This is a new level of service & food for 5th Ave. As soon as you walk in the smell is incredible, atmosphere is cozy, clean, classy. . The staff is wonderful, the drinks are delicious & made with love by Rafael. Food is 5 ⭐️. Oysters are fresh, crab cake perfectly paired w/ a light salad, Brussels amazing in a sweet and spicy sauce, high quality steak.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
aria
My partner was in the mood for some oysters so we decided to check this place out, the atmosphere was ok a little low lit for my preference but they did have a little table lamp that helped. First the oysters, they had a decent line up more than 5 types which was nice, they were a little small for how pricey they were but outside of that they were fresh! After that we ordered the octopus, my take the octopus was tender...... as a dish i dont think it made sence the flavor didnt compliment each other but separate they whould of been fine. After that we got the linguine with clams which was the saving grace of the experience though it was mild the sauce that the dish came in was really good, though i wished we got more linguine. The last thing we ordered was the lamb racks were ok.Never have i spent 200 and left feeling hungry and unsatisfied the shiney grace was the clambs and our server.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Kumamoto Oysters
Harriet G.
The atmosphere is serene-no kitschy decorations, and the music was pleasantly subdued. Our server-Matthew- couldn't have been any more welcoming and helpful. We took his suggestion for the oysters and they were briny -but not too much-just the way my husband loves them. His wine suggestion for me was wonderful. We had the prix fixe dinners. My octopus was very tender and served on a bed of black ink hummus with pomegranates, his crab cakes were plumb and not full of filler like many other places. The pasta dishes-mushroom tagliatelle and lobster ravioli were both perfect. My skirt steak was done just the way I asked for it and the vegetables that accompanied it were done just right. My husband thought the mussels Fra Diablo were a little too "tomatoee", but that didn't stop him from finishing all of them. Desserts were the perfect end to the meal-key lime mousse and peach cobbler. Definitely recommend this for repeat visits.
Danaya Chugunova
Went out for my bday for brunch with my friends and really enjoyed everything about the experience !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Kumamoto Oysters
Violet Richardson
Went for oysters on Valentine's Day with my boyfriend. The prix-fixe menu for the holiday looked amazing, but we had other plans for dinner. We sat at the bar and had a couple rounds of oysters and drinks. The staff were so sweet and everything was delicious, we had a great time. Thanks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Akua A.
The best dish here has to be the mushroom pasta! The wines are great. I wish the menu had a bit more variety. The staff was super friendly.
Emmanuel Vargas-Zapata
Siren Oyster Bar is amazing!! I couldn't stop eating and ordering different variety of oysters. The Connecticut Lobster Roll was great too! Planning my next trip to Siren ASAP. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Raviolli
Vanessa Ortiz
Phenomenal just phenomenal! I would come back for each dish because everything was my favorite. Each item was given so much care and attention to detail. We had the best Osters and Lobster Roll (& I was raised in Long Island that’s saying ALOT)! We couldn’t stop buying osters lol. I think we did about three rounds of oster appetizers. I also LOVED the Lobster Ravioli, it truly blew me away. Finally, we ended the night with the infamous bread pudding…. and I would return to this space just for this dessert! It took me back to my childhood, it was milk sweet but not to sweet and baked crispy at the top but soft and flavorful on the inside. On top of all of that the drinks and shots were great quality. The service and the atmosphere were exceptional as well. I look forward to coming back here and next time I’m inviting my folks and some friends to impress. Great space, I would highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Raviolli
Sudhey Reyes
Amazing food and drinks!! Will definitely come back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michele Jason
Food and cocktails were excellent except for the lobster roll which was WAY MORE roll than lobster. It definitely could have used more lobster. Outside of that one item everything was delicious and we would definitely eat here again.
Unfortunately our experience did not match that of these other 5 star reviews. We were excited to try Siren as south slope desperately needs some fine dining options. We got lamb chops, lobster ravioli, and clam pasta. Pasta was homemade but unfortunately that was the only positive. The dishes just weren’t good. Dishes were not seasoned, raviolis were thick and not delicate - there were only 4 and we didn’t finish them.If this was just an affordable local spot I would give it another chance.But at dishes hitting $30 I expected much more. The most flavorful dish we tried was my daughter’s red sauce pasta from the children’s menu- it was actually really good but this should not have been the best thing on the menu.I did not get oysters or try happy hour so maybe that’s the time to go if you don’t want to break the bank but did not find this meal worth the crazy prices and flavor was just not good.
Bella Trejos
Food is amazing! Great options for both seafood and steak. Favorite was chicken and waffles and lobster. Service is great too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennie Price
Amanda, our server, was fantastic. Food and drinks were great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vladislava Kursheva
What a Wonderful discovery.Big thanks to the app Seated ?This place transfers you from the colorless streets of Brooklyn to an amazing food journey in a coastal land.The food was amazing. Service is professional and comfy. Big Love
I'm somewhat on the fence with posting this review. My experience was not quite as grand as the yelp* community. I grabbed a seat at the bar, and I ordered from the restaurant week menu. I began with the Octopus. The Octopus was tasty, but the black bean concoction didn't work. My second course was Linguine with Clams. The Pasta was overcooked, and the clams were a bit sandy. My third course was Mussels ala Marinara. The Mussels were good, but could have used a bit more spice. I finished with the Key Lime mousse. It was very tasty. Would somebody please tell management that those swinging kitchen doors are a nuisance. Thank you next!
