Restaurants near Earlville

“I contacted the owners of Poolville Country Store to host a 40th surprise birthday celebration for my daughter. I definitely made the right decision choosing this restaurant! From planning the menu to helping facilitate secret guest parking, every detail was taken care of. The place is beautiful with tons of old world charm. Our service was excellent and food was absolutely OUTSTANDING!! Thank you Poolville County Store for making our special evening magical.”

“Well the weather was superb as we dined outside listening to the talented Liz Fiddle!The menu was brief yet offered small plates, sandwiches and comfy sides. Brisket nachos, best chicken sandwich finished with a fresh local baked roll/bread. Extensive beer list of course, and the wine minimal but enjoyable. After feeling full and happy with Liz to boot….we stood by the lake and captured on our phones the best sunset pics. Yes go here …great beer, tasty comforting food, existential views, and the kindest of service.”

“Super good. The menu selection is wonderful, the food is wonderful, and the hosts are wonderful. Who could ask for anything more!”

“I love this local coffee shop in Hamilton! The coffee is flavorful and always perfect! The last time we were there, my husband and I ordered breakfast sandwiches! They were made to order and delicious! They were also accompanied with a unique choice of sides. I had the overnight oats. You have the option of seating inside or outside. The only downside was the wait for our order, but it was well worth the wait!”

“Really cute little store/deli that serves the Hamilton area and Colgate. Was highly recommended on a student tour. Had a great veggie burger, good sandwiches, a soup of the day. Nice selection of take out beers. Perfect for picnic or students on the run. A few tables to eat in. Good!”

“We go here every year in June and August. Forget any negative reviews left by ignorant fools. This restaurant has the best wait staff and service. The warm setting and wonderful charm of this historic building is simply enchanting. The food is divine, never once in all years we've eaten at the Landmark have we ever had a negative experience. The prices are very reasonable when you consider the quality of the ingredients and the skill of the chef and their staff in preparing each dish to order. So long as the landmark is open and I am alive, I will always eat their when I'm in town.”

“Very friendly environment. The owner is very talkative and friendly, and the patrons are the same way. The food is amazing, great burgers and good prices. Place looks very clean, bathrooms are clean and stocked. Will be back!”

“Everything here is delicious! We drive 45 minutes just for their baked goods. The only "bad" thing I would say is that it's ALWAYS packed. Maybe open a second register?”

“Cute and Cozy diner. Was my first time going to a diner alone. Very Friendly/attentive/warm workers! Offered coffee promptly first thing and again before I left. Delicious food! I was in the ER last night and had a terrible day yesterday/barely ate yesterday. This place perked me up with a good start to today. yummy cooked food and kind servers. Thank you Judy’s coffee shop. ”

“One of my favorite places they have ice cream year round lots of different flavors they have really good food I always get burger and fries if I get food. They also have a drive thru. 10/ 10 ”

“An adorable little candy and ice cream store. The service is good even when busy. The chocolates are delicious, but my fam's fave is their milkshakes. Would definitely recommend trying them if you are in the neighborhood. Thank you for the wonderful service.”

“The Hamilton Inn and its employees were so accommodating, helpful, and supportive. We had a four night stay in January relayed to a family funeral, and they could not have been more sympathetic. This is a gem of a place to stay in a geographic area with few options. The service is remarkable, and the rooms cozy.”

“Stopped at Seven Oaks for lunch. The soup of the day was NE clam chowder. It was outstanding! Never had better! Also had the Phuket chicken wrap which was delicious. Prices were moderate and the dining area was very well done. I highly recommend,”

“Loved everything about this place. Warm welcoming staff, delicious fresh food & Travis, our server bartender was a doll. We're gonna drive the 45 minutes to Hamilton to hang out here sometime on the weekend when Travis works! ”

“Loved our waiting... he was very welcoming and had us laughing. He was very attentive to our table as well as other tables. Food was really good too... loved the homemade cornbread hash”

“We went to the Roadside inn last night for Prime Rib dinner. Not only was it delicious and perfectly cooked but our waitress Amanda, was amazing. She was so sweet, and provided great service. We love great food and great service!”

“Ended up here because everything else in Hamilton was closed between Christmas and New Year. We were so glad it was open, and the food was delicious! There were 4 of us, each ordered something different, and everyone devoured their meal. Highly recommend!”

