Well I've been going there since I was 10 years old. I'm 52 and I'm still going to get a slice or two, can't forget beef patties with cheese ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pepperoniprince C.
Ordered: White slice and a saucy Buffalo Chicken Slice Drink of choice: Plain old water Found: Christ Going to Liberty Pizzeria is always a very electrifying experience to me. The pizza is always hot, fresh, and tasty, and the workers are nice as well. This time was different, but not in a bad way. Oh no, in an amazing way. Allow me to elucidate. I visited Liberty at 2:03 pm as I always do, on a Wednesday- not on my usual Mondays. I felt called to enter the building that day- you will soon see why. I order my usual and as I am waiting- I think. I am currently employed as a gym teacher, not a public but a catholic school. I remember my youth. From 3rd grade on up until I graduated, I attended Catholic school myself. I had never found myself drawn to the Faith as a child, of course I attended mass- but that was required of me. Never forced, but I never had a connection to Jesus in my time there. However, there was a moment in my sophomore year of high school we were visited by a priest from the diocese. He told us about his life and situation. In the back of my mind, a voice called to me- what if I became a priest? I toyed with the possibility, but ultimately tucked it deep away. The nagging feeling in me persisted silently. My two beautiful slices came, and I sat down to eat them. I finish my buffalo slice, which was delectable and move to my pepperoni. That's when I see him. In a bubble of the dough on my slice, the image of Jesus appeared before me, cooked into the crust. Jesus looked at me, his eyes beautiful and shining, a soft smile on his lips as if to say "my child, it is alright. Come home." I broke down into tears almost immediately. I have done many bad things in my life, after the affair and the divorce I was left alone with my consequences. Through teary eyes I look at Jesus and nod. I know my path now, to reenter the Faith, to return as the wounded lamb on his proud Shepard's back. He did not leave me behind- I was ignorant to ignore him. I felt compelled to consume the piece, hearing his voice in me saying "my son, this is my body which I have given up for you, take part of it." and not hesitating, I ate the slice. He is with me forever, and he has never left. In the time I am writing this, I have quit my job and I am already contacting my local diocese. Thank you Liberty Pizzeria for bringing Jesus Christ back into my life again. Below I have attached a recreation of the Christ Slice, I never took a picture because I ate it before I could. Apologies
peen pasta
I would not order from here if you want a pie with a reasonable amount of toppings. I ordered a large pie with sausage peppers and onions, the pie they gave me was so sparse and they left out the onions! Each slice had about 3-4 slices of sausage and no more than 4 pieces of pepper. Luigi’s nearby will pile the toppings on your pizza, they were closed today but are always a better option. Forgetting the onions could be an honest mistake, but skimping on the rest was low. In all my decades of eating New York pizza I’ve never been so hurt and disappointed by a pie. The workers are nice enough
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Jenny
Tasty pizza, the guy behind the counter is nice, has a smile and is nice to all the customers which is frankly refreshing to see. Would recommend!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Borgore G
13$ for 4 slices when Mario’s a few blocks away sells entire pies for 14$!?!?This pizza is WAY too mediocre for this price and the pizza place looks like it hasn’t been renovated in 40 years.This place is comparable to 2 bros but it’s 3x the price.
S
Had a great regular slice the other day - perfect Brooklyn pizza: fresh, tangy tomato sauce, mozzarella, and the fluffiest most delicious crust! Can’t wait to try their pies and the pepperoni.
Victor Antonio LLanos LLanos
Go at your own peril. Not the best pizza, but good enough if you're drunk.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
D H.
Great service and convenient. Always respectful upon delivery. Would recommend definitely.
Su
Had a great regular slice the other day - perfect Brooklyn pizza: fresh, tangy tomato sauce, mozzarella, and the fluffiest most delicious crust! Can’t wait to try their pies and the pepperoni.
Supreet Kaur
The people who work here are so nice it makes me want to support the establishment and the pizza is solid
Ordered online, pizza is good, no complaints jsut a lil oily but that's ny pizza, somewhat thin crust, good mozzarella sticks, how u kno if a pizzeria is good, if the mozzarella sticks
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Jeff Hall
Liberty Pizza has such an amazing staff. They remember us every time! We love their Buffalo Chicken Pizza and the Garlic Knots. The price is perfect and they are the best ?
Dean Chalmers
Cancelled order via grubhub for no reason and made out that grubhub was at fault. Was rude on the call to my partner. Avoid. Poor. Liberty - Do better.
Satya Popuri
This is one of the best Pizzarias in Brooklyn. The pizza is so traditional and authentic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
V S.
