Romeo & Juliet's Cafeé & Bakery

1292 Hertel Ave, Buffalo
(716) 873-5730

Recent Reviews

Bernadette Dupre

Pizzas and cannoli are wonderful!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cannoli, Chocolate Bomb

Krista Berg

We always love the baked goods here, especially the cannoli!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Madeline Anderson-Balmer

Had a Galentines dinner here with 12 of us. Great options on the specials menu, fresh food, tasty, and the price is right. Some housemade pasta, delish cacciatore with super fresh veggies and sausage, and pastries basically anything you want. Highly recommend for a casual lunch or dinner. You'll have leftovers for sure! Yaaay!Vegetarian options: Gluten free and plenty of options for ovo lacto vegetarians for sure.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brie

Ruby M.

Meals and desserts are always fresh and meticulously prepared, even when ordering Delivery. Appreciate their consistency! Within a few short visits, they made a loyal customer of me. Highly recommend!

Danielle Little

I was wanted to chime in here about their doordash! And I have to say I’m just so impressed the pasta I ordered was wrapped with care and the slice of cake I ordered was done the same! I’ve never had any food or drink from this restaurant before and the pasta is absolutely delicious! They gave me a side of bread that was so freshly made that I couldn’t be happier with! 10/10 I will be visiting the locations! Because if it’s as good as the take out I’m a lifelong fan now

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cake by the Slice

l rive

Pretty good place to grab some food. Decor could use an update, but if you are not picky about that sort of thing, then give them a try.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

JeDi MaStEr

The staff was very helpful, they explained every dessert they had. I tried several of them and they were all excellent.I also had their pizza, and it was great too, with good crust and sauce.All together, this really was a great cafe.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mike H.

I've had a hankering for this for a while now. Back around 2000, I used to live around the corner and would go get the Quattro Formaggi for $5 special once a week. Well, I didn't feel like driving so we got DoorDash from Hertel Ave all the way to Sloan. Got my fav pizza and also we added a Margherita too and the whole family ate it for rhe next 2 days. Wasn't piping hot by the time it was delivered but that's not a short drive so the pics don't do it justice. Taste was awesome and I know they have some incredible desserts too. I've also been to the Sheridan Drive (near Evans) location and love their food & service as well. Highly recommended trying this place.

John T.

I just love the ambiance and authentic food here. Their dessert offerings are simply Devine. I'm also a lover of their expresso beverage.

Jessica P.

Decent place. Food was good, nothing blew my socks off, but I would eat here again. I thought panini was a bit bland and could use some pesto, mayo, something with sauce or a flavor boost. Pizza was okay and I enjoy the little cup-style pepperoni they use. Tiramisu is a lot heavier on the coffee flavor than I'm used to. I think the chocolate bombe was my favorite of the visit. Staff was friendly. Loved the decor, although the tables felt a bit cramped to me. I will likely return to try some of the other desserts - the stuff in the case looked very tempting.

Christine K.

Amazing food and very nice staff. I finally made it to the Williamsville location and stopped in for some delicious desserts. We tried the chocolate cake, the tiramisu and the peanut butter ganache. My favorite was easily the PB one, i could eat if every day all day. I stopped back for dinner to go( because why not?) and we got the red pepper dinner, risotto ball dinner , soup and kids spaghetti with meatballs. Everything was amazing and huge portions. The owner is very kind and helpful explaining the menu. We will definitely back and I'll be trying the pizza next as it smelled amazing! I wish I had pictures but we ate it all!

Becca

Literally heard an employee tell a delivery driver to stand behind a pilar so that the customers didn't have to look at them. Because he's not bringing in any business and nobody wants to look at them. Disgusting. I think my jaw went thru the ground. Never coming back here.

Susan Goldman

Went there a few weeks ago with a gift card. I was joined by a friend. I ordered a spinach salad that was supposed to come with avocados but I found none in it. I ordered the lobster ravioli and I'm pretty sure it was not real lobster. The sauce tasted fine though. The atmosphere was nice and we had no problem with the service. I have a little cash left on the gift card so I will try the bakery. Overall it was "meh".

Darlene Marcucci-Miller

Love this place. It gas become a retreat for me. Wonderful salads. Pastries to perfection with many yummy horses, family feel, pleasantly friendly service (feel like we are friends)...hospitality at its best. Haven't had one dish I couldn't rave over.

Shannon Mcginley

Went here after dinner hoping for an amazing dessert. Upon walking up to the door that stated the hours, closed at 9pm, the sign was flipped to closed. My sister and I walked in as others were walking out and I said are you open or closed. They said closed, at 8:46pm..needless to say we did not get dessert. Guess we are heading to Wegmans, what a disappointment.

Load More

Romeo & Juliet's Cafeé & Bakery

1292 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216
(716) 873-5730