Frosty's Ice Cream

2424 George Urban Blvd, Depew
(716) 697-1812

Recent Reviews

Ash G

Friendly and fast! Even on the last day of the season which I'm sure has its challenges.

Ashley Fuller

Friendly and fast! Even on the last day of the season which I'm sure has its challenges.

Colleen Brzyski

Coconut with chocolate dip.....tastes just like a Mounds bar.

Peggy Pozzuto

I've been to both locations. Love the vegan options! Always incredible service. My husband got this amazing cannoli sundae. Almost too pretty to eat.

Joseph O

Ice cream nachos are a unique offering, but unfortunately a bit of a one trick pony. They only take cash, which, in 2023, is a complete inconvenience and joke. They do provide an ATM right next to the store, which no doubt they get a cut of. Seriously, just raise your prices by 2.5% - 3%.Got a sundae with marshmallow and whipped cream and it was a small drizzle of marshmallow and three small puffs of cream. Could you spare it?It’s all Perry’s ice cream, so nothing unique that I saw. Seemed rather over staffed for the speed that we received our order.

Brenda Prigg

Very nice place fast service. Excellent vegan icecream

Olivia Dyet

The cookie dough blizzard is so good ice cream

Jessica King

Just picked up a birthday ice cream cake for my husband and it's perfect! The staff there was super nice and even let me come back with my gift certificate that I forgot and refunded me the money. Will be using them again for custom ice cream cakes!

Shawn White

Before completing this rating I visited this location at least 3x. I normally go during the week lunch hour but I went today on a Sunday around 430pm.Pros: There is a lot of flavor options to choose fromCons: cash only business, the service is not always consistent. This last time the child cashier was rude. She was pleasant to the other people that were not a minority so for that I will never go back.

Kyra Udziela

Ice. Cream. Nachos.Genius. I wanted to order 6 more! My wife also got a cereal milk soft serve and it was so spot on. Staff was super friendly and quick. Definitely coming back!

Sandy Spear

So many fun ideas and flavors! Their prices are very reasonable. They only take cash but do have an atm!

Paul Urban

Great ice cream at great prices and you don't need to buy a large cause the portions are huge. Will definitely be going back

Dave Mcmasters

They have a huge variety of ice cream flavors and other desserts that you can order. Like the ice cream nachos or cannoli nachos

Donna Wlosinski

Had a tropical treat with soft serve vanilla ice cream it had a juice of orange pineapple and mango poured over it and topped with whipped cream and a cherry very interesting ate some ice cream then had some of the juice my daughter had a baby cone of vanilla ice cream with sprinkles what a baby! They have so many things to choose from have to visit again to try something different

Brandon G.

This time I had to go with the ice cream nachos! I love this idea. I opted for vanilla ice cream, rainbow sprinkles and strawberry topping. Each order comes with a bunch of waffle cone style chips that you can use for your vessel to deliver your nacho toppings. I love this concept and what makes it even better is how customizable it is. You can opt for any of their soft serve and any of their toppings including the cheesecake bites! And then when you run out of chips, you can grab a spoon and still have a little sundae to eat!Service is always fast here even if a line looks super long. They are so fast at getting people's orders out and moving the line along here. I only waited a couple of minutes. Frosty's does it again with a cool idea and great ice cream!

Load More