I want to like it but I've had a slice here twice and been sick both times (but several years apart) :( Maybe it's just a greasiness thing , I'm not sure. Seems like it's just me. But I still often buy pizza dough from them and make pizza at home- no issues !
Well I've been going there since I was 10 years old. I'm 52 and I'm still going to get a slice or two, can't forget beef patties with cheese ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered: White slice and a saucy Buffalo Chicken Slice Drink of choice: Plain old water Found: Christ Going to Liberty Pizzeria is always a very electrifying experience to me. The pizza is always hot, fresh, and tasty, and the workers are nice as well. This time was different, but not in a bad way. Oh no, in an amazing way. Allow me to elucidate. I visited Liberty at 2:03 pm as I always do, on a Wednesday- not on my usual Mondays. I felt called to enter the building that day- you will soon see why. I order my usual and as I am waiting- I think. I am currently employed as a gym teacher, not a public but a catholic school. I remember my youth. From 3rd grade on up until I graduated, I attended Catholic school myself. I had never found myself drawn to the Faith as a child, of course I attended mass- but that was required of me. Never forced, but I never had a connection to Jesus in my time there. However, there was a moment in my sophomore year of high school we were visited by a priest from the diocese. He told us about his life and situation. In the back of my mind, a voice called to me- what if I became a priest? I toyed with the possibility, but ultimately tucked it deep away. The nagging feeling in me persisted silently. My two beautiful slices came, and I sat down to eat them. I finish my buffalo slice, which was delectable and move to my pepperoni. That's when I see him. In a bubble of the dough on my slice, the image of Jesus appeared before me, cooked into the crust. Jesus looked at me, his eyes beautiful and shining, a soft smile on his lips as if to say "my child, it is alright. Come home." I broke down into tears almost immediately. I have done many bad things in my life, after the affair and the divorce I was left alone with my consequences. Through teary eyes I look at Jesus and nod. I know my path now, to reenter the Faith, to return as the wounded lamb on his proud Shepard's back. He did not leave me behind- I was ignorant to ignore him. I felt compelled to consume the piece, hearing his voice in me saying "my son, this is my body which I have given up for you, take part of it." and not hesitating, I ate the slice. He is with me forever, and he has never left. In the time I am writing this, I have quit my job and I am already contacting my local diocese. Thank you Liberty Pizzeria for bringing Jesus Christ back into my life again. Below I have attached a recreation of the Christ Slice, I never took a picture because I ate it before I could. Apologies
I would not order from here if you want a pie with a reasonable amount of toppings. I ordered a large pie with sausage peppers and onions, the pie they gave me was so sparse and they left out the onions! Each slice had about 3-4 slices of sausage and no more than 4 pieces of pepper. Luigi’s nearby will pile the toppings on your pizza, they were closed today but are always a better option. Forgetting the onions could be an honest mistake, but skimping on the rest was low. In all my decades of eating New York pizza I’ve never been so hurt and disappointed by a pie. The workers are nice enough
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Tasty pizza, the guy behind the counter is nice, has a smile and is nice to all the customers which is frankly refreshing to see. Would recommend!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
13$ for 4 slices when Mario’s a few blocks away sells entire pies for 14$!?!?This pizza is WAY too mediocre for this price and the pizza place looks like it hasn’t been renovated in 40 years.This place is comparable to 2 bros but it’s 3x the price.
Had a great regular slice the other day - perfect Brooklyn pizza: fresh, tangy tomato sauce, mozzarella, and the fluffiest most delicious crust! Can’t wait to try their pies and the pepperoni.
Go at your own peril. Not the best pizza, but good enough if you're drunk.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great service and convenient. Always respectful upon delivery. Would recommend definitely.
Had a great regular slice the other day - perfect Brooklyn pizza: fresh, tangy tomato sauce, mozzarella, and the fluffiest most delicious crust! Can’t wait to try their pies and the pepperoni.
The people who work here are so nice it makes me want to support the establishment and the pizza is solid
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Ordered online, pizza is good, no complaints jsut a lil oily but that's ny pizza, somewhat thin crust, good mozzarella sticks, how u kno if a pizzeria is good, if the mozzarella sticks
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Liberty Pizza has such an amazing staff. They remember us every time! We love their Buffalo Chicken Pizza and the Garlic Knots. The price is perfect and they are the best ?
Cancelled order via grubhub for no reason and made out that grubhub was at fault. Was rude on the call to my partner. Avoid. Poor. Liberty - Do better.
This is one of the best Pizzarias in Brooklyn. The pizza is so traditional and authentic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I want to like it but I've had a slice here twice and been sick both times (but several years apart) :( Maybe it's just a greasiness thing , I'm not sure. Seems like it's just me. But I still often buy pizza dough from them and make pizza at home- no issues !