This is a new level of service & food for 5th Ave. As soon as you walk in the smell is incredible, atmosphere is cozy, clean, classy. . The staff is wonderful, the drinks are delicious & made with love by Rafael. Food is 5 ⭐️. Oysters are fresh, crab cake perfectly paired w/ a light salad, Brussels amazing in a sweet and spicy sauce, high quality steak.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My partner was in the mood for some oysters so we decided to check this place out, the atmosphere was ok a little low lit for my preference but they did have a little table lamp that helped. First the oysters, they had a decent line up more than 5 types which was nice, they were a little small for how pricey they were but outside of that they were fresh! After that we ordered the octopus, my take the octopus was tender...... as a dish i dont think it made sence the flavor didnt compliment each other but separate they whould of been fine. After that we got the linguine with clams which was the saving grace of the experience though it was mild the sauce that the dish came in was really good, though i wished we got more linguine. The last thing we ordered was the lamb racks were ok.Never have i spent 200 and left feeling hungry and unsatisfied the shiney grace was the clambs and our server.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Kumamoto Oysters
The atmosphere is serene-no kitschy decorations, and the music was pleasantly subdued. Our server-Matthew- couldn't have been any more welcoming and helpful. We took his suggestion for the oysters and they were briny -but not too much-just the way my husband loves them. His wine suggestion for me was wonderful. We had the prix fixe dinners. My octopus was very tender and served on a bed of black ink hummus with pomegranates, his crab cakes were plumb and not full of filler like many other places. The pasta dishes-mushroom tagliatelle and lobster ravioli were both perfect. My skirt steak was done just the way I asked for it and the vegetables that accompanied it were done just right. My husband thought the mussels Fra Diablo were a little too "tomatoee", but that didn't stop him from finishing all of them. Desserts were the perfect end to the meal-key lime mousse and peach cobbler. Definitely recommend this for repeat visits.
Went out for my bday for brunch with my friends and really enjoyed everything about the experience !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Kumamoto Oysters
Went for oysters on Valentine's Day with my boyfriend. The prix-fixe menu for the holiday looked amazing, but we had other plans for dinner. We sat at the bar and had a couple rounds of oysters and drinks. The staff were so sweet and everything was delicious, we had a great time. Thanks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best dish here has to be the mushroom pasta! The wines are great. I wish the menu had a bit more variety. The staff was super friendly.
Siren Oyster Bar is amazing!! I couldn't stop eating and ordering different variety of oysters. The Connecticut Lobster Roll was great too! Planning my next trip to Siren ASAP. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Raviolli
Phenomenal just phenomenal! I would come back for each dish because everything was my favorite. Each item was given so much care and attention to detail. We had the best Osters and Lobster Roll (& I was raised in Long Island that’s saying ALOT)! We couldn’t stop buying osters lol. I think we did about three rounds of oster appetizers. I also LOVED the Lobster Ravioli, it truly blew me away. Finally, we ended the night with the infamous bread pudding…. and I would return to this space just for this dessert! It took me back to my childhood, it was milk sweet but not to sweet and baked crispy at the top but soft and flavorful on the inside. On top of all of that the drinks and shots were great quality. The service and the atmosphere were exceptional as well. I look forward to coming back here and next time I’m inviting my folks and some friends to impress. Great space, I would highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Raviolli
Amazing food and drinks!! Will definitely come back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food and cocktails were excellent except for the lobster roll which was WAY MORE roll than lobster. It definitely could have used more lobster. Outside of that one item everything was delicious and we would definitely eat here again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Connecticut Lobster Roll, Potato Leek Soup, Lamb Chops, Kumamoto Oysters
Restaurantji Recommends
Unfortunately our experience did not match that of these other 5 star reviews. We were excited to try Siren as south slope desperately needs some fine dining options. We got lamb chops, lobster ravioli, and clam pasta. Pasta was homemade but unfortunately that was the only positive. The dishes just weren’t good. Dishes were not seasoned, raviolis were thick and not delicate - there were only 4 and we didn’t finish them.If this was just an affordable local spot I would give it another chance.But at dishes hitting $30 I expected much more. The most flavorful dish we tried was my daughter’s red sauce pasta from the children’s menu- it was actually really good but this should not have been the best thing on the menu.I did not get oysters or try happy hour so maybe that’s the time to go if you don’t want to break the bank but did not find this meal worth the crazy prices and flavor was just not good.
Food is amazing! Great options for both seafood and steak. Favorite was chicken and waffles and lobster. Service is great too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda, our server, was fantastic. Food and drinks were great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What a Wonderful discovery.Big thanks to the app Seated ?This place transfers you from the colorless streets of Brooklyn to an amazing food journey in a coastal land.The food was amazing. Service is professional and comfy. Big Love
Recommended dishes: Potato Leek Soup, Octopus, Fritto Misto
I'm somewhat on the fence with posting this review. My experience was not quite as grand as the yelp* community. I grabbed a seat at the bar, and I ordered from the restaurant week menu. I began with the Octopus. The Octopus was tasty, but the black bean concoction didn't work. My second course was Linguine with Clams. The Pasta was overcooked, and the clams were a bit sandy. My third course was Mussels ala Marinara. The Mussels were good, but could have used a bit more spice. I finished with the Key Lime mousse. It was very tasty. Would somebody please tell management that those swinging kitchen doors are a nuisance. Thank you next!