You are not going to find a better price for the quality of food served. Additionally, the wait staff is unbeatable - extremely friendly and always attentive. I can say always because we have become regulars here and have never ever been let down no matter the night or time of day. We have probably eaten here 25 plus times and will continue to be regulars here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nathaniel Sietz
Ordered from Doordash at 1:10PM, order didnt arrive until 2:25PM. To wait over an hour for two slices of pizza is a bit ridiculous.
Anne Panzica
Pene pasta with chicken vodka sauce was very good. The portion is enough for 2.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Francine Seaman
The food was delicious (I drove past many establishments to spend my $$ there) however the deportment/attitudes of the guys behind the counter (on 3 separate occasions between July and October '23) were not welcoming at all (I'm big on Customer Service and rarely complain (was a C/S Manager for many years). Tried a 3rd time as I wanted my family/friends visiting from Las Vegas and Maryland to have "real New York pizza") however experienced the same uncool attitudes (my family noticed it also) hence I'll definitely forgo Gino's of Commack in the future and if that was their intent then mission accomplished Grumps.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Sal Pizzurro
Just had 2 Delicious Cheese Pizza Pies delivered to my office. Everyone loves it and the delivery went smoothly and the delivery gentleman couldn't have been nicer. Pizza is classic, great cheese crust, and flavorful sauce with actual basil as well. Yummy!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Valerie Fiesel
Ordered Pollo Panini- very thin piece of chicken with barely a taste of very thin mozzarella and about 3 tiny pieces of roasted pepper on a round flour tortilla, folded in half and flattened out some more by a grille. Don't buy it !!!!
Food: 1
Courtney Fahn
Only have gone for lunch, but the food is so good, & counter help is always so genuinely nice. Lunch specials are totally worth it. Salad is so fresh, soup is fantastic, pizza is great. Always a great experience.
Just love it hereTheir pasta/chicken night specials are incredible. Pizza is always on point and service is outstanding.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fatoma R.
I've been here for both a sit down meal and pick up- happy with both! The inside has a lot of sitting space so if you want to do a nice family style meal this is a good spot- the servings are also very fair so it's perfect to pick different things and share. Their pastas and salads are delicious and of course their pizza is amazing! My go to is the margarita slide but their regular pie and vodka slice are also delicious!
Gerry Ganz
Best vodka chicken roll to date. Good food all
Food: 5
Service: 5
TheFiveRoadTrippers
This pizzeria is in a very good location with other stores including Trader Joe's. Their decor is upscale with pizza in the front and a full service restaurant, off to the side. I ordered the chicken caesar square slice and the bbq chicken slice. The caesar had a great, creamy, dressing. There was plenty of chicken on top. The bbq chicken slice had a sweet, semi smoky flavor. There was plenty of chicken and fried red onion strings. Both slices were delicious and priced right for lunch. There are many pizzerias going by the name "Gino's" on Long Island. This one is the real deal for great pizza!
Marlene B.
I ordered a vegan pizza pie and was charged $33.00! Highway robbery! I will be going Mario's next time because their prices for a vegan pie is a lot less.
Since moving into the area two years ago, Gino’s has been our favorite food spot where we dine weekly. Excellent food and customer service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sauce, Grandma, Italian, Grandma Pizza Slices, Pie, Chicken Parm
Great pizza and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
?Wheelchair accessibility: ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Veal Chop, Chicken Parm
You are not going to find a better price for the quality of food served. Additionally, the wait staff is unbeatable - extremely friendly and always attentive. I can say always because we have become regulars here and have never ever been let down no matter the night or time of day. We have probably eaten here 25 plus times and will continue to be regulars here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered from Doordash at 1:10PM, order didnt arrive until 2:25PM. To wait over an hour for two slices of pizza is a bit ridiculous.
Pene pasta with chicken vodka sauce was very good. The portion is enough for 2.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
The food was delicious (I drove past many establishments to spend my $$ there) however the deportment/attitudes of the guys behind the counter (on 3 separate occasions between July and October '23) were not welcoming at all (I'm big on Customer Service and rarely complain (was a C/S Manager for many years). Tried a 3rd time as I wanted my family/friends visiting from Las Vegas and Maryland to have "real New York pizza") however experienced the same uncool attitudes (my family noticed it also) hence I'll definitely forgo Gino's of Commack in the future and if that was their intent then mission accomplished Grumps.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Just had 2 Delicious Cheese Pizza Pies delivered to my office. Everyone loves it and the delivery went smoothly and the delivery gentleman couldn't have been nicer. Pizza is classic, great cheese crust, and flavorful sauce with actual basil as well. Yummy!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered Pollo Panini- very thin piece of chicken with barely a taste of very thin mozzarella and about 3 tiny pieces of roasted pepper on a round flour tortilla, folded in half and flattened out some more by a grille. Don't buy it !!!!
Food: 1
Only have gone for lunch, but the food is so good, & counter help is always so genuinely nice. Lunch specials are totally worth it. Salad is so fresh, soup is fantastic, pizza is great. Always a great experience.
Restaurantji Recommends
Just love it hereTheir pasta/chicken night specials are incredible. Pizza is always on point and service is outstanding.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've been here for both a sit down meal and pick up- happy with both! The inside has a lot of sitting space so if you want to do a nice family style meal this is a good spot- the servings are also very fair so it's perfect to pick different things and share. Their pastas and salads are delicious and of course their pizza is amazing! My go to is the margarita slide but their regular pie and vodka slice are also delicious!
Best vodka chicken roll to date. Good food all
Food: 5
Service: 5
This pizzeria is in a very good location with other stores including Trader Joe's. Their decor is upscale with pizza in the front and a full service restaurant, off to the side. I ordered the chicken caesar square slice and the bbq chicken slice. The caesar had a great, creamy, dressing. There was plenty of chicken on top. The bbq chicken slice had a sweet, semi smoky flavor. There was plenty of chicken and fried red onion strings. Both slices were delicious and priced right for lunch. There are many pizzerias going by the name "Gino's" on Long Island. This one is the real deal for great pizza!
I ordered a vegan pizza pie and was charged $33.00! Highway robbery! I will be going Mario's next time because their prices for a vegan pie is a lot less.