Anthony’s is your average Italian take out place. The food isn’t any better or worse than you’d expect from a take out place, and while the prices are a little high, they do give you a portion that can feed an army. It might not be my “go to” place, but in a pinch, it’ll do just fine.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Terrance T.
All your favorite local, New York pizza place favorites done extremely well at an affordable price made by your friendly neighborhood pizza man. This place is always good and never disappoints.
Liv L.
Fantastic! This place is on a side street in East Rockaway. Staff is extremely kind, food is fresh and delicious!! Very easy to order quickly and be in and out. Ambiance is very nice, friendly, warm, and welcoming!! Will be back!!
Cody Hirashima
Edgar is the best and knows his pizza, we love the mild wings and recently got hooked on The Boss pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Garlic Knots
Ron Gravato
Edgar is a very friendly person. He makes the experience like eating over your uncles home.
Jared S.
I picked up 3 large pies, 2 sodas and 2 orders of garlic knots yesterday for an event and was blown away by both the service and the quality! Seriously, it's no wonder they have such a great rating. The spinach was some of the best spinach pizza I've had (and I've had a lot!) and the garlic knots were an interesting and appreciated take on the usual shape. They were more mini garlic knots, but tasted super garlicy and delicious! Next time, I'll be dining in for sure!
Cha Da N.
Whoever gave this place 5 stars should be slapped in the mouth with a long pepperoni to wake up those sleeping tastebuds. This was the worst slice of pizza I've ever had, hands down. The crust was chewy, the cheese was like imitation Kraft. The only good thing was the price. 2 slices for $5.50, it's hard to beat that. Quality on the other hand, well let's just say, if your ever riding around East Rockaway, and you here something that sounds like an extra mud flap underneath your bumper. I just might be the half eaten slice that I tossed out the window.
Isabel A.
I've been going to this place for over 15 years. The chicken roll is the best I've ever had! The plain pizza is also really good by the slice. The service is so quick and the staff is so kind.
Samantha Dobbins
Always delicious pizza!
Sunny C.
Reminds me of elementary school pizza days. Service is great here. It's easy to find street parking. Their chicken roll and spinach roll are great and only $3.75. Great prices, fast service, and good food. There's a few small tables inside if you want to dine in.
Pleasant atmosphere. People serving are nice . Food is good! Hello Edgar!
Shanna M
It was good
Miguel Cruz
First time walking in, ordered a Regular slice and sausage slice (which I haven't had in a while). Very Thin dough , no burnt edges. The cheese was predominat without the grease. The sausage slice, same. No Heavy grease thin dough great cheese. Would like to come in for a burger Next.
Barrett Blackwell
We had an extraordinary time at this restaurant. We loved the fantastic vibes and the food. The waiters are very affable. I am happy we eventually decided to try this place.
paula stackhouse
I wasn't ready for how amazing the pizza would taste. OMG best pizza! Great atmosphere!
Anthony’s is your average Italian take out place. The food isn’t any better or worse than you’d expect from a take out place, and while the prices are a little high, they do give you a portion that can feed an army. It might not be my “go to” place, but in a pinch, it’ll do just fine.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
All your favorite local, New York pizza place favorites done extremely well at an affordable price made by your friendly neighborhood pizza man. This place is always good and never disappoints.
Fantastic! This place is on a side street in East Rockaway. Staff is extremely kind, food is fresh and delicious!! Very easy to order quickly and be in and out. Ambiance is very nice, friendly, warm, and welcoming!! Will be back!!
Edgar is the best and knows his pizza, we love the mild wings and recently got hooked on The Boss pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Garlic Knots
Edgar is a very friendly person. He makes the experience like eating over your uncles home.
I picked up 3 large pies, 2 sodas and 2 orders of garlic knots yesterday for an event and was blown away by both the service and the quality! Seriously, it's no wonder they have such a great rating. The spinach was some of the best spinach pizza I've had (and I've had a lot!) and the garlic knots were an interesting and appreciated take on the usual shape. They were more mini garlic knots, but tasted super garlicy and delicious! Next time, I'll be dining in for sure!
Whoever gave this place 5 stars should be slapped in the mouth with a long pepperoni to wake up those sleeping tastebuds. This was the worst slice of pizza I've ever had, hands down. The crust was chewy, the cheese was like imitation Kraft. The only good thing was the price. 2 slices for $5.50, it's hard to beat that. Quality on the other hand, well let's just say, if your ever riding around East Rockaway, and you here something that sounds like an extra mud flap underneath your bumper. I just might be the half eaten slice that I tossed out the window.
I've been going to this place for over 15 years. The chicken roll is the best I've ever had! The plain pizza is also really good by the slice. The service is so quick and the staff is so kind.
Always delicious pizza!
Reminds me of elementary school pizza days. Service is great here. It's easy to find street parking. Their chicken roll and spinach roll are great and only $3.75. Great prices, fast service, and good food. There's a few small tables inside if you want to dine in.
Restaurantji Recommends
Pleasant atmosphere. People serving are nice . Food is good! Hello Edgar!
It was good
First time walking in, ordered a Regular slice and sausage slice (which I haven't had in a while). Very Thin dough , no burnt edges. The cheese was predominat without the grease. The sausage slice, same. No Heavy grease thin dough great cheese. Would like to come in for a burger Next.
We had an extraordinary time at this restaurant. We loved the fantastic vibes and the food. The waiters are very affable. I am happy we eventually decided to try this place.
I wasn't ready for how amazing the pizza would taste. OMG best pizza! Great atmosphere!