Stopped by to eat Lunch. Had a buffalo chicken w ranch slice and a beef patty. The food wouldn’t digest and my buddy and I both got sick. Got food poisoning and it was not pleasant. Called back the next day and explained to one of the staff members that I was throwing up profusely, and heard him telling the other worker “throw out the meat.” So obviously something was wrong .
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mr F G And Mrs M S.
3.5 stars. We stopped by here for a late lunch. The place looks clean and the service was great. Our waiter were polite. The margherita pizza that we ordered were just decent but the gluten free pizza here were great! If you happen to live in the area, it's worth trying.
Greg Harris
Angelina’s is an absolute amazing Italian pizza based restaurant located in Cold Spring, New York.In September of 2023, I brought and treated my wife and myself for dinner at Angelina and we thoroughly enjoyed our dining experience!!!The restaurant’s staff warmly welcomed us when we arrived and we were quickly provided with a table.Both my wife and I found our pizza entree meal to be well cooked, perfectly cooked and unquestionably delicious!!! We are huge fans of pizza and we consider Angelina’s pizza among the best we’ve ever had!!!When visiting Cold Spring, New York we definitely encourage everyone to visit and dine at Angelina’s. You’ll be guaranteed to have a great dining experience and will certainly love their delicious pizza!!!Parking: Plenty of parking.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza from Mars
Ed O.
Pizza is a lil heavy on the cheese n light on the char- which makes it soft with no crunch. Sauce is very good. I'd prefer it baked a lil more but it's not a bad slice at all. For some, it might just be the perfect slice- especially if you like it cheesy n a lil pillowy. Large selection, clean, nice staff- good spot.
Kien Huynh
My friends and I were out of town visiting Cold Spring and randomly found this place. We love it! We ordered a half and half pizza with Meat lover & Pizza from Mars toppings and I really love the Pizza from Mars. We also had the Mozzarella Caprese and it was fresh. The Farfallel Al Mascarpone was fantastic! One of my friends, who is not fond of Italian food, said that he really likes the Farfalle. The staff was super nice as well. Would recommend!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza from Mars
Greg A.
Good service at this clean neighborhood pizzeria joint. Place is small but they crank out this crispy pizza with great toppings. I also saw other diners eating fried chicken and juicy large hamburgers with fresh tomatoes.
abhilash patni
Amazing cheese and grandma slice
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Lili Marin
Sala pizza- grilled vegetables
Arta B
This place is a hit or miss for me. Super inconsistent.Sometime it’s under seasoned and other times it’s over.I had a pepperoni slice today and the pepperoni tasted bad ! And smelled bad.Took a bit and left the rest. As I through it away I told the guy the pepperoni tastes really bad.. and all he said was “ OK”.Never again.Also paid 10 bucks for 5 mozzarella sticksOver pricedAdding : a slice of cheese cake was $7.50! I can get a whole cake at food time for 10! NO THANKS was over priced and price change all the time.Replay ; no thanks I’ll try cold spring pizza instead !
A Bajramaj
This place is a hit or miss for me. Super inconsistent.Sometime it’s under seasoned and other times it’s over.I had a pepperoni slice today and the pepperoni tasted bad ! And smelled bad.Took a bit and left the rest. As I through it away I told the guy the pepperoni tastes really bad.. and all he said was “ OK”.Never again.Also paid 10 bucks for 5 mozzarella sticksOver pricedAdding : a slice of cheese cake was $7.50! I can get a whole cake at food time for 10! NO THANKS was over priced and price change all the time.Replay ; no thanks I’ll try cold spring pizza instead !
We wanted to have dinner at Murphy’s but their kitchen closed at 8pm on a Saturday night, so on a whim we drove here. Smartest decision ever!I had the beet salad. Delicious! My friend had the Chicken Marsala. Delicious! The pizza was okay. The wait staff were very friendly. I’d look forward to many future meals here. Thank you Murphy’s for closing your kitchen so early!
Alena Taggart
I am a cold spring resident and I went to Angelina’s for dinner and ordered 4 slices of pizza(to go) from the display shelf, my pizza tasted awful and was not warmed up at all, 20$ is too much to not even have it hot and to taste below average is too much much. I can not recommend you eat here, please avoid at all costs.
Joseph Osborne
Loved the calzone and friendly staff.
Lyndsie L.
Got a buffalo slice and was disappointed. Had NO flavor what so ever. Great crispy pizza for sure but sauce had zero flavor so i was disappointed. Inside was super cute though and staff was friendly.