“Ive been coming to this place for almost 2 years and let me say this is hands down the best school dining option at colgate university. One full moon night i went to Donnies and got a quesadilla with wings but the quesadilla tasted like a tortellini. The small wooden boxes that they put our food in needs to GO. There is no space in them to fit multiple different foods. The customer service is MAGICAL. GRETA IS A PRINCESS QUEEN. One day i saw a worker with glitter under their eyes dressed as a mermaid...i didn't question it because wow fashion. Donnies is very very spacious and sometimes they hold events which is pretty cool. Having a unlimited meal plan is amazing because it stops my bank account dropping like a submarine. There are so many food options at Donnies. This is truly the best place to get late night food (also the only place). YOU BETTER GO!!!”

“I just ordered four of Lewis’ stuffed shells dinners for the family, and those are the best stuffed shells I have had in years. The portions of salad, bread, and shells are large, and you just can’t beat the price. I will definitely be back! That was an excellent meal, and I do not know how one meal couldn’t more than fill a person to the brim, leaving leftovers. Two thumbs up and five stars!”

“Healthy food made to the highest standards with delicious cookies and muffins as well. It's a peaceful place where students can come get something to eat or drink and then sit at tables that allow for studying or simply talking with friends. The option for outdoor dining is also available. Set on the 5th floor of the campus library the views are stunning.”

“Great service, so long as you are polite. Prices are average for a bar, $10 minimum for a card. They don't sell food but they welcome you to bring food from the nearby restaurants. Really a great bar for the area, and the service is fantastic.”

“Great wings with just the right amount of crisp, not soggy and chewy, and not fried to a crisp - just right and medium of delicious, even for the spice wimps like me. Slight kick, but not enough to break a sweat. The pizza is pretty good, too! I ordered two days in a row, and the second day, I asked for it to be left in for an extra 2-3min and it was PERFECT! Crispy bottom that stood straight out, and gooey cheese oozing all over. It was like a taste of home made by friendly, hard-working people.”

“Slice review.. first of all I wish I had brought my camera inside. I enjoy seeing real plants inside restaurants. Great to see them propagating them there too. The service was nice and quick. The slice had the right amount of cheese on it. I say this about a lot of slices is I would of liked some more sauce on it but the flavor was on point. Enjoyed it and would stop again.”

“It's my goal to try out all the pizza places in Central NY. Oliveri's is a stand out - friendly staff and a warm little cozy place probably does a lot of business in takeout. They do a good crust here - crispy thinner crust is key. Sauce and cheese are decent too. I will return. Prices are the fairest I have seen in the area.”

“I rarely have time to get anywhere for food before it closes when Im headed to my night shift job. Here, I am able to order my sub online and have it waiting for me even after they've closed. Very thankful for the option and it's always delicious 😋”

“Great Food, I used to work there and I have to say, the service is great, great workers that are relatable and a great atmosphere with nice areas to sit and enjoy your food. The place has multiple areas where it's quiet so students can do their work. The food layout in the Buffett itself is nearly immaculate with the only exception being the events which can be slightly clunky, but other than that it's fine. The only thing that kept me from working and staying there is that I myself, left for college this year. Sure the selection of food isn't all "fan favorites", but with a grill that lets people get burgers, omelettes, fries, grilled cheese, among other things and a pizza station that always offers something for everyone, a build your own pasta section, a deli, and a vegan area that includes a gluten-free section which is a nice touch. It includes a coffee station, fruit area, ice cream area, it's hard to say what there isn't to like at this facility. I would highly recommend it if you are thinking about dinning here because it functions as a restaurant as well.-Chas Frink”

“Came out here on business, afterward got a drink. It's one of the freshest golden chilled beers I've had on draft; very fancy style wooden bar. Great bar tender & staff. ?”

“This is the only pho available for an hour around. If you are expecting pho on par with that from a major city like NYC or LA, you will be disappointed. There is no basil, bean sprouts, etc, and the meat portions are small. However that being said, it still satisfied my craving for pho, and the owners are very nice and ”

“Place seems clean. Staff member was pleasant, friendly and helpful. Great service.Kid-friendliness: The person making the sandwiches overheard that one child wanted a grilled cheese sandwich and she offered to make one for us so we didn't need to make another stop somewhere else. Great service”