13 Best American Restaurants near Cayuta

McClary's Ice Cream Stand American • $
6017-6019 NY-13 Scenic, Cayuta

“Prices are good. Ice cream selection isn't the biggest but enough to find something you'll like. There was only two people working at the time we where there. It was pretty busy and a good size line. However it did move at a good pace. Lots of seating. I got the Caribbean Sunday. Pretty good.“

4.9 Superb18 Reviews
On a Roll Sandwich Shop • $
6, Hanover Square, Horseheads - 10.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch
Philly Cheesesteak
Chicken Philly
Chicken Speidie
Salt Potatoes
Potato Salad
Italian Sub
Turkey Sub
Egg Salad
Steak Sub

“This is the BEST sub shop, hands down. The atmosphere is fantastic and the employees actually care about their customers. They take the time to get to know them, as soon as you walk in as a regular, they know your order. They ask about your family and have really good conversation while you're there. To top it off they make incredible food. The subs are packed full of fresh ingredients and you most definitely get more than your money's worth. They simply NEVER miss. 1000 out of 10 recommend. #Feedthe607“

4.8 Superb52 Reviews
Seabring Inn Bar & Grill • $
330 Sebring Rd, Newfield - 5.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Nashville Hot Chicken
Chicken Wings
Waffle Fries

“Food was great. Wings are naked, not a ton of sauce. Chicken parm seems like chicken fingers with sauce and cheese. Wife got the chicken ceasar salad. Place was busy, service was great. Very friendly staff and owner. Ambiance-it's a dive bar. A really great one!“

4.8 Superb29 Reviews
Bucket Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $
100 Church St, Odessa - 6.07 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Salad
Bacon Cheeseburger
French Fries
Buffalo Wings
Fish Fry

“Great Coffee shop...the owner makes great coffee, is a lot of fun, and the place is sheer community magic.“

4.8 Superb29 Reviews
The Diner Diner • $
59 Old Ithaca Rd, Horseheads - 9.85 miles

Customers` Favorites

Southwestern Omelette with Hash Browns and Bagel
2 Eggs with Corned Beef Hash
Sausage Egg and Fries
Stuffed French Toast
Country Fried Steak
Chicken Tenders
Scrambled Eggs
Breakfast Bowl
Steak and Eggs
Sausage Gravy

“Amazing Breakfast, nice wait staff!! Highly recommend sausage Gravy!!“

4.6 Superb80 Reviews
Sonny's Bar & Grille Bar & Grill • $$
49 Level Acres Dr, Horseheads - 8.63 miles

Customers` Favorites

Medium Chicken Wings
American Fries
Medium Wings
Quesadilla

“Really good food (Sonny's burger is absolutely in the top three in town, and the salads are good too), awesome service and such a great crowd. Live music twice a week!! Definitely, will be back. Opportunity for improvement? Every decoration comes from a distributor, oh well.“

4.7 Superb14 Reviews
Town Tavern Bar • $
1205 Breesport Rd, Erin - 6.97 miles

Customers` Favorites

Burger and Fries
Pizza
Wings

“I was there on a Wednesday evening, which is "Burger night". Coincidentally, I was in the mood for a burger! It's one of the best burgers I've had in a long time and the onion ring were excelent too! The place was busy but I was waited on quite fast, I felt. My order arrived soon after my beverage. I was quite pleased with the service and food. The atmosphere was quite typical for a bar and grill it seamed. Everyone was friendly.“

4.6 Superb21 Reviews
Rosar Grill Bar & Grill • $
114 John St, Horseheads - 10.16 miles

“really? this is listed as a restaurant? does rosar's even serve food? i was unaware. anyways, i love this place. awful, hilarious tunes on the jukebox, pool, video games and darts, and the cheapest beers in horseheads. the men's bathroom door says bears. did i mention this place is located next to a gun shop? i love horseheads. really busy on breaks from school (the only time i'm there, really) but kinda dead otherwise.“

4.4 Superb13 Reviews
Hamlet Delights American • $
103 Sayre St, Horseheads - 10.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Vegetable Fried Rice
Strawberry Shortcake
Hot and Sour Soup
Sesame Chicken
Wonton Soup

“Several locals said the Chinese food was good. They Lied, the Chinese is MID at best. I’m sure some of the other food is decent, but the chicken in the soup and salad tasted like a tasteless gummy worm. Aye and that red berry dressing is trash dawg.“

4.4 Superb43 Reviews
Nick's Pub And Grill Pubs • $
102 N Main St, Horseheads - 10.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheeseburger with Sweet Potato Fries
Philly Cheesesteak Wrap
Garlic Parmesan Wings
One Pound Burger
Summer Salad
Green Salad
Fish Fry
Hamburger
Nick

“My boyfriend and I stopped here driving through on a weekend trip. The service, food, and atmosphere were great. I had the blue cheeseburger, and he had the steakhouse burger. Both were terrific. Big burgers!! The onion rings were my favorite. Oh, and the homemade ranch dressing was fantastic. Highly recommend! ?“

4.4 Superb61 Reviews
Stoney's Casablanca Restaurant American • $
912 Chemung St, Horseheads - 11.16 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fridays Fish Fry of Haddock
Mozzarella Sticks
Tossed Salad
Sandwich

“Good food and friendly staff. Some of our orders were mixed up, but they quickly fixed it for us. Prices are competitive and worth it. Chairs we had at our table had the centers fallen, so I left with a sore back. Otherwise an excellent place for dinner or late lunch.“

4.3 Superb48 Reviews
Sugar & Spice Restaurant Breakfast • $
300 Watkins Rd, Horseheads - 10.01 miles

Customers` Favorites

Stuffed French Toast with Strawberries
Hot Chocolate with Whipped Cream
Pancakes or French Toast
Breakfast Quesadilla
Mini Potato Pancakes
Home Fried Potatoes
Strawberry Pancakes
Philly Omelette
Corn Beef Hash

“This may sound like I have an interest. but we moved to the area recently. I have to say this is the best family owned place I've been to. The service, speed and quality of food is always great regardless of the amount of people. I love this place my family comes to visit and they have to go there every time.“

4.2 Good55 Reviews
13

Beef's

Beef's Bar & Grill • $
203 W Franklin St, Horseheads - 10.17 miles

“Beefs was absolutely amazing before and is even better now under new ownership. The food is spectacular and you cannot beat the prices. The menu is very straightforward but anything you order will not disappoint you. Kristin who was running the kitchen made it a point to clarify our order while making it and Tammy stayed on top of anything else we needed. Don’t let the building itself fool you, this place is exceptional!“

4 Good29 Reviews