Mellisa Sanders
The taco pizza is absolutely delicious! The crust is crispy because of the brick oven. Garlic knots are yummy. So are the burgers!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Sticks, Burger with Bacon Cheddar and Sauteed Onions, Beef Pattys
Stopped by to eat Lunch. Had a buffalo chicken w ranch slice and a beef patty. The food wouldn’t digest and my buddy and I both got sick. Got food poisoning and it was not pleasant. Called back the next day and explained to one of the staff members that I was throwing up profusely, and heard him telling the other worker “throw out the meat.” So obviously something was wrong .
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
3.5 stars. We stopped by here for a late lunch. The place looks clean and the service was great. Our waiter were polite. The margherita pizza that we ordered were just decent but the gluten free pizza here were great! If you happen to live in the area, it's worth trying.
Angelina’s is an absolute amazing Italian pizza based restaurant located in Cold Spring, New York.In September of 2023, I brought and treated my wife and myself for dinner at Angelina and we thoroughly enjoyed our dining experience!!!The restaurant’s staff warmly welcomed us when we arrived and we were quickly provided with a table.Both my wife and I found our pizza entree meal to be well cooked, perfectly cooked and unquestionably delicious!!! We are huge fans of pizza and we consider Angelina’s pizza among the best we’ve ever had!!!When visiting Cold Spring, New York we definitely encourage everyone to visit and dine at Angelina’s. You’ll be guaranteed to have a great dining experience and will certainly love their delicious pizza!!!Parking: Plenty of parking.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza from Mars
Pizza is a lil heavy on the cheese n light on the char- which makes it soft with no crunch. Sauce is very good. I'd prefer it baked a lil more but it's not a bad slice at all. For some, it might just be the perfect slice- especially if you like it cheesy n a lil pillowy. Large selection, clean, nice staff- good spot.
My friends and I were out of town visiting Cold Spring and randomly found this place. We love it! We ordered a half and half pizza with Meat lover & Pizza from Mars toppings and I really love the Pizza from Mars. We also had the Mozzarella Caprese and it was fresh. The Farfallel Al Mascarpone was fantastic! One of my friends, who is not fond of Italian food, said that he really likes the Farfalle. The staff was super nice as well. Would recommend!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza from Mars
Good service at this clean neighborhood pizzeria joint. Place is small but they crank out this crispy pizza with great toppings. I also saw other diners eating fried chicken and juicy large hamburgers with fresh tomatoes.
Amazing cheese and grandma slice
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Sala pizza- grilled vegetables
This place is a hit or miss for me. Super inconsistent.Sometime it’s under seasoned and other times it’s over.I had a pepperoni slice today and the pepperoni tasted bad ! And smelled bad.Took a bit and left the rest. As I through it away I told the guy the pepperoni tastes really bad.. and all he said was “ OK”.Never again.Also paid 10 bucks for 5 mozzarella sticksOver pricedAdding : a slice of cheese cake was $7.50! I can get a whole cake at food time for 10! NO THANKS was over priced and price change all the time.Replay ; no thanks I’ll try cold spring pizza instead !
This place is a hit or miss for me. Super inconsistent.Sometime it’s under seasoned and other times it’s over.I had a pepperoni slice today and the pepperoni tasted bad ! And smelled bad.Took a bit and left the rest. As I through it away I told the guy the pepperoni tastes really bad.. and all he said was “ OK”.Never again.Also paid 10 bucks for 5 mozzarella sticksOver pricedAdding : a slice of cheese cake was $7.50! I can get a whole cake at food time for 10! NO THANKS was over priced and price change all the time.Replay ; no thanks I’ll try cold spring pizza instead !
Restaurantji Recommends
We wanted to have dinner at Murphy’s but their kitchen closed at 8pm on a Saturday night, so on a whim we drove here. Smartest decision ever!I had the beet salad. Delicious! My friend had the Chicken Marsala. Delicious! The pizza was okay. The wait staff were very friendly. I’d look forward to many future meals here. Thank you Murphy’s for closing your kitchen so early!
I am a cold spring resident and I went to Angelina’s for dinner and ordered 4 slices of pizza(to go) from the display shelf, my pizza tasted awful and was not warmed up at all, 20$ is too much to not even have it hot and to taste below average is too much much. I can not recommend you eat here, please avoid at all costs.
Loved the calzone and friendly staff.
Got a buffalo slice and was disappointed. Had NO flavor what so ever. Great crispy pizza for sure but sauce had zero flavor so i was disappointed. Inside was super cute though and staff was friendly.
The taco pizza is absolutely delicious! The crust is crispy because of the brick oven. Garlic knots are yummy. So are the burgers!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Mozzarella Sticks, Burger with Bacon Cheddar and Sauteed Onions, Beef Pattys