cashews, but no. Just good old roasted veggies. The staff is awesome!