The seafood is always fresh and delicious! Best fish market in the neighborhood.
Trope
I travel from the Bensonhurst section of Brooklyn to Cosentino's in Bay Ridge because the fish stores by me have changed for the worse. Luckily I found Cosentino's...this place is super clean, the fish is very fresh, and the staff is very nice. I would definitely recommend coming here.
Anthony P
Very nice fish store. One of the few around.
Nick P.
They have great seafood salad! We've been ordering it for years. Nothing skimped so there is plenty of everything!!!!!
Katie & Eric Caminiti
Best selection of fresh fish. Excellent service!
21rashad L.
I bought whitenig fish from that store on 6708 3rd Ave Bayridge I paid $53 for it The fish was horrible they smell like sh*t i brought them back to return them The store was closed I do not recommend any one to buy from that store The guy in the store told me that these were fresh and the best fish. Very unprofessional They should close that store
Kristen F.
Excellent quality seafood. I've purchased shrimp and salmon at this establishment so far. They cleaned the shrimp for me which was so, so awesome. I seared the salmon in cast iron then popped it in the oven. It came out so delicious and moist. I certainly will be a regular customer. You won't go wrong with this neighborhood gem. Thank you.
J9 Mayring (J9)
Cosentino's has been a staple in Bay Ridge for many decades. They are a friendly, family owned small business and their fish is really fresh! Choose from delicious salmon, cod, seafood, and more. Treat yourself to quality food and eat well.
A R.
Fantastic fish store. They stock a nice variety of truly fresh fish - you can tell by the texture and flavor, and from the fact that it never smells fishy in there. Everything I've tried has been perfect. Perhaps best of all, the owner is very knowledgeable and very nice. Last time he gave me suggestions for cooking fluke, which I wanted to try but knew nothing about, and today he gave me guidance on when the bluefish would be coming in from Long Island. There is a fish store closer to my house, but Consentino's is worth the walk....
Anna Tkachenko
Small place, not a big variety of seafood. The scallops were the best I've ever had though.
The finest fish in all Brooklyn ? great spot for real quality
Julie Blikher
Best shrimp, always honest about market.
Anthony De Coteau
Limited selection of fish and it was costly.
Jenny Russo
The fish is great and very high quality and very fresh. The only Italian store left in bklyn for fresh Fish.
Michael Beckerman
I shop here about once a week whenever I’m in town. I have never once been disappointed by the quality of the fish which is always excellent, and I’ve had the salmon, halibut, tilapia, scrod, scallops, sole and fantastic swordfish. I’ve always found the staff to be helpful and professional and with lots of integrity. Stores like this make me proud to live in Bay Ridge.
The seafood is always fresh and delicious! Best fish market in the neighborhood.
I travel from the Bensonhurst section of Brooklyn to Cosentino's in Bay Ridge because the fish stores by me have changed for the worse. Luckily I found Cosentino's...this place is super clean, the fish is very fresh, and the staff is very nice. I would definitely recommend coming here.
Very nice fish store. One of the few around.
They have great seafood salad! We've been ordering it for years. Nothing skimped so there is plenty of everything!!!!!
Best selection of fresh fish. Excellent service!
I bought whitenig fish from that store on 6708 3rd Ave Bayridge I paid $53 for it The fish was horrible they smell like sh*t i brought them back to return them The store was closed I do not recommend any one to buy from that store The guy in the store told me that these were fresh and the best fish. Very unprofessional They should close that store
Excellent quality seafood. I've purchased shrimp and salmon at this establishment so far. They cleaned the shrimp for me which was so, so awesome. I seared the salmon in cast iron then popped it in the oven. It came out so delicious and moist. I certainly will be a regular customer. You won't go wrong with this neighborhood gem. Thank you.
Cosentino's has been a staple in Bay Ridge for many decades. They are a friendly, family owned small business and their fish is really fresh! Choose from delicious salmon, cod, seafood, and more. Treat yourself to quality food and eat well.
Fantastic fish store. They stock a nice variety of truly fresh fish - you can tell by the texture and flavor, and from the fact that it never smells fishy in there. Everything I've tried has been perfect. Perhaps best of all, the owner is very knowledgeable and very nice. Last time he gave me suggestions for cooking fluke, which I wanted to try but knew nothing about, and today he gave me guidance on when the bluefish would be coming in from Long Island. There is a fish store closer to my house, but Consentino's is worth the walk....
Small place, not a big variety of seafood. The scallops were the best I've ever had though.
Restaurantji Recommends
The finest fish in all Brooklyn ? great spot for real quality
Best shrimp, always honest about market.
Limited selection of fish and it was costly.
The fish is great and very high quality and very fresh. The only Italian store left in bklyn for fresh Fish.
I shop here about once a week whenever I’m in town. I have never once been disappointed by the quality of the fish which is always excellent, and I’ve had the salmon, halibut, tilapia, scrod, scallops, sole and fantastic swordfish. I’ve always found the staff to be helpful and professional and with lots of integrity. Stores like this make me proud to live in Bay Ridge.