Their chicken finger pizza is the most amazing pizza and it’s by far the #1 pizza in western NY. I decided that it’s even better than my favorite filet mignon. Keep up the great work.
Food: 5
Amber
Love this place and the people. Authentic REAL Italian pie.Quality ingredients and awesome staff!. Very affordable & fast. ALWAYS has fresh slices availableKid-friendliness: Great to my kiddoWheelchair accessibility: Yes
Always good! my husband's favorite and a go to for pizzeria food. I enjoy their consistency in quality food and good service.
Meadow S.
First time trying Johnny's. Saw a post on Twitter about the best pizza in Buffalo and Johnny's popped up multiple times, so I had to try it. Pizza was cooked perfectly with just the right amount of cheese. Sauce and pepperoni had great flavor. Will definitely have to get again!
Scatpack716
A favorite spot for subs for me!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calzone
Scott S.
This was my first time getting pizza and wings from Johnny's, and I will say I will be back. I ordered 2 pizzas this crust, and I received exactly what I asked for. The cheese they use is very good, and the flavor of the pizza overall was excellent. My family also loved the pizza and the wings. They have a sweet sauce they call Caribbean and I tried that and it is really really good. The staff was friendly and also note that I went Super Bowl Sunday at 6 pm. They had their act together, and everyone in the front area was taken care of . If you've never been here, I would definitely give it a try.
michele polino
On 2/4, we ordered a large pizza and 20 wings. This is a 1st time for us ordering from here. The wings tasted old and dried out. As if they had been previously made and reheated. Very disappointing and a waste of money. The pepperoni on the pizza was good but overall an average pizza.
Food: 3
Chris Kivi
Stopped by to check it out after 20 years and it's still a really good pizza place. Good slices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James M.
My whole life I've hated pizza, I've been made to try it 100 times over, one day at work I was starving and our boss ordered Johnny's chicken finger pizza, took me 27 years but I finally found pizza I actually like
don't find myself in Cheektowaga often so this was a first for me. but we ordered delivery and it came fast, pizza and wings were both great. if you're in the neighborhood definitely treat yourself!
Food: 5
ZodyPlayz
So ordered hot chicken finger sub whick tasted like old grease and not to mention it was soggy the bread was just mush with chicken on top horrible experience never
Food: 1
douglas krockenberger
Meh, pizza! Quite average compared to others in the area.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Jennifer Loughran
Disappointed with the lack of customer service after a mistake was made on their part. An apology was made, but seemed more like an excuse and was surprised that no compensation was provided for the mistake made.
Service: 2
Debbie S
Pizza ?, fries and sub was very good. Great service.
Everything here is excellent. Can't find better subs in Buffalo.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Taco, French Fries, Chicken Finger Pizza, Cheeseburger, Steak, BBQ, Chicken Finger, Turkey, Cheese & Pepperoni 16 Large, Greek Pizza, Buffalo's Original 50 Bucket, Chicken Wings, Steak Pizza
Their chicken finger pizza is the most amazing pizza and it’s by far the #1 pizza in western NY. I decided that it’s even better than my favorite filet mignon. Keep up the great work.
Food: 5
Love this place and the people. Authentic REAL Italian pie.Quality ingredients and awesome staff!. Very affordable & fast. ALWAYS has fresh slices availableKid-friendliness: Great to my kiddoWheelchair accessibility: Yes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White, Taco, Calzone, Chicken Wings, Steak Pizza
Always good! my husband's favorite and a go to for pizzeria food. I enjoy their consistency in quality food and good service.
First time trying Johnny's. Saw a post on Twitter about the best pizza in Buffalo and Johnny's popped up multiple times, so I had to try it. Pizza was cooked perfectly with just the right amount of cheese. Sauce and pepperoni had great flavor. Will definitely have to get again!
A favorite spot for subs for me!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calzone
This was my first time getting pizza and wings from Johnny's, and I will say I will be back. I ordered 2 pizzas this crust, and I received exactly what I asked for. The cheese they use is very good, and the flavor of the pizza overall was excellent. My family also loved the pizza and the wings. They have a sweet sauce they call Caribbean and I tried that and it is really really good. The staff was friendly and also note that I went Super Bowl Sunday at 6 pm. They had their act together, and everyone in the front area was taken care of . If you've never been here, I would definitely give it a try.
On 2/4, we ordered a large pizza and 20 wings. This is a 1st time for us ordering from here. The wings tasted old and dried out. As if they had been previously made and reheated. Very disappointing and a waste of money. The pepperoni on the pizza was good but overall an average pizza.
Food: 3
Stopped by to check it out after 20 years and it's still a really good pizza place. Good slices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My whole life I've hated pizza, I've been made to try it 100 times over, one day at work I was starving and our boss ordered Johnny's chicken finger pizza, took me 27 years but I finally found pizza I actually like
Restaurantji Recommends
don't find myself in Cheektowaga often so this was a first for me. but we ordered delivery and it came fast, pizza and wings were both great. if you're in the neighborhood definitely treat yourself!
Food: 5
So ordered hot chicken finger sub whick tasted like old grease and not to mention it was soggy the bread was just mush with chicken on top horrible experience never
Food: 1
Meh, pizza! Quite average compared to others in the area.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Disappointed with the lack of customer service after a mistake was made on their part. An apology was made, but seemed more like an excuse and was surprised that no compensation was provided for the mistake made.
Service: 2
Pizza ?, fries and sub was very good. Great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak Sub, Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza Sheet