Their $27 burger was like an orgasm inside my mouth! The meat was juicy and rich and everything I was hoping it would be! I would fly back to NY just to get this bigger. Absolutely amazing
Ryan Nader
The food was very good. The burger was as good as I’d hoped, although the accompanying waffle fries weren’t a patch on good fries. The vegetarian pizza was also very good. Could have been a touch crispier and wouldn’t have hurt being cooked for another minute.The service was very poor. There was no interest in the customer, it does have a conveyer belt feel. Get in, eat, get out. There’s no warmth with the service. I wished for a better experience, one that the food deservesDon’t sit outside in the cold. We did and the awning was left open. We had to continue closing it. The waiter kept opening and never once asked if we were comfortable
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Kate Kosche
Fantastic pizza and wings in otherwise routine setting. Server was excellent. Cocktails were weak. The burgers looked great so next time will get one of those.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Nguyen’S Hot Wings
Alexandre Borges
Terrible
Service: 1
Alan Phelps
The pepperoni cup pizza really hits the spot every time, doesn't it? Walking just a few blocks to grab one has become a bit of a ritual for me, maybe too much of one, haha. Tried the Emily burger recently, based on the rave it's getting, and yep, it's a messy affair but in a finger-lickin' good way – the sauce, onion, and cheese do a little dance that's quite the show. The atmosphere's cozy, perfect for a small get-together or a solo food adventure. Service is on point, though I reckon on sunnier days, you'd be lucky to snag a table.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda D.
I've been here twice now since my friend put me on. Let me start off by saying that i'm not a big pizza girlie and it's only ever so often that I'll crave a slice or two. However this place? Stamping it as my official go-to place whenever I want my pizza fix. The inside is fairly small so expect to be close to the table next to you. Im talking the kind of close where you'll have to shift your table to get in and out. Service is relatively fast and all of the waitstaff are pretty friendly. We started with the calamari bc whenever there's calamari on the menu, i'm ordering it! The breading was perfect and the calamari was flavorful and crispy. I enjoyed the duo a special mayo and some marinara. (How all fried calamari should be served, in my opinion). For our entree we decided to split the colony pie. It's a red pizza with cheese, pepperoni, pickled jalapeños and topped with some hot honey. Whoever invented honey on pizza is genius because it's the perfect combo of salty and sweet. The pizza toppings to cheese to sauce ratio was perfect. Personally I think one is good to share between two people but if you're a group -- def opt to get more! Although we were feeling stuffed, the table next to us convinced us to get the banana pudding for dessert. It DID NOT DISAPPOINT. It's the type of banana pudding that would give Magnolias a run for their money. (Sorry not sorry)
Lucy Brinkman
The Emmy burger lives up to the hype, and earns my 5 star rating. Truly wish I could eat this over and over again. Servers were kind and accommodating, and helped make the restaurant accessible to my 8 month old. No high chairs but they did have a booster seat which did the trick. Pizza didn’t stick out to me, but I wouldn’t try it again to make sure!Kid-friendliness: Booster seat available
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Emmy Burger and Fries
Alexandra S.
Phenomal pizza every time. Hot, fresh, and delicious! Very much recommend Emily. Go for a slice!
Fariddin Mukhammad Rakhim
Teach the guy with the glasses to be nice please. Thank you!
I get the "no modification or substitutions" thing but you should be able to opt for no cheese on your burger. Simple enough.
salvatore gallaro
Top 10 burgers in NYC!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Emmy Burger and Fries, Sauce
Nicole
Emily pizza is where it's
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
C J.
The pepperoni cup pizza is both filling and fulfilling! The price is reason enough to try alone. I'm only a few blocks away so being so close by is dangerous because I'd have it at least once a week.
Andrew M.
Didnt need to wait on a weekend around 1pm but that might have to due with the fact there were flurries and it was cold. Everyone seemed to have been having a good time inside and enjoying their food. Not a lot of tables though and I would expect it to be more crowded on nicer days. Ordered the karaage, emmy burger, and an Emily pizza. Pizza came super quick and was delicious, though the honey seemed to be overwhelmingly sweet. The karaage seems to be chicken thighs battered, fried, and then sauced. Comes with a cilantro ranch dressing that was very herby, but good. The Emmy burger was the reason we chose to try this place and honestly was kind of a let down. There was a lot going on, the caramelized onion, emmy sauce, and juice from the burger made for a very messy eating experience. It was good, not sure it was worth the price point and effort. Overall, nice place to try but I dont think I would be visiting again. Have had better food for half the price.
