We ordered a double batch of fingers, half medium and half garlic parmigiana. They were burnt and the garlic parmigiana were medium with cheese sprinkled on them. When I called a spoke to manager about issue she kept repeating “well we back then the time the vendor tells us so I don’t know why they are burnt”. Literally argued with me and didn’t try to help. We have ordered from here a lot and I’m very disappointed. They lost my support and I won’t recommend to anyone anymore
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Shelly C.
Ordered 2 fish fry's. They were discussing. I tried fish, wasent bad but as my friend continued on we threw it all out. 2 hours later we were so sick. Vomiting and diarrhea. Don't eat. Run for your life..... literally
Mary An Witkowski
I live right down the street from them I'm so upset! This is the third time I've ordered from here and it's dog food. I ordered a turkey club there was no bacon and I paid for it, I couldn't even eat it and the pizza was disgusting too what a waste of almost $50 even picking it up! The last time we ordered the fish strip dinner it was undercooked and we couldn't eat that either. Never Again. Go to masters pizza they cost a little more but their better! Poplars chicken fingers are tiny not worth it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Sir Quentin
So I went here on my lunch break and I waited for a personal pizza. It took 20 minutes to make and I was late getting back to work but this is the best pizza in this area. OMG! It was worth it! Excellent Job Poplar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Shelly Cooper
I bought 2 fish fry's for me and my friend. We both got very sick from it. I called them and told them what happened. They laughed at me and hung up. My friend went to hospital because she was throwing up so much. Don't go there. It's a death sentence.
Marcia Litz
Rueben ‘Loafer’ …….amazing !
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sa D
I called Poplar Pizza to inquire about catering for a birthday party. Due to my hectic work schedule as a healthcare worker, the party was on a Sunday. The person who answered the phone said they usually don't do catering during Bills game Sundays, which is completely understandable, but since this was a morning Bills game (London) they could probably do it and would call me back. I never received a call back and spent days waiting. I think it's just very rude and not customer friendly to not even call me back. If you can't do the catering, just be honest and say so.
Service: 1
Sara D.
I called Poplar Pizza to inquire about catering for a birthday party. Due to my hectic work schedule as a healthcare worker, the party was on a Sunday. The person who answered the phone said they usually don't do catering during Bills game Sundays, which is completely understandable, but since this was a morning Bills game (London) they could probably do it and would call me back. I never received a call back and spent days waiting. I think it's just very rude and not customer friendly to not even call me back. If you can't do the catering, just be honest and say so.
Sara Loft
My boyfriend got one of their personal creations - a Loafer, chicken bacon ranch styled! It was incredible! He was only able to eat half. Each time I eat here, I'm always pleased! Thank you all!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Macaroni Salad, Wings, Fish, French Fries, Pizza
Dawn Dennahower
Great food love everything I have ordered from there favorite is the boneless
I used to really like this place but hate to say that they've started to really cut corners. My latest sub order had very little meat, and they seemed to try compensating for it by loading it up with shredded lettuce. The roll was also pretty stale. Luckily, it was toasted, so that brought it back a little. I just think when you make a sub, the meat should be the main ingredient, I got a salad on a bun.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Jennie P.
Well always order the fried chicken filet sub and the 4 piece chicken dinner. The sub is usually spot 0n..this time the chicken was over fried, close to burnt. The roll was dry and no mayo or oil as requested. The fries with the dinner were dry and way over cooked. Very disappointed
T-Bird 91
Good pizza, ordered wings crispy and came soggy. On a order of ten asked if could be split and for some reason guy said he couldn’t split 10 wings, math isn’t that hard.
Randy Polakiewicz
Worst Sub I ever had roll as hard as a brick went right in the garbage I wouldn’t even give it to my dog l will never order from them again to many other places to go
Food: 1
Leo Tills
Pizza was great. But the cook refused to make my wings the way I asked. I asked for them crispy. And when I wasn't done right they refused to correct it. Terrible service terrible attitude will not return.
We ordered a double batch of fingers, half medium and half garlic parmigiana. They were burnt and the garlic parmigiana were medium with cheese sprinkled on them. When I called a spoke to manager about issue she kept repeating “well we back then the time the vendor tells us so I don’t know why they are burnt”. Literally argued with me and didn’t try to help. We have ordered from here a lot and I’m very disappointed. They lost my support and I won’t recommend to anyone anymore
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Ordered 2 fish fry's. They were discussing. I tried fish, wasent bad but as my friend continued on we threw it all out. 2 hours later we were so sick. Vomiting and diarrhea. Don't eat. Run for your life..... literally
I live right down the street from them I'm so upset! This is the third time I've ordered from here and it's dog food. I ordered a turkey club there was no bacon and I paid for it, I couldn't even eat it and the pizza was disgusting too what a waste of almost $50 even picking it up! The last time we ordered the fish strip dinner it was undercooked and we couldn't eat that either. Never Again. Go to masters pizza they cost a little more but their better! Poplars chicken fingers are tiny not worth it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
So I went here on my lunch break and I waited for a personal pizza. It took 20 minutes to make and I was late getting back to work but this is the best pizza in this area. OMG! It was worth it! Excellent Job Poplar.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
I bought 2 fish fry's for me and my friend. We both got very sick from it. I called them and told them what happened. They laughed at me and hung up. My friend went to hospital because she was throwing up so much. Don't go there. It's a death sentence.
Rueben ‘Loafer’ …….amazing !
Food: 5
Service: 5
I called Poplar Pizza to inquire about catering for a birthday party. Due to my hectic work schedule as a healthcare worker, the party was on a Sunday. The person who answered the phone said they usually don't do catering during Bills game Sundays, which is completely understandable, but since this was a morning Bills game (London) they could probably do it and would call me back. I never received a call back and spent days waiting. I think it's just very rude and not customer friendly to not even call me back. If you can't do the catering, just be honest and say so.
Service: 1
I called Poplar Pizza to inquire about catering for a birthday party. Due to my hectic work schedule as a healthcare worker, the party was on a Sunday. The person who answered the phone said they usually don't do catering during Bills game Sundays, which is completely understandable, but since this was a morning Bills game (London) they could probably do it and would call me back. I never received a call back and spent days waiting. I think it's just very rude and not customer friendly to not even call me back. If you can't do the catering, just be honest and say so.
My boyfriend got one of their personal creations - a Loafer, chicken bacon ranch styled! It was incredible! He was only able to eat half. Each time I eat here, I'm always pleased! Thank you all!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Macaroni Salad, Wings, Fish, French Fries, Pizza
Great food love everything I have ordered from there favorite is the boneless
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I used to really like this place but hate to say that they've started to really cut corners. My latest sub order had very little meat, and they seemed to try compensating for it by loading it up with shredded lettuce. The roll was also pretty stale. Luckily, it was toasted, so that brought it back a little. I just think when you make a sub, the meat should be the main ingredient, I got a salad on a bun.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Well always order the fried chicken filet sub and the 4 piece chicken dinner. The sub is usually spot 0n..this time the chicken was over fried, close to burnt. The roll was dry and no mayo or oil as requested. The fries with the dinner were dry and way over cooked. Very disappointed
Good pizza, ordered wings crispy and came soggy. On a order of ten asked if could be split and for some reason guy said he couldn’t split 10 wings, math isn’t that hard.
Worst Sub I ever had roll as hard as a brick went right in the garbage I wouldn’t even give it to my dog l will never order from them again to many other places to go
Food: 1
Pizza was great. But the cook refused to make my wings the way I asked. I asked for them crispy. And when I wasn't done right they refused to correct it. Terrible service terrible attitude will not return.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1