Original Brooklyn Pizzeria & Restaurant

100 Jericho Turnpike, Commack
(631) 864-9212

Recent Reviews

Sonora E.

0 stars!! Gross it's to say the least! $9 2 slices people ?! And tasted old!! Nasty!! If you go inside look at the pies laying there.. they look like they were made by children! How the heck are these people in business? I'm 100% Italian trust me on this review! Save your money and go elsewhere ! Worst than Dominos!!!

Kevin Welsh

Got a pie and baked ziti to go. Delicious. Highly recommend!!!!

Food: 5

S P

A simple neighborhood slice shop with nice owners. Very yummy pizza and the cannoli are awesome. Chicken roll was so tasty.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Roll, Pizza, Garlic Knots

Bruce Kurtz

Absolutely disgusting inside. The pizza is gross. And everything is empty. This place used to be great, but went very far downhill. Pretty sad. Definitely avoid this pizza restaurant, there are MUCHHH better and more pizzerias on Long Island (and Brooklyn).

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Anton Posner

Great pizza and service. Had a problem with a delivery and they are replacing it immediately. Great way to treat customers.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

mr. tobay

no common sense this placedoodoo

Steveo The Great

The store counter is basically empty.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 3

Scott Peabody

Great Brooklyn style pizza. Paul and Sal are great and I love their house special pie. After Dinapolis in Kings Park closed I tried 8 other places and this was best. Consistently

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Will Thomas

Today 10/1 - Nobody there, not busy and they give me a burned up leftover take out pie. Very disapointed. C'mon, we're not stupid. I've ordered there before. Now I remember why we stopped going there....

Food: 1

Service: 5

Moses Mejia

Love the food, great service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Francese, Chicken Marsala, Chicken Roll, Pizza

Brian M

Be warned - the prices have gotten absolutely outrageous. I stopped in for some specialty slices to go. I was charged $37 for 5 slices. I had to do a double take and ask if that was correct because I couldn’t fathom over $7 a slice when every other place is around $5.Been coming here for over 15 years but this is crazy. It’s a real shame because their pizza is good.

Hanna M.

My family has been going here for 10+ years and the food has always been excellent! Everyone is always so friendly, the food is always ready on time, and is always hot! One of my favorite things to get is their Caesar salad or their stuffed garlic knots, delicious!

Michael Arocho

I paid almost $17 for two slices, a can of soda and a pepperoni pinwheel. That’s on average over $4 for each item. The pizza was definitely not worth it.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Bill Corbett

I feel like there’s a different rating scale for pizza outside of the city. This isn’t good. Nothing stood out. Not the cheese, the sauce and definitely not the barely cooked dough. The dough was stretched thin, but the pizza just flopped because it wasn’t cooked long enough.I know I’ve been spoiled, but is there really no halfway decent pizza out here?!?!

Joyce C.

thanks for putting the pizza together...too bad. you forgot to cook it.... this place used to be good.....so inconsistent. Father And son let this go in a box.

Load More

Original Brooklyn Pizzeria & Restaurant

100 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY 11725
(631) 864-9212