Their $27 burger was like an orgasm inside my mouth! The meat was juicy and rich and everything I was hoping it would be! I would fly back to NY just to get this bigger. Absolutely amazing
The food was very good. The burger was as good as I’d hoped, although the accompanying waffle fries weren’t a patch on good fries. The vegetarian pizza was also very good. Could have been a touch crispier and wouldn’t have hurt being cooked for another minute.The service was very poor. There was no interest in the customer, it does have a conveyer belt feel. Get in, eat, get out. There’s no warmth with the service. I wished for a better experience, one that the food deservesDon’t sit outside in the cold. We did and the awning was left open. We had to continue closing it. The waiter kept opening and never once asked if we were comfortable
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Fantastic pizza and wings in otherwise routine setting. Server was excellent. Cocktails were weak. The burgers looked great so next time will get one of those.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Nguyen’S Hot Wings
Terrible
Service: 1
The pepperoni cup pizza really hits the spot every time, doesn't it? Walking just a few blocks to grab one has become a bit of a ritual for me, maybe too much of one, haha. Tried the Emily burger recently, based on the rave it's getting, and yep, it's a messy affair but in a finger-lickin' good way – the sauce, onion, and cheese do a little dance that's quite the show. The atmosphere's cozy, perfect for a small get-together or a solo food adventure. Service is on point, though I reckon on sunnier days, you'd be lucky to snag a table.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've been here twice now since my friend put me on. Let me start off by saying that i'm not a big pizza girlie and it's only ever so often that I'll crave a slice or two. However this place? Stamping it as my official go-to place whenever I want my pizza fix. The inside is fairly small so expect to be close to the table next to you. Im talking the kind of close where you'll have to shift your table to get in and out. Service is relatively fast and all of the waitstaff are pretty friendly. We started with the calamari bc whenever there's calamari on the menu, i'm ordering it! The breading was perfect and the calamari was flavorful and crispy. I enjoyed the duo a special mayo and some marinara. (How all fried calamari should be served, in my opinion). For our entree we decided to split the colony pie. It's a red pizza with cheese, pepperoni, pickled jalapeños and topped with some hot honey. Whoever invented honey on pizza is genius because it's the perfect combo of salty and sweet. The pizza toppings to cheese to sauce ratio was perfect. Personally I think one is good to share between two people but if you're a group -- def opt to get more! Although we were feeling stuffed, the table next to us convinced us to get the banana pudding for dessert. It DID NOT DISAPPOINT. It's the type of banana pudding that would give Magnolias a run for their money. (Sorry not sorry)
The Emmy burger lives up to the hype, and earns my 5 star rating. Truly wish I could eat this over and over again. Servers were kind and accommodating, and helped make the restaurant accessible to my 8 month old. No high chairs but they did have a booster seat which did the trick. Pizza didn’t stick out to me, but I wouldn’t try it again to make sure!Kid-friendliness: Booster seat available
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Emmy Burger and Fries
Phenomal pizza every time. Hot, fresh, and delicious! Very much recommend Emily. Go for a slice!
Teach the guy with the glasses to be nice please. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Exceptional food, especially namesake
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I get the "no modification or substitutions" thing but you should be able to opt for no cheese on your burger. Simple enough.
Top 10 burgers in NYC!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Emmy Burger and Fries, Sauce
Emily pizza is where it's
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pepperoni cup pizza is both filling and fulfilling! The price is reason enough to try alone. I'm only a few blocks away so being so close by is dangerous because I'd have it at least once a week.
Didnt need to wait on a weekend around 1pm but that might have to due with the fact there were flurries and it was cold. Everyone seemed to have been having a good time inside and enjoying their food. Not a lot of tables though and I would expect it to be more crowded on nicer days. Ordered the karaage, emmy burger, and an Emily pizza. Pizza came super quick and was delicious, though the honey seemed to be overwhelmingly sweet. The karaage seems to be chicken thighs battered, fried, and then sauced. Comes with a cilantro ranch dressing that was very herby, but good. The Emmy burger was the reason we chose to try this place and honestly was kind of a let down. There was a lot going on, the caramelized onion, emmy sauce, and juice from the burger made for a very messy eating experience. It was good, not sure it was worth the price point and effort. Overall, nice place to try but I dont think I would be visiting again. Have had better food for half the price.