Hands down one of the best Pizzas anywhere! Try the Penny’s sauce, you won’t regret it. Great owners, consistently great food.
Dan Dano
Wings were over cooked , hard , this used to be a good place for food maybe this was just an accident but I am not going to rush to find out
Brian Wells
Wings were excellent !
Krista S Pusatier
Accommodating! Great service!
Pizziewings Gigante
The sweet sauce is amazing!
Aaron Wagner
Best place to get pizza logs to go considering the price! (5 logs/$5.50)
William Martin
Awesome pizza ?
Michelle Smith
First time ordering from Penny’s. We had medium wings and fries. No complaints the food was awesome. We will definitely be returning and recommending.
Carolyn B.
Older man working made a racist comment about how he only puts a mask on when he's close to "Asians and Arabs." It wasn't a joke, just pure ignorance and bigotry. Also was told 30-35 minutes and it took 50+. Pizza itself was fine, but nothing to write home about.
Greg R.
Looking for a new pizza place and thought I'd try this, due to the reviews and the location being close by. The pizza was good but wasn't great. I liked the pepperoni, but the rest was just ok, but nothing negative.
Always down to try a "new" pizza spot! I'm a huge fan of sweet sauce on pizza so I was very excited to order from Penny's. Honestly, everything about the pizza and wings we ordered was great. My only comment is that everything was super greasy; not a complaint, just something to point out! My medium wings were also a little overdone and chewy but my bf loved his hot wings. Everything was tasty and I'm excited to have another great option to go back to!
Jenna Cleland
Highly recommend. So delicious, make sure you get the sweet sauce!
Joe Lojacono
Best pizza in tonawanda
Kaleaha Gutierrez
Quick services and friendly staff! Always a pleasure to order from them!
Hands down one of the best Pizzas anywhere! Try the Penny’s sauce, you won’t regret it. Great owners, consistently great food.
Wings were over cooked , hard , this used to be a good place for food maybe this was just an accident but I am not going to rush to find out
Wings were excellent !
Accommodating! Great service!
The sweet sauce is amazing!
Best place to get pizza logs to go considering the price! (5 logs/$5.50)
Awesome pizza ?
First time ordering from Penny’s. We had medium wings and fries. No complaints the food was awesome. We will definitely be returning and recommending.
Older man working made a racist comment about how he only puts a mask on when he's close to "Asians and Arabs." It wasn't a joke, just pure ignorance and bigotry. Also was told 30-35 minutes and it took 50+. Pizza itself was fine, but nothing to write home about.
Looking for a new pizza place and thought I'd try this, due to the reviews and the location being close by. The pizza was good but wasn't great. I liked the pepperoni, but the rest was just ok, but nothing negative.
Restaurantji Recommends
Awesome Pizza get to Sweet sauce
Always down to try a "new" pizza spot! I'm a huge fan of sweet sauce on pizza so I was very excited to order from Penny's. Honestly, everything about the pizza and wings we ordered was great. My only comment is that everything was super greasy; not a complaint, just something to point out! My medium wings were also a little overdone and chewy but my bf loved his hot wings. Everything was tasty and I'm excited to have another great option to go back to!
Highly recommend. So delicious, make sure you get the sweet sauce!
Best pizza in tonawanda
Quick services and friendly staff! Always a pleasure to order from them!