Pizza Restaurants near Carthage

“Back in the day my family were customers at the original Stefano's. I remember Carthage before Stefano's was even around circa 1984. During a recent trip it was great to see the restaurant still open, it was quite the surprise. Stefano and his family were always the best, and the food was great then as it is now. I am looking forward to visiting again soon, hopefully I'll be able to get some of those pepperoni rolls.“

“We love having Stefano's in our community. With several locations around northern New York it's nice to have Stefano's Pizzeria just outside the gate of Fort Drum. They have a great sauce and crust. Try their garlic knots and I love to order my wings extra crispy.“

“Always amazing! Great pizza....Food was great..however I tried to call in an order and whoever..didn't kno the specials. Not much of an issue, drove to the store. Placed my order and It seemed as If there was a party in the back..everyone dancing and fxckin around and it took almost 30 mins for my pizza. Ga damn get ur lives together.“

“I can’t even begin to explain how much we loved this place! It was our first time but definitely won’t be our last! I was a little nervous when we parked, as I didn’t know if it would be appropriate for our 16 month old but they have kid menus and he loved it! We ordered the cheese curds, the sauce was so good! We also recommend the Mac and cheese bakes. We tried the original and BBQ pulled pork. We were NOT disappointed. Will definitely make the drive from Fort Drum to come here again!“

“It was very clean, lots of wood paneling and comfortable. We each had a wrap, chicken caesar and ranchero chicken. Caesar honestly had -too much- chicken to the ratio of salad, but otherwise tasty. Ranchero was good through and through. Fries are very delicious and plentiful. Onion rings were a little bland, but cooked well. If you dip them in anything you should be satisfied.“